Julian Savulescu Ethical Childhood

Improved Essays
Julian Savulescu argues that parents have a moral duty to improve their children’s genetic makeup in the same way that they would improve the child’s “environment” or prevent diseases on the grounds of Utilitarianism (The Ethical Life, 443). Julian thinks this is a duty because it will yield the most positive outcomes or consequences. He believes that failure to use genetic enhancements, when a parent has an opportunity to benefit their child, is neglecting the child’s needs which is morally wrong (The Ethical Life, 443). Savulescu also defends his position by claiming that it would be inconsistent to “train our children to behave well”, but then refuse to seek genetic enhancements for our children so they have the tools to succeed, when both …show more content…
The idea of consequentialism is that we need to consider the final consequences of the action, whether or not the act itself is morally good (Shakil, n.d.). This principle claims that the morality of an action, such as, genetic enhancement depends on the best actual or expected results. Therefore, someone like Savulescu will argue that if we fail to maximize good results through genetic enhancements then we are acting morally wrong, even if we had good intentions (Shafer-Landau, 126). Savulescu tried to defend his position from some common objections, however, this paper will argue that it is not the duty of the parents to genetically enhance their children and point out the concerns in Julian’s defenses of his …show more content…
For instance, it is a parent’s duty to improve their child’s wellbeing, raise them to behave well, cooperate, and become intelligent, and a parent should prevent disease using medication and surgeries as Savulescu has noted. However, “free, equal, and rational people” would not all agree on the moral duty to do these things by altering the genes of their children because it would not be a maxim that fulfills the universal law (Shafer-Landau,193,164). That is also because an irrational person would chase after only their self-interests. In this case, the parents are chasing their self-interest of raising their idea of the “ideal” child. It is true that parents do have the ability to shape their child into the person they hope they will become, however, this ability is not the same as genetically shaping them. For instance, a parent can try and raise a hardworking, polite, honest, and generous child into an adult. Yet, as the child grows up these qualities are something that the autonomous adult must choose to continue to practice in order to be that person. Therefore, a child’s parents influence them only to the point that the child chooses to allow them too. This is far different then genetically enhancing the characteristics and personalities that a parent “wants” for the child because it would result in good consequences. This is because the child no longer gets to decide who

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Modern parenting styles keep the child too dependent. When parents use rewarding tactics the child grows into the idea that their parent is at their bidding. Figuring out how to manipulate situations into rewards becomes second nature, and the parent becomes a slave to the child. The child feels entitled and becomes selfish. Rewarding for good is not a bad thing, but it is completely different when a reward is given for not being bad.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic modification is a growing possibility. With genetic modification, parents could choose anything they want their child to have, the possibilities ranging from hair color to intellect. There are several reasons that genetic modification is wrong, however; for example, parents should love their children no matter what. The only reasons genetic modification should be accepted is to rid of diseases and disorders in a child’s genes. Genetic modification may seem like a swell process for parents that want a perfect child, but it is wrong and unfair to the child unless it is to possibly save his or her life.…

    • 1096 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parents want the best for their children, so it is understandable that they want them to have the best set of DNA, but modifying the child to their liking, is it really what is best for the child? Their decision is based on their preferences and not on the child’s. It is the child that will live with the genetically modified characteristics for the rest of their lives and not the parents. If the child finds out that he/she has been genetically modified to suit his/her parents’ preferences, this might change the way the child feels about their parents. It will cause the child to question themselves and their identity, thus creating a strained relationship with their parents.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some are created with inherent flaws and others break down before their time. However, manipulating with traits should not be allowed because it allows for parents to go to the extremes of changing their child’s traits and in many cases it cannot be reversed once children get older, but how do we truly know if parents will be satisfied with the results. It also brings up the question of: Where do we draw the line when it comes to selective breeding? What I will say is that science has the potential to do good with problems such as diseases and should be utilized to do good for everyone. It should not be taken advantage by inflicting harm upon others, especially with…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parenting styles such as giving their child (ren) everything and anything they want. The word “no” is not in their vocabulary because these type of parents believe that their child is God. Yes a child can have some of the wants they want in life, but that should not affect what they truly need. Parents should set boundaries for their child as they grow up, not just let that innocent life believe “whatever you want, you can have” type of life. Loving your child is healthy and good, but thinking your child is better than other children can lead to narcissism, and there is nothing healthy about narcissism (2015).…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Synthesis Essay On Parents

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Nobody wants to be known as that family. The real question then, is if you’re raising the child just to look sophisticated and not be that family in the community or because you want them to succeed and strive for greatness. Although looking good within the community is a good thing, the real reason parents should develope their child to succeed is because they care. Children can sense the vibes parents are giving off and if they know they’re only doing it to look good it can have a psychological effect on them. They may end up in a with a psychiatrist talking about their daddy/mommy issues.…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These are the parents who believe a little tough love will help their child become a better individual once they reach adulthood. Other sources say no to spanking because it contradicts those who think it can gain respect, and goes on to say that parents who spank out of anger lose the respect of their children and in return gain a child who is scared of them (Giles 2). Spanking because of anger also leads a child to think that it is okay to use violence as a solution when they get angry. They also believe it leads to negative behavioral issues (Rosellini 2). Some even say that there should be a warning placed on birth certificates to discourage…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anna Sommer Case Study

    • 1518 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In Anna’s case, what predisposes her decision is her capacity to be courageous by caring for her impaired child and advocating for herself and her child, to meet its critical health needs, as it is unable to advocate for itself. Anna is therefore finding the balance, or the means, between cowardice and rashness by being courageous. Also, when faced with an ethical dilemma, Virtue Ethics considers the role of emotions and how relationships play an important factor in decisions (Collier & Haliburton, 2015, p. 24). This theory asks the decision maker to take into account the differences between one’s relationship with their friends and…

    • 1518 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This would deprive them of living their own experiences and of finding their own solutions. Even if the parent chooses to be an authoritative parents because it is the best, it will not be achieved, “the process of internalizing cultural values – leave us with a set of rigid categories for “good” and “bad” parents, narrow conceptions of how parents should look, talk, and behave toward their children” (Rereading America 5). Parents have to meet their child’s needs and at the same time make sure they meet the expectation of being an exceptional parent. In some cases authoritative parenting may be successful because these children show a higher level of independence, personal responsibility, maturity, social skills, and academic achievement” (Dominguez 3). This can be disproven because any kind of parenting can lead to children…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Enneagram In Children

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages

    More often than not, parents set and meet profession or relationship goals, but fall short of setting goals for parenting. For successful parenting, one has to have a comprehensive meaning of success and the steps needed to meet the goal. However, every parent wants to raise their kids in a secure upbringing, feeling good of themselves while at the same time growing up happy, helping them realize their unique and real self is the greatest attainment towards parenting. Some parents suppose they have similar or share same character traits as their children. Normally, there is an essential craving that drives a person of a particular personality type to build up an associated behavioral uniqueness.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics