Similarities And Similarities Between The Salem Witch Trials And The Mccarthy Trials

Improved Essays
History 1301 Enrichment Paper 3 History tends to repeat itself. Various amounts of people tend to believe that the 1950 's McCarthy trial is a resemblance of the 1692-Salem Witch Trials, for the cases were rendered as false and filled with a lot of accusations and invalid truths to no-proof at all. Primarily the reason for theses cases,was to blame others for their own gain and respect. Both cases within the McCarthy and the girls in Salem, blamed others for their own personal gain, respect, and honor. Both trials were built off of covered up lies to gain attention and an higher ranking within the community. The Salem-Witch trials of 1692, random people were accused of being witches and were being used as an escape-route for societal problems. and then a similar event in 1950 happened, for in the trial of 1950 people were being blamed as communist to hide society 's problems with this case. The more current trial of 1950 's McCarthy trial starts off the setting in Wheeling, West Virginia, a man named Joseph McCarthy blamed about 205 people of being communists in the early 1950 's. He was a senator believed that by indicting …show more content…
Again, the Salem witch trials and the McCarthy hearings were different times in history, but with the same accusatory methods and historical moments. These cases both involved numerous amounts of innocent victims who were blamed for being something that they were not, and was also very horrendous and heinous to be involved in both these cases for the day and age in which they were living. Their primary goal was to gain reputation from others who did not really give them such respect, and wanting such respect and attention at the cost of other people lives. Both, cases were; filled with deceit, misleading, and ultimately unfair and unreasonable to the people who were effected by it. But in all I hope that such history does not repeat itself according to these two similar

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Although they share similar details, The Salem Witchcraft Trials and the Communist Red Scare are both things that we, as people, often do not like to think too much about as being part of our past. Part of that being that there were many false accusations made on people who were wholly innocent in their actions during times in the Salem Witchcraft Trials. People who were accused were urged to confess even if they were innocent. (Miller, Beers, and Odell 1233). As they were urged to confess, peer pressure became a major issue.…

    • 1932 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People say history is learned to make sure the same mistakes are not repeated. However, this is not the case for American history; in America, citizens have experienced similar negative events. For instance, the Salem Witch Trials occurred in the 1690s, and McCarthyism arose in the 1950s. These time periods both involve people inaccurately accusing others, being put on trial, and often having innocent citizens punished or put to death. Arthur Miller saw how unfair and unreasonable the government was being, when he was one of the many individuals to be called to Congress to give a list of suspicious people.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abuse of power withinThe Crucible was a significant theme that contributed to the storyline and plot of the play. Many characters within the play who were elevated to temporary positions of authority tended to use this fluctuation in power to manipulate others for their own benefit and greed. Abigail was largely responsible for this as she used and abused her newfound power to accuse Elizabeth Proctor of witchcraft so she could destroy John and Elizabeth’s marriage in order to have John all to herself. Other characters that also abused their power were the Putnam’s, who accused Rebecca Nurse of witchcraft so they could gain her land and have someone to blame for their lack of healthy babies. The idea of abuse of power often goes hand in hand with the idea of characters becoming empowered, however, abuse of power was a more substantial theme throughout, The Crucible, because it was this misuse that caused the deaths and altercations and some characters whom abused power did not come from a previously powerless position.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Accusations led to the hysteria and misinformation led to people believing things that may or may not be true. Both the Salem Witch trials and McCarthy trials happened at different times in history but have similar outcomes. Many people became affected with the trials and their livelihood was destroyed. Both trials had deceitful, manipulative, lying people that made things really bad. The outcome of these trials made them known as two of the most important events in history.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This prevailed during The Salem witch trials and the McCarthyism era. According to The Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) article, the video What is McCarthyism? And how did it happen? by Ellen Schrecker, and the video Hunting the Communists! - Joseph McCarthy l THE COLD WAR, if you didn’t answer the courts, “confess” to being a communist or incriminate your friends; you risked jail, losing your job, and, or getting blacklisted.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the Salem witch trials, Abigail convicted many innocent people of dealing with the Devil. The smallest relevance to the Devil, including Mary Warren’s doll with a needle in it, was used as substantial proof of association. Not many had the willpower to challenge her out of fear and those who did were convicted. After WWII, in response to the growing concern of communistic penetration in the United States allowed for unsubstantial accusations in government. Joseph McCarthy, like Abigail began accusing people and changing lives for worse.…

    • 2318 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Understanding the recognition among the New England settlers that witchcraft was prevalent is crucial. Salem was beset with political disputes and internal strife and discord. Land conflicts and personal feuds were common. Some scholars claim that the Puritans felt that they had disappointed God and deserved to be castigated for their sins. Some historians say that the role of the clergy was principally responsible for arousing the people and making them expect compensation; others credit the clergy with ending the whole ordeal.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The magistrates could have seen her frustration as guilt and that alone could have altered how the court would have decide if she was guilty enough to be punished in front of her peers. These witch trials were biased based off of how the women were brought to the public due to their questionable history with the people around town. The witch trials in the sixteenth century sparked a vast movement of people pointing the blame at others that they had a lot of issues with. It started in Salem and spread like a disease that was passed to the people in Stamford Connecticut. The women that were older, kept to themselves and caused rifts in their neighborhoods, were targeted way more than the women who were young and were higher up in the social scene.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As if the Salem Witch Trials did not seem absurd enough as a standalone, the McCarthy Hearings were dubbed “witch-hunts” in reference to the parallels between the mass fear and spread of accusations of the Salem Witch Trials, along with the use of circular logic in that in each scenario, one was considered guilty until they admitted that the accuser was correct in their condemnations (Sowers). Hundreds of thousands of Americans in the 1940s and 1950s believed Senator Joseph McCarthy’s accusations of Communism without any solid evidence, spiraling even deeper into the hysteria by accusing others and making the lives of the suspects difficult— for example, some would never be able to get a job again (“McCarthyism”). Even when citizens involved in the Salem Witch Trials or McCarthy Hearings began to see the reality of the situations and began to oppose them, such when Salem citizen Burroughs continued to try to prove his innocence by praying the Lord’s Prayer flawlessly before his execution at Gallows Hill (which witches were believed unable to do), the leaders of the events would do or say something to conform the people’s opinions to what the leaders wanted or would benefit from (“An…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Salem Witch Trials- Real Vs. Truth The Salem witch trials were trials against friends and family for the only reason of fear, mischief and misconception. In the years 1692 and 1693, there were many court dates and accusations of men and women who were “seen” with the devil, which caused many executions out of fear. The event brought on stories such as the well-known play The Crucible by Arthur Miller and novels such as Susannah Morrow by Megan Chance. However, despite the use of real people, events and locations, how much of these stories are true and what was dramatized to appeal to audiences?…

    • 2069 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays