J.J.C. Smart maintains that there are two types of utilitarianism and that one is the correct and true form of utilitarianism and the other is not. Smart gives many reasons why one is the right version and the other is wrong but ultimately, there is an objection to the version he defends. Smart believes that there are two types of utilitarianism, restricted and extreme. Restricted utilitarianism has moral rules that everyone must follow even if breaking the rule means greater utility. Extreme utilitarianism disregards the rules as long as more utility will come out of it. Extreme utilitarianism is the “real” utilitarianism, or so Smart claims. Smart defends the idea that extreme utilitarianism is the right version because utilitarianism’s
