Robert J. Butler rose to the planter class on his success apprehending runaways with his dogs. Louis Schiller, a black man from Hamburg, would testify in 1876 that …show more content…
While the Census of 1820 did not record the occupations of heads of households or any dollar value of the individual’s estate, it did record the amount of human property in each household since they could be counted as two-thirds of a person for the purpose of representation in Congress. In rural South Carolina, this was a clear indicator of an individual’s social class. The Edgefield District household of John and Elizabeth Butler to which Robert was born in 1815 was recorded in 1820 as including twelve enslaved people. While the family could certainly not be described as poor, a planter family would have more than twelve forced laborers.
When John died in 1831, Robert as the eldest surviving son inherited his father’s property. Three years later, Robert married a Mary Catherine Hall. In the 1840 Census, the household of Robert Butler is listed as including thirteen enslaved people. By 1850, Robert and Catherine Butler’s household included six children, Catherine’s mother-in-law and 28 enslaved