Similarities And Differences Between The Crucible And The Scarlet Letter

Superior Essays
Arthur Miller and Nathaniel Hawthorne each left a clear mark in the world of American literature with their stories. Even though Miller’s book, The Crucible, and Hawthorne’s book, The Scarlet Letter, were written over one hundred years apart, many elements of the stories can be compared and contrasted. The books share the same setting, a number of themes, and an important symbol, but the plots, point of views, and other symbols are completely different. In general, The Crucible tends to be a more fact-driven book (Miler vii), while The Scarlet Letter is completely fictional and contains many symbols for the reader to decipher. The Crucible by Arthur Miller and The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne have many similarities, but also many differences. …show more content…
In The Crucible, John Proctor, the protagonist, has committed adultery and is tormented by his sin. Eventually, he confesses that he had an affair with Abigail, the antagonist of the story, and that he spoke with the devil (falsely) in order to save his wife, Elizabeth (Miller 102). These actions were very similar to the actions of Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale in The Scarlet Letter. Hester and Dimmesdale had an affair together as well, but a judge convicts only Hester of the crime. Though Hester, the protagonist, continues to struggle with her sin, the publicity of her crime eventually helps her move on. However, Dimmesdale’s hidden sin constantly tortures him, much like John Proctor. At the end of the book, Dimmesdale ends up confessing his sin to the city before he dies. Both Proctor and Dimmesdale give up everything, particularly their public reputation, to free themselves from their sins. On the other hand, antagonists Abigail Williams from The Crucible and Roger Chillingworth from The Scarlet Letter are very different. Abigail Williams is a girl who creates a fictional world of witchcraft in order to cover for much lighter sin: dancing naked in the woods. By lying and accusing women in her town to be witches, Abigail causes nineteen women to be hung and one man to be killed by pressing with stones. These actions were all taken in order to keep herself out of trouble. Conversely, Roger Chillingworth acts to take revenge in The Scarlet Letter. Chillingworth is angry at Hester, who is secretly his wife, for committing adultery with Dimmesdale. He decides to use his anger to internally torture Dimmesdale without Dimmesdale even realizing by becoming his personal doctor (Hawthorne 68). Chillingworth is the most evil character in The Scarlet Letter by far, creating psychological horrors that torment Dimmesdale and Hester, who doesn’t want

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The play is by Arthur Miller who wanted to base the play according to the witch trials in Salem. In Salem, rumors go around about a group of girls pretending that everyone is a witch or has something to do with witchcraft. The girls are accused of dancing in the woods which makes them tell rumors about everyone else. Rumors go around and make people act differently because the rumors are affecting their lives and families. Some people even get hanged or jailed for it.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John admits to his affair with Abigail in an attempt to discredit her. He confesses his adultery to the judges while trying to save those who Abigail has falsely accused: “I have known her, sir. I have known her” (Miller 1309). John was ashamed of his sin, but he does not allow this to stop him from revealing the truth, as the truth has the possibilty of freeing everyone. By ruining his own name and confessing his sins, he has the opportunity to put a stop to all of the lies created by Abigail and the other girls.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the inner struggle of guilt, a person can either be redeemed or destroyed. In The Scarlet Letter, by Nathaniel Hawthorne Hester Prynne is ridiculed publicly by the Puritan community for adultery. Mr. Dimmesdale, the man Hester cheats with is a young minister in the town, and hides his sin from the community. Together the two have a daughter named Pearl, that Hester raises. Pearl is a constant reminder of their sin, in which Hester holds onto public guilt, and Dimmesdale onto private guilt.…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This line proves that she has been tempted by the devil and has succumbed to his will. In addition, she admits to witchcraft and accuses John Proctor of being the messenger of the devil. The action of admitting to witchcraft redeems her and implicates John Proctor. According to Henry Popkin, an academic philosopher who specialized philosophy and anti-dogmatism, “This decision has disastrous results, for Mary Warren, facing serious punishment as a turncoat and a possible witch, must defend herself by making a new charge—against the man who got her into this mess, John Proctor.” Mary Warren’s hysteria causes mass confusion and separation in the court and throughout…

    • 1007 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scarlet Letter Sin

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Hawthorne fails to emphasize, however, that there is yet another major sinner in the book, Hester 's husband, Roger Chillingworth. Although he seems to be the affected victim in the affair between Hester and Dimmesdale, his resulting actions after he find out about their sin, are stemmed from hate and anger. Chillingworth’s malicious intent to seek revenge against Hester and Dimmesdale is the least justified of the sins throughout the text because of his inability to feel sympathy and minimal penitent; this causes great harm to Hester and Dimmesdale, making him the biggest sinner. Chillingworth acts out of hate and anger while seeking revenge against Hester and Dimmesdale because of his feelings of betrayal and jealousy. When he returns to town and sees Hester on the scaffold “he slowly and calmly raises] his finger, [makes] a gesture with it in the air, and [lays] it on his lips” (Hawthorne 57) telling her he wants to keep…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another similarity between the two novels is that they both talk about women’s sexuality. The Scarlet Letter’s main focus is that Hester Prynne has committed adultery, leading to her public shame and humiliation. Her adulterous affair showed the sexuality that was to be repressed in society because it was immoral. In The Devil in the Shape of a Woman, the women were seen as temptresses who would succumb to their sexual desires with other men or even with the Devil himself. It seems as if Puritan society viewed women’s sexuality as repugnant because it was both a “sin” and a disgrace to see this women…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The leader is Abigail Williams, who is a manipulator and bully. She had an inappropriate relationship with a married man, John Proctor and wants him to herself. She sees an opportunity with the power she has ganged with her lies, and decides to go after John’s wife, Elizabeth Proctor. Abigail uses her devious ways to separate Elizabeth and John, and accuses Elizabeth of having a relationship with the devil. This accusation changes Elizabeth from a suspicious wife, then later showing her faithfulness, forgivingness, and compassion for her husband, John.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These acts are considered signs of witchcraft. The group of girls starts pointing fingers around the town saying that many people are witches to defend their misbehavior in the woods. In the end, many people die because of the girls’ nonsense. Abigail Williams, Mary Warren, and John Proctor portray the idea that guilty people will bolster and guard their mistakes. Abigail Williams is a prime example of a person who will go the extra mile to cover up her mistakes.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In The Crucible, people are accusing one another of being a witch and is reminiscent of McCarthyism, where senator McCarthy called many different people communists in the era known as the red scare, and in doing so, caused distrust in the people, so the people looked to him for answers and safety, even though he lied about his information. While everything he said was completely false, no one dared to speak up against him because they became the next target in his game of lies. This whole situation inspired Miller to write The Crucible. The Crucible has John Proctor, who cheated on his wife with a young girl named Abigail who fell in love with him. Abigail saw his wife Elizabeth as a pest and so she claimed Elizabeth was a witch.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Filled with regret and sin, he returns to his wife, leaving Abigail furious with his decision. She then decides that she will do anything she can in order to get Proctor back, even if it means telling rumors and lies that quickly spread like wildfire across Salem. As an official leader of the witch trials, Abigail soon becomes so drunk with power that she can get away with anything she wants (Andersen 102). Proctor, who presents his corrupted nature when he cheats on his wife with Abigail, redeems himself when he confesses to the affair and stands up for what he believe is right. The narrator says in the play, ‘The Devil is a wily one, and, until an hour before he fell, even God thought him beautiful in Heaven’ (Miller 35).…

    • 1932 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays