Stalin Five Year Plan Analysis

Great Essays
Register to read the introduction… The Five Year Plans had already caused a lot of distress to workers as Stalin was strict about targets not being met. Society had become unstable as a result of the Five Year Plans, mass urbanisation and violence in overcrowded, unsanitary cities. Mass urbanisation had brought a large workforce to the cities but this was followed by violence and social tension. Because of this there was a lot of hostility towards the communist party which was beginning to worry the government. M.Lewin describes this as a “quicksand society”[ix] which describes just how unstable the attitudes were towards the leadership. Stalin, it can be argued, resorted to the purges to prevent criticism of the leadership. The totalitarian viewpoint would be that Stalin used the purges to control the general population which I agree with, however the revisionist viewpoint would be that the centre used the purges to try and gain control of the chaos but it spiralled out of control and created a momentum of its own. I believe that the social instability within the main cities from mass urbanisation and the dissent that the Five Year Plans created contributed to the continuation of the purges as the leadership and Stalin needed to find a way to control the chaos. However I do not believe that this was the work of Stalin’s paranoia but Stalin doing what he believed as necessary to keep …show more content…
Lewis and P. Whitehead argue that “It has been irrefutably proved that the murder of Kirov was organised through Stalin through Yagoda and the NKVD”,[xi] however Russian Scholar and politician A. Lakoviev states that “L.V Nikolayev planned and perpetrated the murder alone”[xii]. By looking at it in this respect it shows that Stalin may not have been directly responsible for the purges. But without the murder of Kirov the purges might not have happened as Stalin would have found it difficult to justify his actions. I believe that some parts of the NKVD acted on their own, continuing the purges for their own gain. As historians Corin and Fiehn say “Some units, especially in areas outside of Moscow, operated on their own fiefdoms”[xiii], I believe the NKVD did act more like a mafia outside of Moscow using the purges to their own …show more content…
Lewis and P. Whitehead, Stalin: A time for Judgement, p63

[xii] R.W Thurston, Life and Terror in Stalin’s Russia 1934-41, p22

[xiii] Communist Russia under Lenin and Stalin, Corin and Fiehn, p227

[xiv] Robert Conquest, The Great Terror, p21

[xv] Communist Russia under Lenin and Stalin, Corin and Fiehn, p201

[xvi] A.Nove (ed.), The Stalin Phenomenon, 1993,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Nationalism is a shared feeling between a group of a geographical and demographic region seeking independence for its culture or ethnicity. Nationalism can be expressed as a belief or a political ideology that involves an individual becoming attached to one’s nation. The interest of a nation as a whole held to be an independent entity separate from the interests of subordinate areas or groups and also of other nations or supranational groups. An extent of nationalism can only be pursued by nations or countries when the effects of their nationalism does not harm any other nation or country; if that point is reached, or conducting a systematic way of reaching that point, it is called ultranationalism, an extreme form of nationalism. The source…

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To help justify the research I will use quotes from the book “Bitter Watters. Using these quotes to show how the Soviet society was run under Stalin. After describing both time periods of the Soviet Union, we will compare and contrast the two. Finding the most important change between the two time periods and why it was important to the Soviet Union. Before we discuss the two time periods, we need to analyze the book itself.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    His visions were this: greatly increase the productivity in Russia through intensive labor camps and quotas to prove Russia’s greatness. As Stalin intensified his 5 year plan and became more obsessed with meeting certain production quotas, he expanded the role of labor reform and prison camps. Also known as the Gulag, these labor camps had been around since Lenin’s rule, but were at that time seen more as actual labor and reforming camps. However, Stalin saw potential in these camps and started sending more and more criminals, and even some innocent people to the Gulag in order to complete his 5 year plan in 4 years. In order to get these people to the camps, arrests had to take place.…

    • 2051 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Soviet Union Dbq Analysis

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Stalin had incredibly vast powers allowing him to enforce his own belief system in punishment, Roy Medvedev’s article in Moscow News specifies “The Great Terror was a matter of] the most cruel tortures, interrogations, [and] the fearful abuse of human dignity” (Doc C). Joseph Stalin’s powers in the Soviet government took control of all forms of discipline and if he were to think a punishment was necessary no matter how little a crime to no crime at all, it would be taken into action. While these forms of mass torcher were being carried out, cultural achievements and military strength gave the world something else to focus on. By grabbing the attention of the world to see the public side of the Soviet Union, no one would see the Great Terror or the secret police force of Stalin harming their own people. The government wanted control of the votes even when people could individually vote, Reg Manning’s article in Time magazine states “To this end it went to great lengths organizing its elections, including sending hundreds of thousands of political workers to visit every Soviet home to encourage voting” (Doc D).…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tactics Of Joseph Stalin

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Purges were what Stalin stooped to to show that he was a dictator to not be messed with. In the year 1934, Stalin began the Great Purge. This was the real way to show that Stalin meant business. Almost all of the Bolsheviks were slaughtered to put an end to the old revolutionist ways. By the end of the 30’s the Great Purge or Great Terror had moved away from the old Bolsheviks and extended to the regular peasants.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Stalin had installed fear to get what he wanted. You can speed up time by mass production, but more importantly treating your citizens badly. Today we live in a society where everything is mass-produced. Labor unions make up quite a percent of the workforce. Industrialization is everything in the world, and from the age of Stalin till now it will always…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Joseph Stalin also reduced the rights of many Russians. Many Russians also lost their lives under the rule of Joseph Stalin. In order to determine whether the Russian Revolution was a success or failure it is important that we consider numerous aspects. Based on the five texts provided Animal Farm (Chapters IX-X), by George Orwell, an excerpt from “Education, Literacy, and the Russian Revolution” by Megan Behrent, “Stalin and the Communist Party…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joseph Stalin Dbq

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Over the 30 years of Joseph Stalin’s dictatorship, the estimated death toll ranged from 28 to 40 million people, whom died from a variety of things, such as famine, executions, and a very large war. Stalin assumed autocratic rule of the Soviet Union in 1924 following the death of Lenin. Stalin made a variety of reforms, but his main focus was on the economic issues that was occurring in the communist country at the time. Stalin made his economic reforms solely to make the most amount of money possibly, even if millions of people had to die. I completely contest to Stalin’s beliefs and ideas during this very controversial time in the USSR.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Dictator: Stalin was the Worst of Them All Throughout the years, there have been many ruthless dictators. These dictators include, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, Fidel Castro, Mao Zedong and the worst of them all, Joseph Stalin. Many people think that this is not true. Some people will call Adolf Hitler the worst and most ruthless leader of all time because he killed so many Jewish people and anyone he did not like.…

    • 2114 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the other hand Old Benjamin, the donkey knew what was going on in the society but prefer to remain silent. Private life in Stalin’s Russia creates a new definition of freedom of speech. By that, it means someone can have their freedom of speech with the consequence in mind of getting executed by political leaders if the arguments are against the will. People who knew about what was going on prefer to remain silent in order to keep their life safe and without getting caught. The way Stalin treated the people will brutality affects the response on which every individuals experienced high intimidation from people who control the situation.…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Modern World History textbook it tells, “To realize his vision, Stalin planned to transform the Soviet Union into a totalitarian state” (441). Thus, Demonstrating that Stalin stole the people’s rights and freedoms by turning the Soviet Union into a totalitarian state to achieve complete control. By doing this he will have no limitations and extreme loyalty at all…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stalin would completely erase a person from from ever existing, including in newspapers,books, and pictures. During Yezhovshchina, the intense time of purges from 1937-1938, Stalin purged over 1.2 million people. From 1924 to 1954, an estimate of 40 million people were purged directly linked to Stalin. This is double the amount of Hitler and three times the amount of Mussolini's. Purges were not Stalin's only way of demonstrating terrorism. He purged religious leaders and closed down churches.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Contrary to Vladimir Lenin, who was quite modest and refused any kind of public praise, Stalin relied on constant worship in what became known as Stalin’s cult of personality. In this sense, Stalin’s personality cult went against traditional Bolshevik practice. This cult allowed Stalin to have a stronger support system for his policies as he lacked the same prestige as Lenin, especially in the 1930s when the famine of 1932-1933 increased opposition and he started to rely on drastic measures such as the Great Purge, in which he eradicated any people he perceived to be a threat to his authority. Thus, Stalin’s cult also grew as his absolute power and dictatorial leadership style also grew in the 1930s. Interestingly, however, Stalin was significantly…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stalin utilized secret police, armed with tanks and armored cars, to suppress riots. Telephone lines and mail were monitored, and children were used to gain information about disloyal remarks spoken in the home. In 1937, he launched the Great Purge, a campaign of terror attempting to eliminate all threats to Stalin's power that resulted in upwards of 8 million deaths. Stalin and his government also controlled all newspapers, movies, radios, and other sources of information. Russian writers and artists became victims of censorship, and individuality was stifled.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Parhon's Purge Summary

    • 2323 Words
    • 10 Pages

    VIOLENCE AND THYRANY IN SOFI OKSANEN’S “PURGE” BÁNYAI BOTOND-PÉTER 11.12.2014 FINNISH LITERATURE SCANDINAVIAN STUDIES FACULTY OF HUMANITIES UNIVERSITY OF OULU Contents INTRODUCTION 3 THE PLOT(S) 3 TITLE 4 HYSTORICAL BACKGROUND 4 TORTURE AND FEAR 5 WHAT DOES BEING A SURVIVAR MEAN? 8 CONCLUSIONS 8 BIBLIOGRAPHY AND SOURCES 9 INTRODUCTION Purge is the third novel written by the famous Finnish author, Sofi Oksanen. In the beginning she had written this masterpiece as a play. It was performed at the Finnish National Theatre and had a huge success.…

    • 2323 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays