John M. Mcpherson's For Cause And Comrades

Improved Essays
The Civil War was a war unlike many others that occurred throughout that span of the United State of America’s History. The war was fought between the citizens between the northern states and the southern states. Some call this war a war that pitted brother against brother. The fighting broke out among people that had common qualities, but different views when it came to political, social and economic issues. For instance, the debate on State’s rights or slavery was heavily debated prior and during the Civil War from the early to mid-1800. In the book, For Cause and Comrades by John M. McPherson, the stories of enlisted soldiers of the Union and Confederate Army are explained in detail. The book goes into detail on what influences drew men …show more content…
Since this war was fought in only the United States, a man’s duty and loyalty was to his section of the country. Many soldiers in this war wanted to have a part or a hand in the action. When they were in the state of inaction, it could be considered dishonorable, and that was something no individual or regiment wanted thrusted upon them. In the book, the author states “A South Carolina cavalry officer whose company had been on picket far from the scene of First Manassas felt shame when he encountered those who had fought there” (31). The shame came from his cavalry’s inaction and how others on the confederate side were engaged in action. Fighting for a cause and something you believed in was considered upholding honor, where inaction did nothing for the cause at hand. Honor and responsibility played a large role in the enlistment of soldiers on the Union side as well. A physician from the Kentucky side claimed “I will not enlist for a period longer than three months unless my country needs me, in which event I would enlist for life” (23). In this case, the physician felt a responsibility to fight for the objectives of the Union.
In conclusion, the book The Cause and Comrades explains the factors that were responsible for drawing men of the northern and southern regions to the Union and Confederate armies. Those factors included religion, ideology and honor which played their own independent and large part in getting men to sign up as soldiers in the Civil War and continue fighting that war that lasted longer than anyone had

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Up until the Emancipation Proclamation, there were many different reasons for why the Civil War was being fought, because no one would acknowledge the real underlying cause. The Union was anti-slavery and the Confederacy was pro-slavery, but neither acknowledged that this was a cause of the war. The Emancipation Proclamation “freed” slaves in rebellious, Confederate, territory. Many southerners disagreed with the Emancipation Proclamation and kept their slaves because it was not a law that they were free. President Lincoln was under serious fire for the document, but he said it was “a necessity of war, to weaken the enemy.” The blacks that were able to escape slavery found refuge in the Union army.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He did this research to find depth in the argument of the cause of the civil war and that is exactly what he did by using many different people and their personal experiences during this time. When the South Carolina Convention happened and they passed their ordinance Charleston became a central factor of importance during this time. They created their own government and then had to become aware of state rights, economy, and other laws with their newfound government known as the Convention. This convention creation was made to be followed by others to eventually “dissolve the Union” politics were very involved in the turmoil between the North and South. With that being said, there were many events during this time so Dew tries to touch on the more important topics in detail to create proof of his argument in the book in that “slavery and race was the heart of the matter” (pg.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mcpherson’s For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War, interprets not what was previously expected from this novel, including the political and militaristic motivations, but rather the personal, and humanistic side of the Civil War. Slavery, being commonly interpreted as the highlighted factor concerning all things related to the Civil War, the assumption was that in all sincerity, this was the cause, sustentation, and motivation for War between the North and the South. But as McPherson bases his thesis on, with the letters he has chosen to do extensive reviews on, he shows what sustained the soldiers throughout the phases of war. The book is filled with constant references to Mcpherson’s sources, giving backing to his conclusions.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book “Apostles of Disunion,” by Charles B. Dew, we are presented with ideas of secession, slavery and racism. The overall goal in this book was to prove the causes of the Civil War. We are given experiences and background from southerner, Charles B. Dew in order to justify the underlying reason for the cause of the War. During this time period of 1860-1861 there was a lot of talk as to what the real cause of the Civil War was, in which there have been many theories and hypothesis’ from historians as to what was the true reasoning was behind it all. Being a southerner, Dew is passionate about his facts, and researches to better support his argument.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was a power struggle. Throughout all of history, it has been perceived that slavery was at the forefront of the causes of the Civil War. However, there is a multitude of causes and meanings of the Civil War from the perspectives of both the North and South. Unfortunately, in war the cause in which soldiers are fighting for can often be blurred due to the gruesome nature of the battles and inhumane treatment of fellow human beings. Soldiers in the Civil War and citizens of other countries had contrasting understandings of what the war was truly being fought for.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Key People and Causes of the American Civil War A lot of individuals accept that the significant reason for the Civil War was a direct result of subjection or slavery (Thomas, 2). Truly there were a few components that including about territorial differing qualities, contrasting elucidation of the constitution, bondage, state 's correct, sectionalism, particular regional extension, prompted the Civil War (Kingseed, 3). Mr. John Brown,…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The technique that the North used was calling all slaves who were in the South to join to them. On the other hand, Southern people did not have any technique to face the Northern army and to make them lose the war. Also, the Southern people were afraid they would lose the war if the slaves continued running from…

    • 2221 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas along with others agreed that John Calhoun’s legislation would undoubtedly fuel a developing civil war in the States. However, his opposition to secession and war made him unfavorable and he lost his reelection (42-43). Although, Thomas did not fight in the war because of old age, his life ended with his children fighting an unimaginable war. He never saw the end of war, but he did see the consequences that the war brought to an untrained army fighting an industrialized one with more…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even at the end of the war the South did not see the slaves as a free group of people, they resented the Union, the damage they inflicted on their homes and land and they abhorred the new working structure the government created. The main objective of the Civil War was not to abolish slavery, but protect the Union and reunite the nation. In the end the free slaves sought to reunite, not the nation, but reunite with their lost relatives and family that they were torn apart…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It was slavery as a whole, they just did not agree that slavery deserved a part in the United States as a whole.This war was a significant part of America and it took place between 1860-1865 when the Southern states began to drift away from the Union. This War was a significant part of history and involved many key points which helped shaped…

    • 2436 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays