Analysis: Is Race-Based Medicine Good For Us?

Improved Essays
As seems to be the case in every aspect of society, there seems to exist a racial disparity in the way people are medically treated. There are many arguments involved in the debate about whether doctors should racially profile their patients, most of which mimic a general perception in that they understand parts of the complex system of racism in the 21st century, but ignore other facts that are plain to see should one only look. These arguments and their shortfallings relate to the idea that people often overlook the intersection of race with every other identifying feature. One could find this in the social concept of colorblindness or in the fact that white seems to be the default race to those who have never thought about it, even in academic …show more content…
What Dorothy E. Roberts presents at the end of “Is Race-Based Medicine Good for Us?” is a social justice approach to answering her title’s question. She says that it’s possible for the discourse to shift from attempting to address white privilege and political/social racial disparities such as mere access to good healthcare, to an attempt to eliminate these problems from the narrative by finding “genetic explanations and technological solutions” (Roberts 542). She argues that, even through genetic research, the conclusion met would be that “Black people’s health would improve far more by universalizing health care, equalizing the education system, removing environmental toxins from Black neighborhoods, stopping employment discrimination, and reducing poverty” (Roberts 542). This suggests that any discussion of race or the possibility of racial profiling should include examination of the social struggles faced by the Black community and other communities of color. It’s likely that the answer to any question one might have lies, not specifically in genetics, but in a person’s position in …show more content…
When doctors indicate that they know how to treat a person based on their race, many are thinking of race in terms of present-day. Instead, according to Sally Satel in “I Am a Racial Profiling Doctor,” they should be considering the reasons behind the statistics they base their choices on. She notes that “the genetic variant for sickle cell anemia cropped up at some point in the gene pool [in Africa],” which would, as opposed to the simple fact that a person is Black, account for the disease being more commonly found in Black people than in white people (Satel 3). This serves to explain that simply medically treating a person differently because they’ve checked “African American” on their paperwork relies primarily on bias, which has no place in

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Case Study

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Just as Skloot (2010) stated, “when black patients showed-up at white-only hospitals, the staff was likely to send them away, even if it meant they might die in the parking lot” (Skloot, 2010, p. 15). Furthermore, the structural healthcare disparities that Henrietta Lacks demonstrated included the facts that she was a female patient at the time when white men dominated the healthcare field, poverty, lack of education, and being black when whites were given privileges. All these factors have influenced the predatory behaviors of the medical professionals at the time. In fact, Skloot (2010) described that “for Henrietta, walking into Hopkins is like entering a foreign country where she didn’t speak the language” (p. 16) which speaks more about the lack of understanding related to the health services she was…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    There is a problem in healthcare where racial and ethnic disparities exist. Despite the abundance of healthcare facilities, technology and pharmacology and other aspects to which the U.S. is envied by others, something that should be accessible to everyone, is not. The quality and improvement of health care have been a long- standing and persistent issue of national discussions in the United States for years. This problem has negatively impacted African American women because there is a disparity of access and quality of care that they are receiving. Poor outcomes in health care, based on race or ethnic background exist in every level of the American health care system.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    OUTLINE (Optional) Introduction Throughout American history, we have liberated ourselves from dictatorship of Great Britain, fought in and won many great wars, and is currently boasting to be potentially one of the greatest nation that there ever war. However, there is an important national issue we have failed to completely get rid. Racial inequality is the discrimination against people of color, meaning unfair advantages and disadvantages given to people based off bias of race. Background info/context: Relating back to the book, The Other Wes Moore, the idea of racial inequality within the treatment sector of the healthcare system is prominent.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Disparities in Mental Health Care and Ways to Avoid Them Since the 1960 's, studies have shown that racial disparities in mental health care have been prevalent in the United States. Even though more attention has been placed on these racial disparities, there is still a substantial difference in the health care and treatment that racial minorities receive when compared to white Americans. Institutions, however, such as the University of San Francisco, California, have developed new ways to help doctors realize their own prejudices when working with patients (Dembosky 2014). Thus, there are a numerous amount of ways that a physician or doctor limit the prejudices they face when handling a patient with a mental illness.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hence, racial stereotypes in the medical field should be eradicated because of the frequent deaths of minorities from preventative reasons, and the astonishing amount of blacks waiting for organ transplants.…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Racism

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Blacks wouldn’t question their doctors when they were told something was wrong because they thought doctors knew best. In the book, “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks,” it says “Especially black patients in public wards. This was 1951 in Baltimore, segregation was a law and it was understood that black people didn’t question white people’s professional judgement. Many blacks patients were just too glad to be getting treatment since discrimination is hospital was widespread.” Not only was this true but back then blacks didn’t have any background knowledge on anything, so what other choice did blacks have except trusting white doctors and their resource .…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Disparities in Health Insurance Including its Accessibility, Usage and Financial Impact In a world that has made great strides in social equalities, racial disparities in the health care industry are still a prevalent matter. This is especially true when it comes to access and utilization of health insurance. Inequalities can be seen throughout the health care system and have a major impact on our country’s (both current and future) health and well-being.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Implicit Bias Analysis

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This encounter is an example of racial concordance; the patient is the same race as his physician. Based on the results of the study, an encounter between a physician and an African American male would have a low rate of implicit race. In terms of race, the majority of Black American physicians do not prefer White Americans over Black Americans thus preventing a racially bias diagnosis for a patient (Sabin 2009). A study performed by the Society of General Internal Medicine, reflects this idea of unequal and bias diagnosis for patients. Implicit bias will occur in this situation due to the implication of the lack of compliance in African American males.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Describe the primary issues presented in the case study. The case study of the doctor in the sleep study clinic represents issues with health disparities, race, poverty/socioeconomic class, ethnicity and culture. The doctor clearly puts his own needs first as well as remains at the job due to its proximity to family and friends.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Race and Reification in Science” by Troy Duster, the main argument consists of the idea that African Americans simply have more health problems than other races. Studies show that African Americans tend to die quicker, and have issues of hypertension or heart diseases in their early life. Duster emphasizes the differences between Americans of European decent and Americans of African descent in the field of science, medicine, and society by giving multiple examples of real life situations that occurs today. Alfred North Whitehead states ideas about “the fallacy of misplaced concreteness”. He implies that “If we think of a shoe as really a shoe, then we are not likely to use it as a hammer (when no hammer is around)”.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many researchers have identified health disparities the goal is look at the the cyclical pattern that ultimately results in widened disparities in health care between minority groups and the majority and in continued discrimination of minority group( e.g., Buki, Borrayo, Feigal & Carrillo, 2004; Clegg, Li, Hankey, Chu, & Edwards,2002) . According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services states there is inequality in the quality of care given. For example if a white person suffered from a cardiovascular disease and a person of color suffered from the same thing would they received the same treatment? With health disparities healthcare becomes bias because society tends to aid the white person first and better versus the person of color. The first definition of health disparity was found in September 1999, Director Harold Varmus that worked for the white house was charged with creating a…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Racial disparities are a major issue in healthcare affecting mostly minorities as studies have confirmed. Root causes have been identified but with little achievement in removing the root causes. People perceptions can impact how care if given or received when there is distrust in the system or biased decision base on fraudulent research that support a claim. ACO and outcome based treatment may try to fix the problem, however, until the root causes of racial disparities are addressed and fixed, there won't be a breakthrough in fixing the problem in healthcare.…

    • 91 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Healthcare is more than just the care that you receive in a hospital. Poverty, lack of employment, and lack of housing all fall into that category. And all racial bias can and does take part in these implements of health. It seems people are hesitant to claim that there is healthcare discrimination. Some of the leading causes of death include heart disease, stroke, cancer, diabetes, kidney disease, homicide, hypertension, and liver cirrhosis; African Americans have higher death rates than whites in all of these categories.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism and discrimination are being progressively implicated in racial and ethnic disparities within health care. Many believe that the inequalities associated with racism contribute to other factors including, safety and quality of care of ethnic minority groups. But racism and discrimination in healthcare do not solely occur from a provider to patient perspective- when health care providers initiate racism and discrimination practices to the patient. Racism and discrimination also often occurs from a patient to provider perspective- when the patient initiates racism or discrimination practices to the health care providers.…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the use of genetic data to define the validity of race erupted in the 1970’s, some scientists have addressed the notion that genetic variation by means of racial differences represents a form of racialization and therefore racism, in healthcare settings and within health spectrums in general. By using race as an indicator of genetic disparities we are acknowledging race as a biologically based enigma rather than a social construct. We allow discrimination to color a picture of embodied inequality among healthcare measures. Just as the anthropological definition of culture defines cultures as static entities defined by geographic boundaries, we cannot perceive race as a biological marker of genetic variation because it to is complex and static. Human biology, no matter what geographic location one hails from, is…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays