Stabilization Of Russia Case Study

Amazing Essays
Stabilization of Kosovo through Russian Involvement Every state is motivated by self-interest when it comes to international affairs. Ethical reasoning can come into play when states try to intervene when infractions against human rights occur. The protection of human rights is a basic law a majority of states enforce. However, when a violation of these basic rights is tested the way in which states react is key to understanding the complexity of humanitarian intervention. Humanitarian intervention considers many arguments, the main being responsibility versus sovereignty and the destabilization of a preexisting, tyrannical regime. Although both arguments are valid for discussion, many people fail to see this because of self-interest. This …show more content…
The ethical concepts, traditions, and strategies utilized by the state became clearer. Consequentialist reasoning and self-interest were the main influences behind limited involvement based on the Russians extremely destitute state. Boris Yeltsin and Sergei Lavrov took the economic stability of Russia and its people into extreme consideration. The evaluation of the potential negative effect was evaluated and ultimately decided humanitarian intervention would be too costly. However, costly involvement could be Russia still considered the possible benefits. These included political alliances and access to a region close to Western States that could impose a potential threat. This strategy not only proved to protect Russia’s sovereignty and imperialism but also would help cleanse their already damaged image due to the effects of the Cold War. Chernomyrdin and Lavrov believed in limited involvement in the region but still wanted a unilateral pressure imposed for Russia’s benefit. Although consequentialism was a large factor in the decision to stay uninvolved in the conflict, Yeltsin still believed that protection of human rights should be accomplished. However, this should avoid complete intervention and would only be discussed through a summit meeting. Russia’s deviation from the original plan was due to the alignment of self-interest as brought …show more content…
However, with the threat of airstrikes and an estimated large number of civilian casualties Russia became involved, but with restraints. The stabilizing of a regime was the goal in order to secure the conflict and limit infractions upon human rights. Stabilization was the philosophical goal, but was not met due to NATO bombing Serbia in an effort to force Milosevic out of power. Although humanitarian intervention was not avoided, the Russian government still declared it was their responsibility to protect the sovereignty of the people. This was accomplished through the use of a UN world leader summit, under the agreement that Boris Yeltsin would attend. Ultimately the summit lead to controversial decisions and in the end resulted in the demise of Milosevic’s tyranny in Serbia and a needed regime change. These actions lead to the autonomy of Kosovo as an independent state, which still stands today. The Kosovo Crisis simulation categorically shows how one decision by a state actor can change the course of an unresolved conflict evaluated by an entire system of states. The protection of human-rights is a goal that every state should have in mind; however the consequences of intervention can outweigh the benefits. Humanitarian intervention takes the argument of responsibility versus sovereignty and the destabilizing of a preexisting regime. Both these arguments display

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The patriots might disapprove the achievements of Gorbachev as the Soviet leader. Nevertheless, their judgement has in fact neglected the importance of him in constructing a peaceful world which had been undermined for the whole Cold War. Undeniably, Gorbachev did make unimaginable concessions in the resolution of regional conflicts and arms negotiations. His acts were often recognised as ruining the great country of the USSR. However, according to Nikolay Shmelev, the Russians would not have been able to persuade our main partners in the West without those concessions.…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By making the Soviet Union public enemy number one, the United States rationalized their harsh response to the revolutionary impulses in other nations. Williams places a great deal of emphasis on U.S. accountability in the Cold War. While this does not accurately depict the power of the Soviet Union, for the purposes of his argument it is quite…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was created after WW2 and its policies include maintaining plenty of political strength and political unity with the goal of easing tension between the East and the West, however the opposite happened during the Cold War which led to national and international politics being affected. (Kennan) This fact shows how global organizations were affected by the Cold War in how they built their policies around the rivalry between the US and the USSR which led to other parts of the world being affected by these change in politics and policies. In the way the Cold War affected America domestically, it gave a common enemy to US politicians who used the red scares and fear of communism to get the American people’s votes. American politics were impacted by the Cold War not only in the policies that were created, but how the politicians of this era conducted themselves and how they used the situation to gain political power. The Cold War also had instigated strong anti-communism within the US that led to drastic policies and acts to be put into place such as the McCarran Act and the Communist Control.…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another argument put forth by the pro-scholars is that a theory of necessity permits the use of force to avert a humanitarian disaster as the lesser of two evils. Because states exist to further the rights of their citizens, state sovereignty depends on the rights and responsibilities it has for its citizens. They conclude that states that attack their own people, or fail to protect them, should forfeit the legal protections associated with statehood. This allows for state sovereignty to be overlooked in favor of individual sovereignty. Similarly, in the Kosovo case, government officials, human rights groups, philosophers, and legal scholars alike vigorously debated the compatibility of NATO 's military intervention with Article 2(4) of the UN…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Such emphasis on importance of practicing empathy matches with liberalists’ view that empathy is required in international cooperation. Failure to be empathetic, however, can cause the strong to lose and evidences that supports McNamara’s claim can be found in Record’s article. Record first introduces Andrew Mack’s argument. Mack argued “will to fight and prevail” is the ultimate determinant of which side is likely to win. According to Mack, “ for insurgents ‘war’ is total, while for the external power it is necessarily ‘limited’, meaning that weaker side has its country and independence to lose in a war so it fights with everything it has.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For starters, Russia was amongst one of the only nations not to join the UN sponsored resolutions calling on Syrian President Assad to step down, instead Russia went against the mast and supported Syrian president in order to protect Russian interests (Hahn 2012). Due to Syria’s close proximity to Russia, the Russian government fears that if the current regime in Syria comes to an end, the United States will take actions to instill a democratic system in the nation thereby furthering the United States power in Russia’s sphere of influence. In other terms, Russia is taking the realist approach of zero-sum, meaning Russia can win as long as United states loses; which is why Russia continues to support President Assad. Regardless of the fact that Syria is in desperate need of humanitarian intervention, Russia is continuing to stick by the realism theory of political responsibility in pursuit on one’s own interest, meaning that as long as Russia’s self-interest are not being negatively affected by the humanitarian…

    • 1055 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Russian Pipeline Essay

    • 2321 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Moreover, the U.S. must help financially troubled EU member states, thus preventing them turning toward Russia. In addition, U.S. should leverage foreign policy and diplomatic relations with the United Kingdom (UK) to prevent the UK from leaving the EU, thus preventing a serious weakening of the EU and further possible consequences that favor Russia. Nonetheless, the U.S. must preserve its influence in Europe and the current balance of power in order to achieve its national interests and security. If the balance of power shift is already inevitable, it would be best if it happens in the EU’s favor, so it can rise as a regional hegemon and prevent Russia from becoming…

    • 2321 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kurds Case Study

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages

    At the surface it would be simple to say “back the Kurds” in the fight against ISIL. However, the US is faced with a catch-22 in regards to this “simple” decision. Official support for the Kurds directly opposes the agendas of Turkey and to a lesser extent the GOI. As such the political savvy decision to support the SDF represents a compromise in policy but not a comprise in our country’s ethics or morals. Nonetheless, it is important to understand that there is more this complex situation.…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Truman Doctrine was the start of the policies set for dealing with other countries during the Cold war. The disadvantage to this was that if the U.S. did not want to get into any more conflicts and one came up in which a democratic country needed aid, the U.S. had to get involved to help defend democracy. According to Frazier (2009), people feared that it would lead to spending large sum of money to other countries and could lead to a breakdown with relations with Soviet Union or war, (p. 4). By helping countries with aid, other countries may look at the support as a way to spread Western or American ideals that they find as a threat to them. Countries that we are not helping may also think we are trying to get a military advantage going into a country.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Human nature is flawed therefore when survival is the main goal of a state, conflict is inevitable because a state has no way of predicting the true intentions of another state. This is why it is necessary for a state to expand their power, in order to have enough power to defend themselves in the anarchic international system. Many of these ideas came from Thucydides’ writing about realism in the international system. In many of his texts he writes about how a state’s survival depends largely on their material capability and alliances. More specifically if a state is internally solid with a strong communal identity, this will then lead to domestic stability and more importantly a strong foundation in the international system.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays