Sound And Fury: How Two Sided Argument Impact One Family

Improved Essays
Sound and Fury Paper

The point in writing this paper is to show how a two sided argument impacted one family. When half of a family is deaf and half of the family is hearing things can be complicated. This paper is going to be about the struggles that this family faced when it came to making decisions about cochlear implants. You will see how each family chooses how their children will experience life and the challenges they will have to overcome and how they will overcome them.
There were parts of the movie I liked and parts that I disliked. One thing that I liked in the movie was being able to see the two sided argument. I found it very fascinating to see the different opinions. There was a hearing side and then there was the deaf side.I was familiar with this topic of the controversy of cochlear implants. However I just didn't realize how big of a decision it is for the deaf community and how angry it made them. So I was very surprised when the deaf community took cochlear implants as such an insult and basically thought of them as a sin. I was not
…show more content…
It was out of their comfort zone to look at cochlear implants. During the movie one thing that I noticed is that the deaf community were rude to hearing people. In specific the parents of Peter. Peter's parents wanted the best for their son and were looking out for him. However at the picnic when all the deaf community was together this showed how tight knit they all were. Cochlear implants jeopardize the deaf community because they believe that if everyone gets cochlear implants then there will be no deaf community. An example of deaf pride in the movie was when the deaf grandparents were arguing with Peter's parents you could really see how passionate they were about their community. I don't think that the two worlds would be able to compromise. The deaf community is too passionate about their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In other words, losing their hearing was a major detriment to their lives and could only be described as traumatic. After reading the book, I believe this is because they have lived their entire lives as a hearing person so it is like they lost a part of who they are. For example, on page 5 a deafened man explained that “…my hearing…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction to American Deaf Culture by Thomas Holcomb begins with a graphic celebrating Deaf culture to set the tone for the whole book. Holcomb discusses the difference between being deaf and the Deaf community, and the difference between community and culture. He uses specific examples to show how Deaf culture adheres to all five hallmarks that make up a culture. In the third chapter, he defines many of the terms and labels used to describe deaf people, including hearing-impaired and hard of hearing. Within this section, a helpful guide of appropriate terms and inappropriate terms is provided so hearing people understand what is acceptable when describing a deaf person.…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of the Deaf community believe they aren’t as important, and then again some of the Deaf community believe they are a great and another way to help communicate with the hearing community. She talks about how James from time to time would misplace his hearing aid, and for a family with a low income, it can be a problem replacing them. At this time- and still in the present time- hearing aids are expensive. I work at Costco Wholesale and we just got in hearing aids and a hearing aid department. For a lot of people, insurance doesn 't cover the whole cost.…

    • 1549 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lou Ann Walker, “Losing the Language of Silence” scholarly essay; Walker’s main idea is that the deaf culture is fighting to survive in today’s worlds. St. Joseph’s school for the deaf in the Bronx New York City has experienced this fight firsthand. One third of their students now have cochlear implants and they fear those implants could be the reason for the demise of the deaf culture. Children who now have cochlear implants are not learning sign language. These kids are being put into public school with lip-reading instruction.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It’s been 7 years since I lost my hearing… I can define it as rock climbing, it can be an hardcore work to reach to the top of the mountain, the rocks falling near me, my hands and feet getting swollen and my muscles feeling burn all of that didn’t matter once I could hear again using my cochlear implant. Once I was at the top. I didn’t have to deal with a loss anymore because I wasn’t losing anything I was gaining one of senses back, the one that allowed me to be independent again. With my cochlear implant I am part of this wonderful world of sounds my voice is louder, clear and powerful. I have more power under my control than any other hearing person in the world!…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “A Deaf Person’s Ethical Perspective why forcing Cochlear Implantation is Wrong” Introduction to Interdisciplinary Studies Extra Credit Paper Dr. Mark Packer Eric G. Shuping April 1, 2015 “A Deaf Person’s Ethical Perspective why forcing Cochlear Implantation is Wrong” As a deaf person, I look at our deaf society to be something of value and cherished for such a long time because we are such a small society. Being deaf while growing up in a hearing society, people treat us as if we are “disabled” like something is wrong with us.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The problem sparked into a big outrage because the decision of appointing a hearing president was thought upon because people that are hearing are more capable than people that are deaf. For the students of Gallaudet University, a barrier between the hearing world and the Deaf world was developed and opened a whole new level of disrespecting…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Deaf Like Me Summary

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The book “Deaf Like Me” by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley intrigued because it was about a hearing family that had a deaf daughter. I was also interested that the book was written in the perspective of the father. The statistic that vast majority of deaf children are born to hearing parents has always made me fascinated with what each hearing parent has done for their deaf child. I knew that this story would most likely have a happy ending considering the title “Deaf Like Me” I made the inference that maybe his daughter would find inclusion from being emerged in the culture of deaf individuals. “Deaf Like Me” followed the story of the parents Tom and Louise Spradley in the early 1960s.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Deaf Again Summary

    • 1850 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Deaf Again is an autobiography of the life of Mark Drolsbaugh. Mark analyzes and discusses the psychosocial and educational aspects of deafness by using experiences and his family’s encounters throughout his life. He begins with Sherry, Mark’s mother’s experience of his birth to exemplify how the deaf are treated due to the communication gap between the deaf and hearing. He then discusses experiences that impacted his psychosocial, emotional, and educational development from the time he was diagnosed deaf as a child through to his adult years when he fell in love with deaf culture. Mark was born hearing and began losing his hearing in the first grade.…

    • 1850 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Train Go Sorry Analysis

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Train Go Sorry: Inside a Deaf World, written by Leah Hager Cohen, is a biography of the author who has a relationship with Lexington School for the Deaf and a portrait of two deaf students (Sofia and James) throughout their time at the school. She switches her delivery, telling her family’s story and the stories of the two teenagers to narrate the truth about the deaf world. The book sheds light on the deaf school in New York, the stories of the two students, deaf culture, and various controversies within the community and between both deaf and hearing groups to give worth to these topics. Cohen, a hearing woman, writes using insight and sensitivity as she educates on mainstreaming, signed communication versus oral communication, advancements…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sofia really shows how she is adapting to the hearing world through sign language, but her mother didn’t learn as much American Sign Language. TTY’s are also described and how it became the most useful thing in the Deaf Community and how it is a great way to communicate. Sometimes, hearing aids aren’t important to others, as it is very important to some. But to people who are dead it can be very useful and understand the hearing world. James usually loses his hearing aid, and he comes from a poor family and a hearing aid can be very expensive.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Youtube video “Through Deaf Eyes’” is about how Deaf culture has changed in a positive manner throughout the years. It highlights special moments in Deaf culture, such as society attempting to teach Deaf people how to speak verbally, how Deaf people are no longer discriminated in today’s culture, and how technology has impacted the Deaf community. This documentary is a very educational video about the Deaf culture and how it has evolved. This video made me come to a realization of the Deaf Culture and how it has changed drastically over the years. In the 1800’s, Deaf people were completely misunderstood and were often seen as strange or mentally retarded (ASL IVC).…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mark Drolsbaugh’s autobiography, Deaf Again goes through his life journey as a deaf individual who tries to find his Deaf identity in the hearing world. Mark was born as a hearing person, but as he got older he gradually started to lose his hearing which made it difficult for him to fit in as “normal child.” Some of the challenges that Mark faced in his life were conformity, isolation, communication barrier and the delay of having an ASL education. Mark felt like an outsider for the first time when he began to lose his hearing in kindergarten. Kindergarten is a time to build friendships and learn with others, but for Mark he realized he was different and felt alone.…

    • 1702 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    I. Summary (1-2 paragraphs) The documentary Sound and Fury addresses the use of cochlear implants for individuals who are considered by a medical professional or speech and language pathologist as either deaf or hard-of-hearing. In this specific film, Heather, age 6, and Peter, who is almost 2 years of age, are individuals who, after the consultation of numerous respective occupations, believes could benefit from a cochlear implant. This documentary focuses on the fact that the implementation of a cochlear implant isn’t a simple process in terms of the decision to do so by the family to the actual procedure, as it needs to be surgically implanted. Throughout the documentary, numerous concerns are brought to light on the effects a cochlear…

    • 1821 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sound And Fury Analysis

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages

    "Sound and Fury," a documentary by Josh Aronson, is a compelling story of a struggle between two cultures; the hearing community and the deaf community, grounded in a conflict between members of one family, split over the perceptions and beliefs of what it means to be"normal. " It is a film about identity and culture, belonging and being an outsider, misconceptions and a desire to be understood. It is a film about the struggles of a cultural minority to find its place and acceptance in the larger world. Sound and fury is a tale of a family whose members are both; hearing as well as hearing impaired. The main character in the movie is a six years old Heather Artinian, born deaf to parents who are both hearing impaired.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays