Should Prisoners Be Used As Research Subjects In Clinical Trials Requiring Human Subjects

Improved Essays
Recent scholars have proposed that prisoners be used as research subjects in clinical trials requiring human subjects. Scholars suggest this in order to address the problem of using non-ideal research participants and not having enough research participants to satisfy a study. Finding research participants is a lengthy process, including sufficiently explaining the potential risks and benefits of a study, getting informed consent, and maintaining the participants for the entire duration of the study. Recruitment of human research subjects can sometimes take longer than a researcher would like, which in turn makes the process more costly. Additionally, researchers may recruit more subjects than necessary, also contributing to superfluous expenses. …show more content…
In many studies, it is required to know the medical history of the participant as to see how the particular research has affected a person based on their past, thus being able to draw conclusions from the research. But with prisoners, researchers will have inadequate or no access to medical histories. This could lead to outcomes of the research that are indescribable. Additionally, prisoners could have unforeseen medical problems that could hinder with the outcome of the research. Furthermore, while there may be a large amount of individuals in prison across the country and the world, not all of the prisoners would meet the requirements to be a subject in certain studies. Prisoners are also in prison for various amounts of time, thus making it difficult to run a long term study with specific participant requirements. In addition, informed consent would still be a requirement of prisoners since they still are human research subjects. However, attaining informed consent from a prisoner could prove to be more difficult than obtaining it from an average human because prisoners often have less education than the average person. This would may it more difficult to make clear the risks and process behind the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Prison Ethics

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Testing on prison in mates spending life in prison. It is both morally and ethically wrong to conduct scientific research on prison in mates spending life in prison. In the following examination I shall underline and point out justifiable evident the will support the stance on this issue, as well as evidents that oppose this issue. Virtue Ethics and Deontology well be used in support of the argument for this issue and consequentialism will be used as the apposed support or this issue.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American judicial system is riddled with corruption, racism, and privilege. In his book, Just Mercy, author and lawyer Bryan Stevenson chronicles the unfortunate and rapid deterioration of the mental health of his client and friend Walter McMillian following his release from death row. Mental illness resulting from wrongful imprisonment on death row stands as a deplorable and preventable collateral consequence of the negligence of the judicial system. The trauma of the death row experience as an innocent man sparks Walter’s symptoms of anxiety and dementia.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Stanford Prison Experiment The Stanford Prison Experiment is unethical and inhuman. It is also evidently a product of poor decision-making. If the scholar involved had considered using two individuals to take the roles of primary experimenter and prison superintendent, the experiment would not have advanced to the levels it did. Moreover, this independent individual would have interfered with the direction the experiment was taking.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Inmates are often treated based on crime committed or length of criminal history, not just in prison but also in society in general. A prior criminal history may affect many aspects of life, from obtaining a secondary education, to being able work in specific career fields, such as: law, law enforcement, or medical careers. When incarcerated prior knowledge of prior criminal history by the correctional officers in charge of your health and welfare can affect the way the inmate is treated and the freedom within the prison they get. Correctional nurses and health care providers should not have access to an inmates’ criminal past as it fosters an environment where bias is found in the treatment of patients and bedside manner is almost non-existent, as they are subject to the same judgment and prejudice as the correctional officers in charge of…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 1990, the federal government enacted the Americans with Disabilities Act statute requiring prison facilities to provide accessible and usable by persons with disabilities. The Standards of the American Correctional Association (ACA) published operational standards designed to enhance correctional practices for the benefit inmates, staff, administrators, and the public. ACA standards provide a guide in operating jails and prisons effectively as self-contained communities in which all necessary goods and services are provided in a safe, secure, and controlled manner. Last but not least is The Center for Prisoner Health and Human Rights striving to improve the health and human rights of criminal justice populations by effectively address the dimensions of public health and human rights crisis of the prison population into law, policies, and practices. One of their goals is to advance the continuum of health care for prisoners from admission through their release into the…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The study will include two experimental groups and a controlled group of individuals whom will be paid to spend time in a prison simulation. The results of this experiment will be qualitative as the ability to quantify someone psychological state would not be beneficial in this experiment. Participants There will be a total of 30 male subjects between the ages of 21 years old and 35…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In society today, when someone breaks the law, they are sent to prison to be punished. Prison, in one perspective, values rehabilitation for the prisoners; however, it does not actually focus on helping the prisoners. The social stigma of having the label of a prisoner is detrimental to the chance of success after they are released. Therefore, prisoner incarceration and recidivism rates in the United States are among the highest in the world. In the article "When Prisoners Are Patients," Theresa Brown elaborates on personal stories involving inmates in the prison healthcare system in her work as a nurse.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If researchers use specialized terms or language which is common in research, subjects may not understand the meaning and are unable to give consent. Federal regulations on human subjects includes special provisions of certain subjects called special population, juveniles and prisoners. Juveniles as human subjects usually involve the parents or guardian permission and sometimes from the juvenile subject themselves. Prisoners are treated as a special population for other reasons. Because of their ready accessibility to experiments and interviews, prisoners have frequently been used in biomedical experiments that produce serious harm (Mitford, 1973).…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aging Inmates: An Ethical and Financial Crisis Incarceration of criminals is a concept that receives a lot of attention from lawmakers and citizens alike. However, majority of this attention is based on the unconscious perception that those in jail pose an immediate danger to our society and their imprisonment is keeping the community safe. Little attention is given to the aging prisoner, the one who is chronically ill and remains in prison despite that he/she may no longer possess the physical and/or emotional capacity to pose a threat. What follows below is an in depth look at the ongoing issue of poor health care provided to the aging incarcerated, as well as its physical, financial and ethical constraints. Historical Background…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It would take quite a bit of time to get used to being called by their names again and have their lives become more normalized. After the kind of abuse they endured, they could have some post-traumatic stress and self-esteem issues from all the humiliation they endured. I think that they should have found better ways to stimulate prison life in order to create a safe environment for the research to be observed. Their study should have had more research done prior to the experiment; so they could have a better idea of what the prisoners are going through and how to handle each issue as it arose. There should have been more medical staff on the scene to make sure the participants when in a state of good health to continue the experiment.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For-Profit Prison Research

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The United States has become infamous around the world for several reasons in the 21st century. Perhaps one of the reasons that is least talked about is the one that sits right beneath the nose of every citizen in the country. The reason being the overwhelming number of people currently incarcerated in the United States jail system. The United States and all of her citizens account for less than 5% of the world’s population. This being said it seems strange that the United States also accounts for over 22% of the worlds prisoners.…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this essay factors that influence the health of Australians and the function of the Australian health care system relating to the priority population of prisoners in Australia will be discussed. The priority population will be described and the social determinants of health in particular drug addiction and unemployment will be explored and the influences that affect this group and their health. Social determinants of health are conditions in which people are born, grown, live, work, age, education levels and environment (WHO, 2013). In addition, the strategies that have been taken to help prevent further inequalities arising by the Australian health care system.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Although statistical data and research shows there are healthcare disparities as it relates to minorities, much isn’t done to change negative patterns. However, researchers’ have chosen to examine the healthcare racial inequalities of African Americans. Cultural differences, and racial conscious and unconscious are factors that contribute to the gap in African American health. Therefore, collecting only medical data and physician behaviors towards certain diagnosis, is not enough to determine or conclude that there aren’t any deep rooted unforeseen components that play into racialist thinking by physicians.…

    • 2046 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although many prisoners leave prison unchanged, many can face psychological issues after years of being locked in a cell. A recent study shows that when they were assessing a sample group of male inmates they found a change in behavior. “12 met the criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder, and most reported additional mood and anxiety disorders. There were major problems of psychological and social adjustment, particularly within families,” (Adrian 1). Many can develop mood/anxiety disorders, as well as problems dealing with social adjustment when returning to their everyday lives.…

    • 1658 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mental Illness In Prisons

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Sadly the public has faced an increased threat to safety as untreated inmates are continually being released into society. Successful community reintegration can only be achieved by a push toward rehabilitation that provides continuous benefits and accommodations to inmates who suffer from mental illness. Persons with psychiatric disabilities rely heavily on federal benefit programs for housing, food and medical care and evidence shows that eligible offenders who receive such benefits show increased rates of success (Tomasini & Imas, 2005). Recidivism rates can reach as high as 70 percent in some jurisdictions without needed services such as medication supplies and housing (Barrett et al, 2004). The medical profession has a chance to advocate for changes by capitalizing on public health opportunities for diagnosing and treating mental disease and for linking patients to care after release (Rich et al, 2011).…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays