Should We Celebrate Columbus Day Analysis

Decent Essays
Can history be trusted? Many Textbooks just skim the surface or contain author bias. Relying on one source of evidence or information can be risky. The story of Christopher Columbus is one specific example. Recent evidence of slavery, biological warfare and forcing christianity on indians proves Columbus day shouldn't be celebrated. In the passage “Should We Celebrate Columbus Day” in the 4th paragraph it says “Columbus led had the additional consequence of bringing new disease to the new world which over time , devastated the native population”, which prove biological warfare. Also in the 3rd paragraph it says,“In an era in which the international slave trade was starting to grow, columbus and his men enslaved many native inhabitants” ,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The interesting voyages of Christopher Columbus will everlastingly be told and celebrated by many. Gloria Deák answers the inquiries concerning Columbus' noteworthy attempt to fill in the blank spaces on who he was, what he set out to fulfill, and where he succeeded. Deák depicts Columbus as an incredible mariner whose achievement in intersection the Atlantic Ocean was an unequaled feat of navigation. She goes on to clarify that almost no evidence is given to propose that he was the heroic Renaissance figure regularly portrayed in textbooks. She paints Columbus as a creative, fearless, and contained man of cruelty.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Is Columbus Worthy?

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages

    For example I think that columbus is not worthy of a holiday because of the cruel things he did to the native americans. As a result of this they were forced into manual labor were the suffered and died. Evidence to back that up is that columbus murder, torture, pillaging, robbery, slavery, kidnapping and forced them to leave thee home lands. However my claim connects to my evidence because they both have reasoning why I do not thing he’s worthy of his own holiday. Due to all the cruel mean things h e has done he is NOT a hero he is a villain…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Did you know Columbus Day is a lie? If you don’t know who Columbus is, he was a man who was claimed to discover America. Many think that Columbus found the New World looking for new undiscovered land but he was in fact trying to find gold and an all-water route to Asia as well as Queen Isabella’s mission for spreading Christianity to Asia. Columbus Day shouldn’t be celebrated because he was not actually the person to discover the Americas and Columbus thought he landed in Asia. First, Columbus Day shouldn’t be celebrated because Columbus thought he landed in India and didn’t think he discovered new territory.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Columbus Day Dbq

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, what these people fail to realise is that he may have had an impact on where people sailed in the fifteen hundreds, he was about 500 years late to being the first sailor to come across it, not even taking into consideration the “some 145 million people” who already inhabited the hemisphere in 1492 (Document B). Columbus's influence on future sea voyages may have been great, but it merely led more explorers to conquer lands of Natives and then enslaving them, showing that any impact he had was certainly not positive. Another argument which some use to support the continuation of Columbus Day is that “it is necessary to pay a price for progress,” and that just like “Hiroshima and Vietnam,” we must do anything for the preservation and expansion of Western society and ideology (Document H). This argument is misguided as the slaughter of thousands of innocent Natives through slavery and barbaric ruling cannot be compared to dropping a bomb which will end a war, that would have kill millions of soldiers. It also does not compared to a war launched in order to protect the freedom of other people from the oppression communism.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas King the author of The Inconvenient Indian, takes a chapter to explain the stories and history surrounding the past relations of Whites and Native Americans by presenting many common conceptions then describing why they are actually misconceptions. The Chapter is named Forget Columbus, the author elaborates by saying his wife told him not to start the book with Columbus but this becomes relevant when he continues to say that everyone believes they know what Columbus did and they revere him for his deeds when no one actually knows him or was able to witness the explorer’s deeds first hand. This is much like the history of conflicts between the United States and Native Americans. Kings then lists famous battles, massacres, and war heroes…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Christopher Columbus has always been a controversial topic. Some individuals believe he was a hero and founded the Great America at no one’s expense. On the other hand, some individuals believe that Christopher Columbus was a deleterious, inconsiderate, and clueless explorer. Was Columbus a thief and a murderer and should he have his own holiday, is the topic of theologian Dr. Tink Tinker and BBC producer Mark Freeland’s article, “Thief, Slave Trader, Murderer: Christopher Columbus and Caribbean Population Decline” (Tinker and Freeland, 2008, Pg.25). After deliberation and a close look at sources Tinker and Freeland argue that Columbus was a thief and murderer who should not be honored.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Celebrating Columbus Day: Should We? The issue of whether the United States should continue to celebrate Columbus Day or not has been a topic of interest for quite some time. To some people Columbus Day is a ridiculous day on which we glorify genocide of the Arawak Indians while to others it is considered a day of great importance and a celebration of an honorable man in history. Columbus Day is actually the latter description, but to prove this an agreeable definition is needed. What exactly is an “honorable man”?…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Columbus Day is an unnecessary holiday that, for some reason, we still honor today. The holiday is also an affront to the indigenous population. The false sense of patriotism is wrong to memorialize. The whole day is based off of a fabrication of the true events. When children are in elementary school, they are taught that Christopher Columbus was a hero, to shield the truth.…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hello, I feel like we should stop celebrating Columbus Day as a national holiday, as he is not a historical hero. My reasons for this is that he destroyed a civilization, enslaved and terrorized Indians, and was generally ruthless to others. When Columbus got to the New World, he destroyed a society present there. He and his crew brought new diseases, such as smallpox, measles, and influenza to the New World. The Indians, who had no medical knowledge, couldn’t fight the viruses, killing off a majority of them.…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We shouldn't celebrate Columbus Day. Not just because he was a bad person. Yes, it is because spread so much disease, and I really don’t want to be celebrating someone who committed near genocide. But mainly, I don’t want to have a day where the Native Americans in our country feel hurt and betrayed as we celebrate the man who killed so many of their ancestors. The majority of people in America aren't Native American.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sky Woman Analysis

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Most children in school learn about his discovery of America and how “amazing” he was; what we do not see is Columbus’ treatment of the indigenous people of the land. My school never talked about the rape or the killings that occurred during his so-called “discovery.” To me, this misconception of Christopher Columbus means the spread of European ideas through lies. As a student, I have the right to learn the history of my country even if my history includes gruesome…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Columbus’s legacy is debated because some people regard him as explorer and discoverer who initiated the modern age while other people associate him with imperialism, colonialism,and conquest. The reason for the hate towards Columbus is the fact that Columbus caused the death of millions of native people through disease and the fact that he initiated the Atlantic slave trade. However, other people argue that the sacrifices were worth bringing the two worlds together. When the two hemispheres first came into contact, there were many important effects that transpired, such as new foods in both hemispheres.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Primarily, in light of the abuse, death, and cultural eradication that the Native Americans were forced to suffer through as a consequence of Columbus’s voyage, Columbus Day cannot be celebrated the way it is today. Notably, the population of Native Americans is estimated to have dropped from a quarter million to a few hundred in just a few short decades (Bergreen 301). While Europeans caused many of these deaths unwittingly by carrying diseases to the Americas that the Native Americans had no resistances to, far too many deaths were caused by deliberate “torture, wholesale slaughter, and ‘the harshest and most iniquitous and brutal…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Columbus Day, observed on the second monday of October, commemorates the foundations of Europe’s presence in the New World and the massive exchange of people, trade, and ideas that have led to what our country is today. It is a reminder of the absolute terror and cruelty the indigenous peoples that had, for the most part, been peacefully living on their land for thousands of years until that point, been subjected to. Christopher Columbus was a man responsible for the decimation of three major civilizations, as well as the ultimate genocide of the indigenous peoples as a whole, one of the largest in human history. Columbus alone committed an array of horrific acts, using the Indians as sex slaves and extorting them for labor, stealing their land and goods, and hunting them for sport and dog food. His choices and treatment influenced how other would later view and deal with the Indians, eventually leading to their near extinction.…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the chapter ‘Forget Columbus’ of the book ‘The Inconvenient Indian’, the author Thomas King writes about his point of view on the forgotten history of the Native Americans. He conveys about the tales made up about the natives and americans engraved in the history to mainly appeal to the white audience. The author starts the chapter by telling how insignificant was the discovery of the land of natives made by Columbus. According to him the only reason why he was given credit and recognized because his story as Columbus sailing the oceans, travelling across with interesting adventures and going through hardships with a letter to the Emperor of Indies by the King and Queen of Spain captured the imagination of the audience and met the expectations…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays