Stem Cells Controversy

Great Essays
Since the discovery of stem cells in 1978, (Murnaghan) the controversy circulating around these cells has been immense. First off, let us define stem cells; stem cells in Merriam Webster dictionary are defined as “a simple cell in the body that is able to develop into any one of various kinds of cells (such as blood cells, skin cells, etc.)” (Merriam-Webster). Furthermore, there are two types of stem cells, embryonic and somatic, and between these two types of stem cells is where the real controversy stems. Somatic stem cells are those derived from adults or children, and embryonic stem cells are those derived from human embryos. The controversy surrounding these stem cells centers on the embryonic stem cells. The controversy is centered around …show more content…
Somatic stem cells, though limited, have been used for years in many successful procedures. The reason adult stem cells are so limited is due to the fact that their main roles are to maintain and repair the tissue in which they are found (What are adult stem cells?). Despite this, somatic stem cells have been used to help with brain cancer, ovarian cancer, testicular cancer, Chron’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, spinal cord injuries, and stroke damage (Adult Stem Cells - Therapies & Treatments List ). Moreover, they have been successful in making ears, noses, blood vessels, tear ducts, and windpipes in North London (Ears, Noses Grown from Stem Cells in Lab Dishes.). The results of the use of somatic stem cells should inspire us and excite us with the possibilities that could come from the use of embryonic stem cells. Looking at these results begs us to ask the question, if the limited somatic cells can do so much good, how much more could embryonic stem cells …show more content…
Just like any other medical procedure, the use of stem cells poses certain risks. Some of the risks include: stem cell (graft) failure, organ damage, infections, cataracts, infertility or new cancers. But these risks are not the only reasons why people are opposed to stem cells, in fact those risks are not even the main reason – ethical concerns are. The main ethical concern is that using embryonic stem cells is the murder of a baby, otherwise looked at as an innocent human. This thought is usually carried out by certain religious groups. However, this is a debate within itself – is it a human from the time of conception, fertilization, the third trimester, or birth? For this reason alone, we cannot base how unethical embryonic stem cell research is due to varying opinions. Legally, a fetus is not considered to be “alive” or a human until the time of birth (Definitions of Life and Death). Because of this law, we can assume as a nation that the use of embryonic stem cells is, in fact, not the killing of a human life. Despite what religious groups may say, we must remember that an entire, city, county, state, or country will never be in unison when it comes to religion and religious views and we therefore must focus on this issue from a neutral standpoint in which religion

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The intern sighed as she threw away, yet again the remains of a manipulated human embryo into the receptacle. As the intern began to clean the petri dish that once held such a small but significant life, she wondered how the rest of the scientists took killing an innocent life so lightly. Stem cell research is beneficial because it helps to further the research towards the cure of diabetes, cancer, other various diseases and illnesses, and the advancement in the growth of such stem cells also helps further the research in organ growth. However, some ways the scientists conduct and carry out stem cell research is neither morally correct nor practical. Stem cell research helps further the advancement in the curing of diseases such as diabetes…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stem cells are cells that have the ability to differentiate into many different types of specialized cells. However, stem cells are not where the controversial and ethical debates come from (NIH). Embryonic stem cells are the potentially life saving, while life ending, solution that flares controversial debates from scientists, religious leaders, politicians, and everyone in between. Embryonic stem cells are stem cells derived from an human embryos that are around five days old and have the ability to reproduce through cell division as well as differentiate into any type of cell (NIH). Embryonic stem cell research has great rewards with the possibilities of cell based therapies and cures of more than ten life altering diseases, but also has great consequences of cell rejection and the destroying of human embryos (NIH).…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is a scientific article with the purpose of giving the audience a view of the arguments for and against stem cell research. It emphasizes that scientist want society to understand the importance of embryonic stem cells. This paper opens up with multiple thesis questions such as, “what moral status does the human embryo have?” Counter arguments are provided after the initial claims such as, even though there is no specific point to consider an embryo living, during pre-implantation stages, there is no psychological, physical, and emotional properties, these properties are what makes personhood (3). The paper introduces the religious stances of major religions.…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    By comparing the process of embryonic stem cell research to that of adult stem cell research, it is shown that adult stem cell research is considered more right than embryonic stem cell research because adult stem cell research doesn’t cause harm to embryos, as compared to embryonic stem cell research. The fact that adult stem cell research doesn’t cause harm to embryos is reason enough for the majority of the public to support adult stem cell research, rather than embryonic stem cell research. Additionally, William Saunders states that “...the production of human beings for the sake of experimentation, research, or the harvesting of organs is morally wrong. Human beings are not disposable biological material.” (Saunders 2).…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fact that embryonic stem cells can do all these amazing things makes researchers want to gain access to them to discover new things. Researchers will try to turn these cells into anything in order to find a new, great discovery. These researchers…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stem cell therapy is used to control the growth of adult stem cells in a laboratory and use them to replace any dysfunctional cells within the body to prevent disease. An example of treatment would be replacing brain cells in order to treat Parkinson’s disease. Another goal is to develop insulin-producing cells for people suffering from diabetes. Scientists also hope to repair damage to the heart due to heart attacks. The public generally accepts adult stem cells because embryonic cells are not required, since the cells are taken from the…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The use of human embryonic stem cells has been hailed as the next major step in the battle against serious degenerative disorders such as diabetes and heart disease, and for some, debilitating for lethal neurological diseases, such as Parkinson’s. (Braude, Minger & Warwick). However this is a hotly debated issue. Ethical Dilemma The main controversy surrounding stem cell research isn’t about “if” it should be done or not, but rather what source of stem cells are okay to use and what methods are okay for obtaining them.…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While the scientific community often raves about the possibilities that embryonic stem cells pose for treatment of disease, most of the studies that have been performed using them have only shown minimal effectiveness. In fact, since these cells are totipotent and have not differentiated for any tissue type, these cells may not be good at detecting the environment they are placed in to know what kind of cell to become. Some researchers fear that these cells could actually be harmful if they do not become the correct cell type or if they do not stay in the location they were placed into (10). While these might simply be due to the lack of research using stem cells, it is not certain that these cells are actually as beneficial as they seem on first glance. If it turns out that these cells actually are not useful for treatments in the clinical setting, it would mean that numerous potential human lives were wasted for nothing.…

    • 1754 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because of a lack of legal clarity on this issue it has grown into a moral debate across the world. The world has been forced to think about some very tough questions like: Does life begin at fertilization, in the womb, or at birth? Is a human embryo equivalent to a human child? Does a human embryo have any rights? Is the destruction of a single embryo justified if it provides a cure for a countless number of patients?…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today’s scientists and the media, have made it an objective that Embryonic Stem Cells is the center and main focus of all Stem Cell Research, considering there are other varieties of stem cells out there. In spite of some of the negative controversies, stem cell research should be key to the future…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The topic of my argumentative research paper, is stem cell research. I am going to research and write about the importance and controversy surrounding stem cell research. I will discuss who are the support and activist groups, and a timeline of the United States laws. For my argumentative essay, I will explain some of the reasons why stem cell research is proclaimed to be unethical and why it can be a crucial procedure for abolishing and controlling diseases. I will provide details into which groups support research and why religions worldwide do not.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many ethical arguments for and against stem cell research and therapy, regarding issues such as the types of cells, the sources and techniques of production, and use of them. There are few concerns about research on or therapeutic uses of adult stem cells. However, embryonic stem (ES) cells have been associated with serious ethical debates. The use of this new science and technology for human reproduction has prompted ethics and policy disputes around the world. There are studies done that confirm the complexity of the issues raised by stem cell research.…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Another reason for the debate surrounding stem cell research, and their application in medicine, is people’s weariness of their ability to regenerate endlessly (Eve et al.). This is because the same ability to regenerate endlessly that makes them so valuable in regenerative medicine could make them deadly due to a potential mutation that would allow them to turn cancerous (Eve et al.). But new studies using malignant embryonic carcinoma cells - a cell very close to the stem cell- show that by putting the cells under retinoic acid (which comes from Vitamin A) treatments which forces the cells to differentiate into human neurons, which would allow biologists to “turn off” their dangerous properties (Eve et al.). Furthermore, it could be argued that stem cells only mimic other malignant cells and have no cancerous qualities themselves(Eve et al.). Like all new scientific discoveries, stem cell research and their use in medicine still have kinks to be worked out before they are perfect.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    7. How do the stakeholders, their contexts and their bioethical principles support your viewpoint? Explain. Doctors are responsible for treating and caring for their patients to the best of their ability. They also have moral and religious opinions which can play a part in their treatment decisions.…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Stem cell research can be difficult, costly, ineffective, and questionable in the realm of human morals. Perhaps the hardest component to overcome is the lack of an abundant stem cell source. Scientists encounter numerous obstacles isolating and growing specific stem cells. The process itself is very complex and tightly controlled. To complicate the process further, the cells must be a close match and delivered to the right location in the body.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays