Should Students Get Paid For Good Grades?

Improved Essays
“According to the most recent Phi Delta Kappa poll, only one out of four Americans say students should be paid for their grades” (Flannery). As Alfie Kohn said, the bigger the reward, the bigger the damage done (Flannery). Instead of using a physical reward such as money, there should be encouragement given when a student is working hard no matter the outcome. Money cannot buy children's feelings towards themselves and what they can accomplish. While some students may argue that being paid for good grades is beneficial, financial compensation for high marks on a report card does not build good character traits and can even be detrimental to kids for years to come. Most people think paying their kids for good grades is favorable to them, but it is the exact opposite. Paying children for good grades does not help their creativity at all (Flannery). They have the mindset to do their work good enough to get paid, which is a bad mindset for any future endeavors. Also, getting paid causes a lack of intrinsic motivation (Great Schools). They are not driven to excel in order to learn more, but to perform well enough to receive a reward. Good grades in school should not really be a true achievement, but should be more of an expectation. In addition, this deters performance in the long run (Flannery). Students will eventually …show more content…
Most people believe it is their child's job so they deserve to be paid for it, but school is required. A job in the future is a choice, not a requirement. Children should not be paid for something that all kids are expected to do. Other people think that the kick-start motivation of cash is actually useful. Yes, it does have that immediate inspiration, but if it does not stay and is not internal, there is no point to it. There are many people who believe that cash incentives are good, but teaching students to be motivated to highly perform long term is even better (Great

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Every year more than 460,00 NCAA student-athletes compete in 24 sports (NCAA). These are held to high expectations not only on as an athlete but as a student too. But should student-athletes at the collegiate level be paid. They go through expectations of vigorous training while playing and maintaining their studies. In the article Are players School Employees?…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She states facts throughout the article on how incentives can benefit students in achieving higher test scores and passing grades. But she also throws facts in why incentives may not have any benefit on students at all because they just do not have time to bring up their grades or they just do not want to. Livingston talks about how even if students are motivated to do better is does not necessarily mean they know how to and they might not be able to improve their test scores that easily. Sometimes incentives can have a negative impact on schools, and things such as cheating on tests can occur in schools and nothing is really being…

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gardiner explains that rewarding the child only motivated the child to reach the reward as quick as possible. Supporting this claim Gardiner also states, “While there may be an initial increase in desired behavior, in most cases, these attempts to buy performance won’t last long. Eventually they may do serious damage to students’ intrinsic motivation” (Gardiner, 1). This statement just further stresses the fact that in the future children will only work hard to receive rewards, but once those rewards are not present the child will stop their hard work. This issue occurs most often in school when teaching a child.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the college professors only did what these kids are begging for, they would have no negatives and their school days would go on. These kids would still learn the exact same knowledge. There is no need for the added pressure from the grades. This pressure can result in many effects that can only stunt learning. Not being used to the pressure can cause many kids to struggle with anything from doing the homework to taking tests.…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As of 2013 student loan debt is over one trillion dollars. This makes people think that college should be free because some people can’t afford college. Also, students will be in loan debt because they can not afford a place to stay. These claims are invalid because students usually force the student loan debts on themselves. College should not be free because kids will not try hard, there will be too many graduates, and free college does not cause kids to make decisions, whereas if college were free then poor kids could go to college and the world would be smarter and safer.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Sooner or later, we need to respond to the fact that we have an epidemic of substance abuse that is taking a real toll on the lives of young people in America” says psychiatrists Dr. Keith Ablow. Fifty percent of twelfth graders in the United States admitted to using drugs in the past year. Legally, only students that participate in extracurricular activities can be required to take a drug test. Should student athletes should be required to submit drug tests before participating in school sports because it could cause them to quit using the drugs; therefore, making them healthier and also to to help their decision making abilities which is a very important aspect in sports.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has been proven that sports and athletics can benefit socially. Confirmation on the social assistance, (Kids and Sports Video) verifies that sports really do improve confidence in student athletes, and creates additional friendships. Confidence is proven to improve because of their performance in front of others. They also become armed with a multitude of life skills. Increased relationships with other student athletes is caused from interaction with your teammates.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Furthermore, that’s how people end up on the streets being homeless. They have no education background so they have no money for shelter, food, clothes or anything. Also, the government should be investing money for something worth the cause. They shouldn’t be wasting money, besides funding it for our future, to help many people become teachers, doctors, nurses or other professional’s jobs. Many students graduated from high and wants to go to college but they don’t have the money for it.…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Imagine, being thousands of dollars in dept only for the reason that you made the decision to drop out. The average debt all graduating seniors with student loans is $30,000. And the average debt for an adult is $5,700. Students should not be required to pay back the money used to educate them, if they drop out.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    School is an expansion of your discovering that is not required for lower end occupations, but rather without a higher education it is difficult to land a well paying position. On the off chance that school is required for such a large number of professions would it be a good idea for it to be free? Offering free school would have its good and bad times for the school and the state or fortune. Giving without end free school will clearly advantage the understudy and give most universities more participants, however how does the school make up for paying for school supplies for the majority of the understudies while as yet paying workers? How supportive would it be for a nation or even only a state to offer free school?Whenever inquired as to whether school ought to be free a great many people would most likely say yes, however that is from right off the highest point of their head without pondering what the advantages and disadvantages are to the circumstance.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The United States school system is not educating children correctly. One reason the school system are flawed is because every school offers a different educational program. In order to attend a private school, you’ll have to pay for an education. The average amount for a private elementary is $7,770 and high school is $13,030 per year. As for charter and public schools, you do not have to pay for an education.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The students will not get held back, or have their teachers call home due to failing grades. Parents will not have to worry about their kids failing classes because their students want the money. The students will be on top of things and wanting money and they will not fail. Compared to a job paying in schools is perfect. When people go to work they get paid an hourly wage or salary.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion, I believe that students should not get paid for getting good grades. In the process, I believe they are being taught the wrong motive attributes and confuses themselves with the matters and does not matters. Moreover, the policy cannot be sustained due to the lack of funds and studies have also proven that money is a bad motivator. Your expected to receive good grades from your family and…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    School is a necessary system worldwide to invest in a society 's future. The primary argument as to why educational institutions should be free in the U.S. is not to give everyone the equal opportunity to education as stated by Lawrence (a professor of History emeritus at SUNY Albany) although it is one of the reasons, the primary reason is to increase the number of educated workers to hopefully improve our economy. It is stated that an “educated work force has become an essential component of economic growth and competitiveness (Student Aid Alliance). However, college tuition filters out those who are not willing to pay for their education and also funds universities so that they are able to function and upgrade their facilities. College should not be free because it would lead to tax raises, the value of a degree would decline, and the overall quality of the educational environment would decrease.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Clare Levison, “ I think it can be an effective incentive, as long as you’re using it as a teachable moment to tell them about budgeting and saving.” But undoubtedly this could be challenged because even if students were being paid in the long term, their academic performances are lower than those who are not getting paid. Students who want to lean will be better than those who are only studying to get money. In addition, getting paid may be effective, but it is external and is generally short- term. Students should not be bribed and should study to get an education and not money.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays