Positive Stereotypes Are Hurtful Too Analysis

Improved Essays
In America, there are different cultures, religious, and languages in our community, and these elements form diversity. Having varies of diversity bring colors into our community, but it also create conflict within different groups. In Grace Hsiang’s essay ““FOBs” VS. “TWINKIES”: The New Discrimination Is Interracial”, the author discusses about the cultural conflict within the same ethnicity, and she points out people can avoid internal discrimination by recognizing there are two cultures. In Hailey Yook’s essay “Positive Sterotypes Are Hurtful, Too”, author writes about the harmful of judging others based on their ethnic stereotype. A lot of people think Asians are intelligent, and the author points out this “positive stereotype” can be harmful …show more content…
As it is mentioned in Hsiang’s essay, Asian discriminate against each other within the same culture because they do not recognize that two diversity can be existed within the same culture. In fact, many of these people are from immigrant families, and they are frustrated because they face pressure from their and their community. “Many of us very much want to belong to our parents’ community, but we cannot completely embody one culture when we are living in anther. The pressures we face force many of us to feel we must choose one culture over another. We can either cling to our parents’ ideology, or rebel against it and try to be “American.”(FOBs VS. TWINKIES p.19-23). Parents of second generation of Asian American should let their children understand that they live in this country is a privilege, but they should not make pressure on children and force them to choose one culture over and discriminate toward another. It is similar in Hook’s essay, there is a lot of smart Asian, and it no doubt make people think that Asians are smart. However, this positive stereotype makes Asian students feel stressful, and it is not fair for them because it may neglect their own afford. One of my friends told me, when every time he got a good score on math test, his friends and family would not praise him, but they thought it is normal for an Asian student to get the good score on every subject. In fact, this made him felt stressful and depressed too because his effort on studying was neglect and he worried that he could not get a good on next test. A lot of time, this phenomenon makes a lot of students want to choose with other culture because they do not like the current culture they are

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Reflection On Stereotypes

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Stereotypes are everywhere in the world. Our ridged expectations of a community are sometimes all we know about that certain group. The students had a preconceived idea about the Harvard students being snobby and the Law students thought the students would not take the task seriously. This chapter really hit on many stereotypes throughout the chapter and how powerful it can be when stereotypes are broken. I would never think to take my class on a field trip to a courthouse to participate in a mock trial.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicholas Kristof’s, “The Asian Advantage” employs a humane, yet insightful tone and a free-flowing syntax composes a sound analysis of stereotyping and the role it plays in shaping a group. In the article, he claims that the titular group, Asian-Americans, aren’t necessarily successful due to intellectual prowess, but that it can be attributed to high expectations and family value. Experimental research in addition to expert testimony sprinkled throughout allow the claim to gain credibility and inevitably become common-sense. The implication of stereotyping playing a vital role in an individual’s success is explored in depth throughout this article.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For years now, people have tried to be more “politically correct” in everything they say or do. “Political correctness,” I have observed does not only pose problems for those in the majority but for the minorities as well. While on the surface this seems to be just a way of being considerate and kind to fellow human beings, I believe it is actually hurting society as a whole. When majority members cannot speak candidly, members of under-represented groups also suffer. What it results in is that no one, even the minorities it tries to protect, can discuss their concerns about fairness and fears without falling into the negative stereotypes.…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I was first aware of my “class” in the fifth grade when I was attending Hidalgo Elementary School. My parents decided that it was a time for a change because it wasn’t in a good neighborhood. My parents decided to transfer me to Bullard TALENT by the end of 5th grade which was a different environment for me than what I was used to. The majority of people attending Bullard TALENT were Hispanic and the majority of people attending Bullard TALENT were high end people. I was used to being around Hispanic people that when I attended Bullard TALENT I felt different from my classmates I felt like an outsider who didn’t fit in at all.…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They are invaders in the land that supposedly belongs to them, hence they are not and cannot be just “American,” but they are Asian-American. They are the other. Similarly, from the viewpoint of the people who have remained in their countries and have not immigrated or been exposed to the daily life of a U.S citizen, the term Asian-American is a reminder that members of the 1st generation, particularly those were born in the U.S and those of the 1.5 generation, are also truly not one of them. When interacting with people of the country they have descended or immigrated from, they may be viewed as “outsiders” due to having interacted and lived in the country deemed to be the land of freedom and opportunity. Asian-Americans who have left their home country physically through birth or immigration, to go reside and immerse themselves in the land full of dreams, hopes, freedom, and opportunity, are now outsiders.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is evident that America is a melting pot and always has been a country with diverse groups of people. Due to the increasing racial and ethnic diversity, people are labeled and grouped into categories mainly for convenience and familiarity (Healey & O’Brien, 2015). Over the course of this semester, I have learned numerous terms, concepts, and theories concerning minority groups in the United States. Of those things, the most intriguing and eye opening information that struck a chord inside of me concerned the stereotypes that affect minority groups, in addition to the prejudice and discrimination these group members face. Before this course, I had heard many stereotypes, joked about and ran from them, but it never occurred to me how detrimental…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once believed as unassimilable and perpetual foreigners, Asians took a new position in the Western society. Since then, it is thought that Asian Americans are the “model minority” and present…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Asian American Dream

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In many ways, Asian Americans have accomplished gaining the “American Dream” of getting a higher education, working a great job and financially over achieving. Therefore, Asian Americans are labeled as the model minority, a diligent and hardworking group that other minorities should follow (Le, 2011, p.13). Model minority is defined as a minority group of people who are expected to accomplish a higher degree of socioeconomic success than the average economic status (Wiki, 2016, p.9). But in reality, after the Latinos and Blacks, Asian Americans are the most likely to have highest high school dropout rates and are less likely to have access to higher education than other groups (Le, 2011, p. 4). Because of this model minority label Asian Americans…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Asian-Americans felt discrimination after the Vietnam war, when immigrants from Vietnam came to America. Groups such as the "Organization of Chinese Americans" fought to secure rights for Asian-Americans and prevent discrimination. Challenging stereotypes about Asian "passivity", and rejecting the exoticism and racism of "oriental" labels, Asian American activists mobilized this new consciousness to demand an end to racist hiring practices, biased school curricula, demeaning media stereotypes, residential discrimination, and the gentrification of historically Asian American neighborhoods. (Chinese…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today’s society has placed plenty of stereotypes upon Asian Americans. Labeling them as the model minority, assuming that all Asian Americans are intelligent by nature, seems to be the most common (Szu 2003). These stereotypes have been negatively affecting the growing population of Asian Americans in the school systems, as they are leading to teacher bias. Bias in the classroom can cause teachers to view all their Asian American students as intelligent and assume they are receiving academic support at home although most are not, this is highly affecting those who struggle academically. As a result, many Asian Americans, such as Hmong students are not reaching their full potential in the classroom nor are they given an equal opportunity (Doan…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Asian American Stereotypes

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is once again putting them into certain roles that are limiting. Another occurring theme the articles mentions about Asian Americans in the media is the need to assimilate with the white culture. This type of belief is exactly like the sidekick stereotype, where the minority needs the help of a white person or gravity’s to be like that white person. “One of the most compelling examples of such conformity in the representation of the Asian American in media is the side-kick” (Huike, 2015). In many shows, Asian is seen assimilating or assimilated into the white culture and it is that assimilation that has led them to achieve great economic success in America.…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America is made up of many different types of people who live in a country. This society of people have different perspectives on what they think of America. Although everyone within the region have their own way of what they believe is important in their lives social assumptions affect their perspectives as well. America past history have shaped most of the issues that are currently happening in the society today. Race, class and stereotypes have an effect on the American culture values.…

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fifty one percentages of the Asian Americans, according to the U.S. Census (2004) who had completed college almost double. Asian Americans are “model minority label and still stereotyped based on the most advantaged and successful members of their group, rather than members who are poor and struggling, as African and Hispanic Americans tend to be stereotyped.” (Zack, 2012) Asian Americans had a bachelor degree or higher. Asian American are lifelong learners.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, the United States has always been in conflict over the subject of race and racism. Although, the United States in reality is supposed to be free and united as the country name says it is, however that is not the case as it stands now. Racism has been around for a while and no one has said a thing, until a group of brave people, The United States Constitution, and Henry Luce present their sides about the truth about race and racism. To begin with, in an article written in The New York Times by Geeta Gandbhir and Michéle Stephenson, they write about how Asians are experiencing being stereotyped by the public. It is for some people that Asians are considered to be a “model minority” and superior to the other races.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Contrastly, Hsiang speaks of a discrimination that happens within the same culture. Specifically, the author describes how Asian Americans separate into two groups: FOB’s and Twinkies. To further this statement, Hsiang, the author of FOBs and Twinkies: The New Discrimination is Intraracial, articulates “The problems start when those who have made one choice discriminate against those those who have made another” (Eschholz 343). This quote supports the declaration that certain groups within the Asian cultures discriminate against the opposite groups by summarizing that problems and difficulties arise when discrimination takes…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays