Positive Stereotypes Are Hurtful Too Analysis

Improved Essays
In America, there are different cultures, religious, and languages in our community, and these elements form diversity. Having varies of diversity bring colors into our community, but it also create conflict within different groups. In Grace Hsiang’s essay ““FOBs” VS. “TWINKIES”: The New Discrimination Is Interracial”, the author discusses about the cultural conflict within the same ethnicity, and she points out people can avoid internal discrimination by recognizing there are two cultures. In Hailey Yook’s essay “Positive Sterotypes Are Hurtful, Too”, author writes about the harmful of judging others based on their ethnic stereotype. A lot of people think Asians are intelligent, and the author points out this “positive stereotype” can be harmful …show more content…
As it is mentioned in Hsiang’s essay, Asian discriminate against each other within the same culture because they do not recognize that two diversity can be existed within the same culture. In fact, many of these people are from immigrant families, and they are frustrated because they face pressure from their and their community. “Many of us very much want to belong to our parents’ community, but we cannot completely embody one culture when we are living in anther. The pressures we face force many of us to feel we must choose one culture over another. We can either cling to our parents’ ideology, or rebel against it and try to be “American.”(FOBs VS. TWINKIES p.19-23). Parents of second generation of Asian American should let their children understand that they live in this country is a privilege, but they should not make pressure on children and force them to choose one culture over and discriminate toward another. It is similar in Hook’s essay, there is a lot of smart Asian, and it no doubt make people think that Asians are smart. However, this positive stereotype makes Asian students feel stressful, and it is not fair for them because it may neglect their own afford. One of my friends told me, when every time he got a good score on math test, his friends and family would not praise him, but they thought it is normal for an Asian student to get the good score on every subject. In fact, this made him felt stressful and depressed too because his effort on studying was neglect and he worried that he could not get a good on next test. A lot of time, this phenomenon makes a lot of students want to choose with other culture because they do not like the current culture they are

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    For many, however, this just isn 't the reality. People from all over the globe have come to America in the pursuit of a better life, only to be held back due to their race, beliefs, and gender. A mentality such as this is destructive because it affects not only the way people perceive one another, it affects the way society in general perceives itself. This is because narrow mindedness and discrimination stops social and political growth, which can create tension between…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In America, racial discrimination and ageism are becoming big topics due to the ever ageing baby boomer generation and diversity. Society visually discriminates both groups based on their stereotype and race, using stereotypical and racist discrimination interchangeably and misinterpreting the difference between the two. The characterization of stereotypes is brought by the idea that an individual behaves or acts a certain way; not to be confused with discrimination, discrimination is the treatment of a group of people based on ethnicity, sexual orientation, race, etc. People of minority status have had a tough time with visual processing, especially when it comes to black individuals being categorized as a thug. Discrimination does not only…

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In America, like mentioned before, the culture is different than in your own hometown or country, run on people today are marrying with different cultures, religion, and race. To the majority, this can become very difficult, expanding the American society into a new form of family. The American society is very controversial, there is racism, hate, class value, group separation, and loss of family connection. Marriage and family are changing the…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He just does not want his friends to know that he enjoys going to class because he doesn 't want them to make fun of him. High school students are always trying to be accepted by their peers. They will do what is necessary to fit in. These students also run the risk of getting into drugs and dropping out of school because schools in low income areas are not as controlled and there usually is not someone there who cares enough to help pull these students out of these issues. When Escalante first gets to the Garfield High school he was told that he would be teaching computer science, but to his surprise the class was canceled because the school could not afford computers and was told he would be teaching math instead.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As it happened in the film “Stand and Deliver”, the staff of Garfield High had such a low expectation in their students that they weren 't preparing them for college. Since the Junior students were being taught 8th grade math, the teachers thought that they did not have any plans of continuing their education at a higher level. Moreover, recalling and examining the scene in where Jamie notified the staff that he was planning to teach calculus, they literally just laughed at him. Since they all had low expectations from the students, they thought that Jaime was crazy if he thought that he would be capable of “teaching those kids calculus”. They had the impression that the students were too dumb to learn…

    • 1823 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    And if they give the wrong answer it not only humiliates them but also brings shame on their families. Hong Kong students are taught to be modest and not to display their knowledge freely until being specially called for. All these things can lead to misunderstandings since most American teachers highly promote class participation. It's a normal thing that American teachers expect Asian students to ask them to explain something difficult. However, most Hong Kong students don't do that as we have seen earlier.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Test anxiety only causes students to perform badly and makes them forget some of the content they learned. "Standardized testing evaluates a student 's performance on one particular day and does not take into account external factors" (University of Columbia, 2013). Teacher are stressed out due to the fact that they are given what they are supposed to teach and don’t really know how to teach it. Every year teachers format their material to fit what they have seen on previous tests. Testing doesn’t take part in a student’s future and won’t be significant in their real-world jobs.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The foreign blacks feel white people like immigrants more then black americans so when there children start to straight line assimilation and begin to be more custom with modern society they fear they are loosing their advantage. These parents are worried of their children being influenced by mainstream America and developing into black americans so they stress the importance of their ethnic identities in order to have social mobility. Black immigrants feel as if they have an advantage over Black Americans one they wish not to jeorpodize in the generations that follow so their children are able to prosper like how they…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most schools provide utensils, textbooks, or paper in the main office. If the student doesn’t come with the materials he or she needs to succeed the student is being careless. Some students don’t understand how vital it is to come to school prepared to learn. If students don’t show up to class, he or she won’t be able to learn the lessons to succeed on any test, especially standardized tests. Sometimes parents or guardians don’t care if a student comes to school or not, they can honestly care less.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Dream Essay

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, the real “American dream” is not as exciting as the original meaning, materialism and idealism serious confrontation and conflict to show the dark side of the American dream to every immigration groups. Asian Americans by more than a dozen Asian nation as well as American-born descendants of the composition. Despite the different Asian group have different languages, different ethnic, different cultural backgrounds, but share a common experience in the United States. When Thomas’s mother just came to the United States, she suffered discrimination from the local people, which manifested in many ways. Language barriers and different cultural backgrounds led her life has become particularly difficult.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays