Smittz Whistleblower Case Study

Improved Essays
6. When Smittz was asked why he called Councilmember Lincoln and informed him, he indicated he didn’t know how the whole “whistleblower process” worked but he thought telling an elected official would get the ball rolling.

Smittz should have referred to the City of San Jose Whistleblower Hotline and not have contacted Councilmember Lincoln. The Whistleblower Hotline’s purpose to provide the public and employees with an opportunity to express concerns such as: theft of City resources; record falsification, including timecards; misuse of City equipment or property; misuse or waste of City resources, including government funds; and improper activities by City officials, employees, and contractors. There are various ways to express concerns by calling, email, and regular mail. If Smittz did not want to be known as the Whistleblower, he may choose to remain anonymous.

7. When the Auditor interviewed Lazigai, he indicated he was not aware of the email from Smittz and he did not open it if it was sent, and he did not call Smittz telling him to handle it.
…show more content…
Although Smittz said he did, Lazigai said he had no knowledge of this incident. Therefore, Smittz lied about informing Lazigai. Smittz must have had a fear of conflict because there was no conversation between Smittz and Lazigai. Smittz must constructively and respectfully engage in conflict even if it is with the Deputy Director. Lazigai needs to be aware of the situation. The incident with Newton and Jones cannot remain submerged and hidden from

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Angelique Pinkstaff (“Pinkstaff”) began her employment with the City of Los Angeles with an original appointment as an Administrative Clerk (formerly Clerk Typist) with the Department of Transportation (DOT) on November 13, 2005. Pinkstaff received a 5th month probationary evaluation report in 2006 which is rated is “Standard”. Pinkstaff has no previous discipline or commendations. Case Summary: The current discipline relates to several incidents of Pinkstaff engaging in inappropriate conduct (sexual relations) at the workplace and during working hours; working less than full work days without using appropriate leave time; and leaving her assigned work location without appropriate reasons.…

    • 1947 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sean P. Brenn Case Study

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The next day Scott said she was led into a conference room where the HR Director, Faith Phillips, Steve Weber, who was from the County, and another person were sitting waiting for her. Weber said something about it not being a County problem and the Director called her a liar. The Director said he spoke to the constables and they didn’t know anything. The Director told her he wasn’t going to look into it any…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Bell California corruption scandal, this involved misappropriated funds. This was a story that hurt the citizens of Bell, California because the city officials took upon themselves to give themselves raises without the knowledge of its citizens of Bell California where there were 36,000 residents and one in four residents was below the poverty line. There were city officials who paid themselves inflated salaries of up to 100,000 dollars per year. A former powerful city manager Robert Rizzo was the one who established the scandal that rocked Bell California.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Case of Eileen Foster v. BofA and Countrywide The story starts March 7, 2007. Eileen Foster was promoted to Executive Vice President, Fraud Risk Management while she was working for the Countrywide Financial Corp. This role requires our whistleblower to supervise and monitor internal bank processes and mortgage fraud investigations, if needed, organize and send conclusion in the form of suspicious activity report to the U.S. Treasury as well as the board of directors. During her time, she learned that Full Spectrum Lending Division (FSL) managers in the Boston area were subject to several fraud allegations, she directed an investigation into the matter, found conclusive evidence of “egregious fraud”, including document and invoice forgery,…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mary Grasing Case Summary

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages

    time of the incident, therefore the administrative subpoena to Verizon landline would not have turned up Gabe’s home records; an additional subpoena would have been required to obtain this information. The conclusion of the Massachusetts State Police report states “A review of phone records does not support WILLOUGHBY’S claim that a phone call occurred between GABE and MARY GRASING on October 18, 2011 at approximately 4:00 P.M.” Without seeing the additional records, if any, Mason was in possession of, it is unclear how this conclusion could be drawn. What analysis of Mary Grasing’s home records does show is that Marshard’s landline and Gabe’s landline were in contact with the Mary Grasing between October 17, 2011 and October 19, 2011, this is consistent with Willoughby and BenDavid’s version of the facts. These records should have…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Spoke to James R Lapeosa (NJ DL # L05133837910462) who stated that he had been having ongoing neighbor dispute. He was advised to call and report issues right away when it happens as he could not remember exactly what happened. Lapeosa was advised to speak with the courts in regards to signing a complaint.…

    • 54 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Question 2: A. Roughed Up at Recess: Pg. 74-76 In the case study, the WITI-TV received multiple phone calls regarding children being bullied and "beaten up" by classmates on school playgrounds. After the reports had arose, a reporter by the name of Bob Segall began investigating the issue by conducting surveillance at one of the troubled schools.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whistleblowing: Although bureaucratic lore commonly holds that uncovering unlawful waste, fraud, or abuse will result in chilling isolation, impossible job transfers, or other cruel and unusual forms of recrimination, there are still ways to fight back. There are means with which public servants can force a change in an organization’s course without being forced out of a job (Holzer & Schwester, 2011). As the Public Accountability Committee members do not have any direct city influence, the committee could be fair and impartial in their decision-making…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Anita Hill vs. Clarence Thomas case has been labeled as one of the most controversial cases in history. Clarence Thomas was a 43 year old judge who had just been nominated to the Supreme Court in 1991. Soon after he was nominated, Anita Hill accused him of sexual assault in the workplace during the time that they worked together at the Equal Employment Opportunities Commission. As controversial as this case may have been it only hindered Clarence Thomas’ way up to the Supreme Court. The case should have been looked into more thoroughly and meticulously.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion, many maritime laws and safety standards were created and updated to prevent the safety of passengers and keep as many people alive and safe at sea after the Titanic sunk, and even though it was a catastrophic event, we have learned much from it about safety. Marc Issacs, a maritime lawyer, said, ” The sinking [of the Titanic] wasn’t necessarily the wake-up call, but it was a big momentous event that reminded people that safety had to be dealt…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Whistleblowing has been a topic of discussion in business for over a hundred years. While there are federally mandated regulations in place to protect whistleblowers, some still argue that whistleblowing is wrong. The main argument of these naysayers, like Norman Bowie and Sissela Bok, is that whistleblowing is an act of disloyalty to the company. In Ronald Duska’s article Whistleblowing II, he takes opposition to this stance. Throughout his article he makes three main points: employees have no obligation to remain loyal to a company, the primary function of business is profit, and the analogy between business and team is erroneous.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the case study of Gilbane Gold, David Jackson, the engineer responsible for waste treatment in Z-Corp, was put in a very difficult situation. In the beginning, David was getting results from Frank’s waste water discharge tanks that showed that they have been releasing arsenic and lead at higher levels than what the city allows. The waste water ends up into the popular and profitable sludge product called Gilbane Gold. Gilbane Gold is sold as a fertilizer to farmers for about 75 years. David mentions his concern of this in the monthly meeting.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that the auditors in this case, Ernst & Whinney, should have great blame in not having the sufficient information and knowledge to fall into the pressure of the bribes committed by Minkow and analyze the fraud that was occurring. The upper management in ZZZZ Best made the financial information seem perfectly fine, therefore the auditors were unable to identify any miscalculations that would then lead to fraud. Minkow and his company for years kept on staling the fact that his insurance business had an actual positive cash flows system occurring. This would keep the auditors from seeing the main problem concerning the fraud that was started from the very beginning by Minkow and his carpet/insurance business. As this wasn’t enough fake information conducted by…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An Intern’s Dilemma Have you ever felt that something was not quite right? As an intern Mark was asked to do something he just did not feel comfortable doing. He knew he needed to complete his internship, but was not comfortable lying to the companies he was seeking information from about who he was representing. Mark had a lot to process through and decide how he would proceed. He needed to decide what was ethical, how his ethics aligned with the corporations, and how he would respond to the request.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. From the perspective of a college or university, is there a difference between internal law and external law? What are the kinds of sources of law of each kind? Discuss.…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays