Roper V. Simmons Case Study

Improved Essays
In the Supreme Court case, Roper v. Simmons, Christopher Simmons at the age 17 while in junior in high school murdered a Fenton, Missouri woman Shirley Crook. (Roper v. Simmons, 2005) Simmons committed burglary and murder by breaking and entering, the Crook’s residence and tying up victim Shirley Crook, and throwing her body off a bridge. (Roper v. Simmons, 2005) Simmons advised is accomplice Charles Benjamin and John Tessmer, that they could "get away with it" because they were minors. (Roper v. Simmons, 2005) The Fenton police after receiving information of Simmons' involvement, arrested Simmons at his junior high school and took him to the police station. The Fenton’s police read Simmons his Miranda rights; however, Simmons waived his right …show more content…
Simmons, 2005) Did the police officer inform Simmons that he could refuse to answer any questions and leave whenever he felt the need? During an almost two hours of interrogation, Simmons confessed to the murder and agreed to perform a videotaped reenactment at the crime scene. (Roper v. Simmons, 2005) "Simmons was outside the criminal jurisdiction of Missouri's juvenile court system" (Roper v. Simmons, 2005, p. 1). Therefore, the state charged Simmons with burglary, kidnapping, stealing, and murder in the first degree. After, Simmons' confession and the videotaped reenactment of the crime, Simmons was tried as an adult. Before trial Simmons discussed the crime in advance and bragged about it later. Therefore, the state called no witnesses and sought the death penalty. However, “the state called Shirley Crook's husband, daughter, and two sisters, who presented moving evidence of the devastation her death had brought to their lives” (Roper v. Simmons, 2005, p. …show more content…
Simmons filed an appeal and subsequent petitions for state and federal post-conviction relief, which were rejected. “The Court held, in Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U. S. 304, that the Eighth Amendment, applicable to the States through the Fourteenth Amendment, prohibits the execution of a mentally retarded person” (Roper v. Simmons, 2005, para. 1). Therefore, Simmons filed a new petition for state post-conviction relief, arguing that Atkins’ reasoning established that the Constitution prohibits the execution of a juvenile who was under 18 when he committed his crime” (Roper v. Simmons, 2005, para. 1). Simmons had no prior convictions in juvenile court; therefore, the prosecutor and defense counsel addressed Simmons' age, which the trial judge had instructed the jurors they could consider as a mitigating factor. (Roper v. Simmons, 2005) The Eighth Amendment may not guarantee pretrial release; however, it forbids cruel and unusual punishment and determines that cruel and unusual relationship to the standards that society sets. The Eighth Amendment right takes a back seat to society's interest in the supervision and control of juveniles. (Elrod & Ryder, 2014) “The Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments forbid the execution of offenders who were under the age of 18 when their crimes were committed” (Justia, 2005, para. 1). Juveniles are more vulnerable to police interrogation due to their extreme “immaturity and inexperience,” which

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Simmons obtained new counsel because of ineffective assistance of counsel, but was denied the motion for post conviction relief. Issue Presented: Whether it is lawful under the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution to execute a juvenile offender who was older than 15 but younger than 18 when he committed a capital…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brenton Butler Case Study

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Over the course of the years, many have been wrongfully convicted and accused of crimes they did not commit. The mission of the judicial system is to prove your guilt and if they can successfully do so beyond a reasonable doubt, then you will be convicted of that crime. Everyone walks into the court innocent until proven guilty, but unfortunately some proven guilty people are still very much innocent. In one case where this so happened to be true was during the case of Brenton Butler. Brenton Butler was accused of allegedly robbing and murdering an elderly woman at a nearby hotel in his hometown Jacksonville, Florida.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cole Cannon Case Summary

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The U.S. Supreme Court would judge the case on whether sentencing a fourteen-year-old to life in prison without parole violates the Eight and Fourteenth Amendment’s prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment (Carrizales & Schultz, n.d.). Miller’s counsel argued that sentencing a fourteen-year-old to life without parole without considering certain factors such as his age violates the Eight and Fourteenth Amendments’ ban on cruel and unusual punishment (Carrizales & Schultz, n.d.). The state of Alabama argued that punishing a fourteen-year-old to life without parole does not violate the Eight or Fourteenth Amendment, but serves a justifiable penological goal when the crime is aggravated murder (Carrizales & Schultz,…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Roper Vs Hammons Essay

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the Supreme Court case, Roper v Simmons, the justices argued at what age does a person become culpable for their crimes and should receive adult punishments. The respondent, Christopher Simmons, was 17 years old when he and a friend broke into a woman’s home, robbed and tortured her, then killed her by throwing her off a bridge. After being convicted of the crime, Simmons was sentenced to the death penalty, which he eventually revoked. When the case made it to the Supreme Court in 2004, the court came to a 5-4 ruling that executing minors was “cruel and unusual” punishment, thus violating the Constitution (Roper). This case overruled the 1989 case, Stanford v. Kentucky, which previously decided that capital punishment on capital offenders below the age of 18 was not cruel or unusual (Stanford).…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In reference to Atkins versus Georgia, The Supreme Court eventually ruled that by executing the mental challenge did violate the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments pertaining to cruel and unusual punishment (Legal Information Institute, 2017). Simmons’s counsel argued that the Constitution forbids the execution of a juvenile who is under the age of 18 when a crime was committed. Simmons filed a new petition for a state post-conviction relief, arguing that Atkins’ established reasoning that the Constitution forbids the execution of a youth who was under the age of 18 when they committed a crime (FindLaw, 2017). Nine years later, the Missouri Supreme Court finally reviewed Simmons’ case in 2003 (Legal Information Institute, 2017). The Missouri Supreme Court acknowledged and reversed Simmons’ death sentence to life imprisonment without the eligibility of parole (FinbLaw, 2017).…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction In this paper, I will discuss the key facts, issues, and court holdings of the Fare v. Michael C. case. Discussion The Fare v. Michael C. case was heard before the United States Supreme Court in 1979, following an appeal referencing the Miranda Warnings issued to the juvenile defendant (Elrod & Ryder, 2014). At the time of the arrest in February 1976 in Van Nuys, California, the suspect, Michael C., was just over sixteen years old (FindLaw, n.d.)…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Re Gault Case Essay

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This case changed my outlook far as execution of juveniles. This case involved Simmons a young man that had a murder charge. I feel at age 17 you should be aware of our actions and with the fact that he bragged about the killing was an eye-opener to think of the possibility that this individual could have had mental issues or suffered some type of abuse as a youngster, that may have caused him to carry out this act of violence. I don’t feel he should have been executed due to these possibilities; however, a tough sentence should have been enacted. This case changed the development of sentencing anyone under the age of 18 to death it was ruled cruel and usual punishment.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The case posed questions regarding the conduct of an inmate who participated in assisting fellow prisoners in planning the appeals for a writ of habeas corpus and any other legal papers. The amendment in scrutiny was the 28 U.S.C ~ 2242 that violates such prisoner actions. C. 384 US 436 (1966) Miranda v. Arizona Argued 2/28/66; 3/1/66; 3/2/66 Decided Jun 13, 1966 On March 1963, Ernesto Miranda was arrested for the allegations of rape and kidnapping.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Death Penalty is a highly contested issue in the United States that has been put forth to the Supreme Court many times. The Court operated under the assumption that is due process is observed, life can be taken from an individual. However, the court 's opinion of the death penalty has changed over time. In 1972, the Court considered Furman v. Georgia, a case involving a white man who murdered a black man.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Attorneys who deal with Civil Rights and Constitutional issues attend to predicaments concerning the Eighth Amendment every day. Still though, it leads you to think “what exactly is a “cruel and unusual punishment” within the meaning of the Eighth Amendment?” (What…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Simmons, I disagree with the Supreme Court’s decision in favor of Simmons. I believe that Simmons deserves the death penalty, there was no reason in Simmons’ claims and agreement about how the execution of minors violate the prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment. Yet, the defendant premeditated the crime and did not consider the victims’ life. The defendant enters into the victim’s home, robbed the victim, then tied up the victim and threw the victim off a bridge. In addition, the defendant stated that he assured that he would get away with the crime because he was minor.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Has the court sentenced the minor due to the evidence presented and the extent of the case? (Aggravated Murder). Miller argues, these amendments have been violated because of his age, while the state argues, the crime was determined aggravated murder, and so sentencing is justifiable and appropriate. Throughout the trail similar cases such as Roper v. Simmons (2005), and Graham v. Florida (2010), worked in Miller’s favor by using the information in the trail. Roper v. Simmons was a cased based on, if juveniles were able to be sentenced to the death penalty due to a murder.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The West Memphis Three and Labelling Theory On May 5, 1993, three eight year old boys named Steve Branch, Christopher Byers and Michael Moore, were reported missing in West Memphis, Arkansas. The following day, their bodies were found in Robin Hood woods, tied and mutilated. In early 1994, three suspects named Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley Jr. were convicted of murdering the three boys. Damien, Jason and Jessie were referred to as the “West Memphis Three”.…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Darlie Routier case is one of the most perplexing cases of accused filicide. Routier was accused and convicted of one count of capital murder in the killing of her two sons Damon age 5, and Devon age 6. Routier claimed that an intruder entered her home as she slept in bed with her two sons while sleeping beside her. Routier’s husband Darin and her son Drake (an infant of 7 months at the time) were unharmed in the incident. To complicate matters more Darlie Routier was injured severely in the alleged attack, with several stab wounds and a slashed throat.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Therapy Case Study

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Introduction Ian is an eighteen year old male, referred by the Juvenile Justice system for therapeutic counseling due to his conviction as a sexual offender. As a social worker reading Ian case file, Ian’s case history starts after his mother’s death when he was five-years old. Ian’s sister and her husband moved into the family home to assist Ian’s father with his care. While in the home, Ian’s brother-n-law murdered his 18-month old daughter, Ian’s niece. Ian mistakenly confessed to the crime because he hit his niece earlier with a toy.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays