Dorothy Lee Individual Autonomy And Social Structure Analysis

Improved Essays
Within numerous societies many individuals must give up their uniqueness for the good of civilization as a whole, succumbing to such things as minority status and inequality. However, Dorothy Lee’s intriguing piece Individual Autonomy and Social Structure, discuses how individual integrity and social structure are able to function simultaneously (Lee 14). This is crucial to the community, yet it is often lost within the confines of social structure that creates barriers around what one can and cannot do. These barricades prevent the freedom of self, a concept that all should willingly embrace instead of neglecting entirely. This essay will discuss the fundamental social problem of individual autonomy and social structure, the paper will critically analyze the Navaho Indians’ child rearing methods to prove that the two are able to coexistence effectively, thus concluding with the basic resolution of the key social dilemma presented by Dorothy Lee. …show more content…
The complication at hand is that society indeed possesses a form of social group, however, this collective does not allow human beings the freedom or chance for spontaneous operation, thus lacking the value for sheer personal being (Lee 5). By giving members of society the freedom to act on their own accord, specifically children, they are learning about responsibility, life, and community without control. That is, the parental control that is exerted upon them as children, making sure they refrain from disobedient or dangerous behaviour. The Navaho Indians and their childrearing behaviours display how individual cultures can co exist rather than being in opposition to one another, it is possible to still have structure and also have personal autonomy. The respect for individual integrity is a concept that a Navaho mother and son exhibit in the following

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Imagine one, dwindling culture that has a 152% higher chance at winning the lottery compared to another population. Except the reward they win is not wealth, it is the rate of injury. For the Native American people, this statistic is true when juxtaposed to other Americans (Demographics). Similar to this, many unbalanced problems where Native Americans are on the inferior side of the scale compared to Americans with an alarmingly superior side, have appeared in native culture. The roots of these issues can be found starting in 1860, when the United States government established American Indian boarding schools to help bring education to the “lacking” Indians.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Autonomy Analysis

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    One example offered by Meyers argues that the traditional women’s position of staying at home still allows for personal autonomy since “to be autonomous people must conduct their lives in accordance with the dispositions of their authentic selves. Since individuals differ, it is unlikely that one sort of environment would give every self-maximal opportunity to flourish” (Meyers, pg. 622). A traditional woman can have personal autonomy by staying at home, if that is where she truly feels that she belongs on her own convictions. The public sphere is so diverse and encompasses various occupations that it is appropriate to view the home as another sphere that one could find their true self in. These features of the traditional women still allow for some degree of autonomy.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Cherokee Removal

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Perdue and Green’s “The Cherokee Removal, A Brief History with Documents” is an introduction to the social and political period surrounding the removal of Cherokee Indians. The authors’ inclusion of many documents, shares with readers, the Indian voices as well as key political figures’ position on sovereign governance. This complex period is successfully outlined by Perdue and Green, with a chronological account of the Indians’ first encounter with Europeans through the inevitable journey, “Trail of Tears”.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “When their children, as for example the children of the Wintu Indians, ask “Can I? they are asking for information on the rules of structure; for instance, they may be seeking clarification about a religious taboo or a social custom. They are saying in effect, “Is it permissible for me to…?” and not, “Do you allow me…?”” In this example, Dorothy Lee shows that “permisiviness” goes not from person to person, parents do not “permit” their children, instead children ask for clarification of social structure regulations.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identity is a key importance to the overview of any individual’s culture. Without the culture it begins to develop this confused identity that does not have a clear connection to oneself. Identity is important to the main body to understand history, language, and family connection. The loss of identity is caused by the forced assimilation to the Indigenous culture to create this blind imagery that one does not clearly demonstrate their own culture. Throughout the book Bad Indians by Deborah Miranda, it explains why an individual who has lost their true identity has lost the whole self of their character.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Individual Autonomy and the tension to conform to Societal values In the pursuit of individual autonomy, tensions exist in the obligation to conform to the values and expectations of the wider community, however, this doesn't always need to be the case. The subject of sociology involves the study of just about every aspect of life from the smallest individual concern to the largest institutional crisis. It is because of this broad range that there will inevitably encounter tensions. Individual autonomy is a persons basic human right to be free to make their own decisions without being influenced by other factors.…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social structure was a vital component to any Native American tribe. The Algonquians, for example, a group that inhabited the Northeastern portion of the continent, “lived in bands ranging from one to three hundred members”. Families lived together in wigwams “made of bent saplings covered with birch bark”. Not only did a husband, wife, and their family reside in these structures, but their married sons and their families lived there also. “Both the Iroquois and the Algonquians had strong tribal identities above and beyond the basic nuclear families.”…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian touches on many issues faced by many modern-day Native Americans throughout their lives, one such issue being poverty, which appears to be present in most Indian families. The sort of poverty that plagues the Spokane reservation is the same kind that has plagued Native Americans for generations. One possible root cause for the situation would be that the current natives on the reservation see that their parents couldn’t do anything to rid themselves of poverty, so they lose hope and, as a result, perpetuate the problem. While the degree of poverty in Junior’s Indian reservation is extreme, the underlying struggles that come with such a financial predicament are to be made note…

    • 1107 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The most basic level of social anthropological analysis is an analysis of the family structures a group ascribes to. In the Amhara group, the primary social group is made up of one’s immediate family, the nuclear family structure of a married man and woman and their children. While the Amhara people are close to their larger community the main unit is small and external relations mainly comes from interactions through the church. The Tsaatans are similar in this regard, their primary social structure is made up of the nuclear family and because of their nomadic lifestyle, traveling with their reindeer across the isolated taiga, they are unlikely to receive much external social contact other than from their shaman who helps connect them to the spirits that they worship. The Lolos Noirs are more social, living in village communities and having social connections with those around them, worshipping with their larger community and helping others with their work.…

    • 1854 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Truly, the privileged tribal initiative is not static, but rather liquid, and effectively subject to challenge by other would-be petitioners for that position, so authority in these groups is not generally steady. It is this condition of flux, and a craving for strength,…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emphasising the diverse and distinct cultural values of various nations around the globe, Thomas Balmes’ documentary, Babies, juxtaposes the early development of individuals against the influences and ideologies imparted by the society. Centered around four young infants- Ponijao of Opuwo, Namibia, Bayarjargal (Baya) of Bayanchandmani, Mongolia, Mari of Tokyo, Japan, and Hattie of San Francisco, America -in contrasting civilizations, the documentary records not only the psychological growth, however, equally the sociological interactions of the featured young individuals. Alongside illustrating various norms, values, beliefs and practises, the documentary not only captures the role of technological development in the global world, but also…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    West African Family

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Introduction Have you heard of the old African proverb “the old woman looks after the child to grow its teeth and the young one in turn looks after the old woman when she loses her teeth” (Akan, Ghana)? Solidarity, unity, inter-communities, and family relationships among West Africans have been known for thousands of years. Family and community play an important role in traditional West African culture. The traditional value of family and community breeds the harmonic communal culture.…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Which changed the view of native nations from co-equals to a group they could dominate over, ultimately “population/resources overturn juridical notion of Indians…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The contrast between indigenous people and those who voluntarily arrived by ship has been emphasized more than commonalities constructing the “ecological Indian” as a pinnacle or at the least something that “Man…” is not. The hunting practices employed by many indigenous tribes was ritualistic in nature with a right and wrong methodology to utilize (Krech 129), however, colonizers would question these practices with regards to buffalos in comparison to the European “proper” and “sporting” methods of hunting (Krech 130). Additionally, the prioritization of economic security over environmentalist concerns can be understood as very human, but increased pressure and scrutiny from outside of a reservation is placed on indigenous populations because they have been held up to the standard of an “ecological Indian” (Krech 226-227). This is another example of a socially constructed “fundamental truth” because these criticisms do not acknowledge the history that forced the tribal leaders to choose between two detrimental…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a real temptation to not inform the Karrayu people of why we will be living with them so that we might gain the most unbiased and pure view of their family values as they understand them. In order to avoid this we shall be sure to discuss the reasons of our desire to be “adopted” by a family and what exactly we are searching for in our research with the Karrayu people before performing any research. We shall also be sure to have a discussion with the family that each person shall be staying with to ensure that they understand what this “adoption” means. Along with immersing ourselves into a Karrayu family, we will also run a few interview with the Karrayu.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics