Similarities Between Black Swan And The Paranoid Schizophrenic Mind

Superior Essays
Black Swan and The Paranoid Schizophrenic Mind Mental health represents a wide range of disorders that tend to have a bad reputation in society. The stigma towards these disorders represents a misguidance and social lack of education regarding the truth behind the problem. The media as well as cinema photography tend to over dramatize and add unrealistic portrayals making the disorder look worse than it really is. In the film Black Swan, a ballerina by the name of Nina falls tragic to a wide range of disorders in order to become the perfect dancer. Black Swan represents the downward spiral into the paranoid schizophrenic mind of a women who is looking for perfection in herself, acceptance from her mother and a way of proving her self worth …show more content…
While given this opportunity, she is faced with the issue of not being edgy enough to dance the part of the black swan, and is constantly being told to be less stiff and to add sexuality to her dancing (Villarreal, C., 2010). She begins to unravel when a new dancer is introduced and threatens the chances of Nina remaining the lead dancer of the play. The new dancer, Lily, lacks the skills that Nina has but represents the edgier side that is needed to perform the dance of the black swan. As a result of Nina’s insecurities and need for perfection, this causes her to start slipping from reality. Nina starts having vivid hallucinations that seem as though they have happened but in reality were just a figment of her mental state. She begins hallucinating acts of violence and sexual content that involves herself and others. In the process of slipping from reality, she is able to finally free herself from her perfections and allow her dark side to come out. She appears on opening night of the performance and performs the best performance of her career but subsequently becomes her last performance. Her hallucinations and paranoia of possibly not getting to dance on opening night created a disillusion of characters within herself and ultimately caused her to harm herself unknowingly back stage. Nina, not realizing what she had done to herself, dances the last act …show more content…
Nina could be mistakenly diagnosed with Dissociative Identity Disorder because of the role she plays for work (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). She is conflicted by playing the persona of two different characters, the white swan and the black swan. The white swan is innocent and honest while the black swan is violent, careless, and sexual. Nina is the white swan and struggles to play the part of the black swan. In the process of transforming herself into the black swan, Nina struggles with dynamic of maintaining her innocent strict ways while letting go and becoming the free spirit of the black swan (Aronofsky, D., 2011). The struggle ultimately is too much and she breaks down. It is easy to mistake her disorder for Dissociative Identity Disorder but the diagnosis of schizophrenia is more appropriate because of the delusions and the hallucinations (Villarreal, C.,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In efforts to loosen her up, he sexually harasses her and tells her to go touch herself. Leroy also employs a new ballerina in their group, a free spirit called Lily. Although Lily is not as skilled in the technical parts, her personality makes her perfect for the role of the black swan. Leroy frequently tells Nina to model after Lily, making her extremely jealous and paranoid that she will end up losing the lead role. As a result, Nina’s mental state goes into freefall and she is no longer able to function.…

    • 2380 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A stigma of mental disorders is that they go hand and hand with a violent disposition. In Black Swan Nina violently lashes out multiple times throughout the film. Due to her paranoid delusion it makes sense that Nina may have had violent tendencies, but a violent personality is not linked to psychosis disorders. Another major criticism was that the film failed to provided a diagnosis or treatment of the Nina’s mental disorder and psychotic break down. I, however, would argue that this proved to be the most powerful aspect of the whole movie.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Her conscious overturned her, and she could no longer bear the guilt. Although she appears so evil, what she is really doing is trying to work herself up to the pitch of committing murder, to psyche herself up for the dreadful task. Lady Macbeth’s personality change led to her suicide. Her thoughts were justified for a short while, only until she became aware of her actions, resulting in suicide. Lady Macbeth wanting to break traditional gender roles usually winds up in trouble.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nina Sayers is a shy and frigid girl. She is a member of a ballet company in New York City. The company holds an audition for the piece, Black Swan, under a sexually aggressive director. The variation of the piece requires Nina Sayers to be both, the black and white swan. This causes stress to Nina because her personality is different than what is required to be the “Black Swan”.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mona was deeply afraid of losing practically her only friend, so she created an alter ego known as “A”, who was seemingly evil and out to ruin most of the girl’s lives. This is a major sign of fear of abandonment, but it doesn’t end here because shortly after attacking the girls Mona tries to make Hannah feel bad for reuniting with her old friends. Manipulating her by crying and telling Hannah that she is a selfish, worthless friend. After manipulating Hannah to go back to focusing on her, you can tell that she bounces back to her normal self and does not act like a total nut case anymore. As the show goes on, Mona or “A”, begins to become more impulsive and…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bree is the one who makes the bad decisions and she has more fun which is why Kristina ends up doing so many terrible things. When she meets guys or people with drugs she calls herself Bree. This is important because she has an alter ego that is taking over her life and that alter ego is influenced by crystal meth. She loses all of the friends she had before the visit because she no longer cares what her friends have to say and she finds everything they say irrelevant. She no longer wants to do the things she used to love to do.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Later, she starts to recognize that after all the harm she and Macbeth have made, nothing good has come of it. She says, “Naught’s had, all 's spent,/ Where our desire is got without content” (3.2.5-6). This indicates that she is regretting all she has done because it has not given her the power and prestige she wanted, and it is only making her feel worse about herself. Lastly, a big turning point in Lady Macbeth’s stability was at the banquet when Macbeth started to talk to the ghost in front of all the guests. She doesn’t really know how to even handle the situation because Macbeth is almost admitting to all the crimes he has done.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, Claude McKay excavates the true meaning for her actions through the use of diction and metaphors. Though the poem started as a description of a beautiful Harlem dancer with talent, by the end of the poem it is apparent that she is actually very unhappy due to traumatic experiences of objectification. Being treated as only an object that is appealing to the eyes of others caused her to be subjective and stuck in her fantasies, which only distanced her further from her own…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the kunsterroman novel, The Awakening, by Kate Chopin, the protagonist, Edna has to make a lethal decision to overcome her inner conflict. Edna does not fit in with her society. She describes her marriage as an “accident” (Chopin, 24). She does not show love towards her husband and children. Her friends confuse her about society, one pulls her in and one pulls her out, and she gets so disturbed that she decided to take herself out of it in a whole by killing herself.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Miller’s Why I Wrote the Crucible Miller says, “Fear doesn 't travel well; just as it can warp judgment, its absence can diminish memory 's truth” (Miller). Hysteria—a mass of fear and excitement is what leads Abigail Williams to falsely accuse Elizabeth Proctor of witchcraft. Abigail Williams selfishly tries to rid Elizabeth Proctor so she can fulfill her dreams and be with Proctor herself. Miller’s motif of hysteria in The Crucible is evident through Abigail’s faulty logic in blindly accusing an innocent woman. Due to fear of the unknown and not being able to have the life she’s always dreamed of, Abigail blames Elizabeth of witchcraft, creating a mass of hysteria that spreads through Salem like wildfire.…

    • 1770 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays