Should Minimum Laws Be Repealed

Improved Essays
Notably, Cassell is not alone in the quest to reestablish how minimum mandatory sentencing is carried out and in some circumstances, avoided completely. Professor William G. Otis is a law professor at Georgetown University and former federal prosecutor who served as Special Counsel Member to President George H. W. Bush. In a similar tone to Cassell, Otis in his article "Should Mandatory Minimum Laws Be Repealed?" explores the concept of minimum mandatory sentencing from the perspective of the federal legislature’s lack of faith in the ability of state judges to uniformly get sentencing right when offenders were found guilty of carrying crime. As a direct result of such legislation and as explored above, thousands of non-violent, first time …show more content…
On the Democratic side of the aisle who historically has been liberal in the criminal justice department, has called for a reduction of time in sentencing for crime involving drugs to combat the existing mass incarceration in this country. As an example, Senator Dick J. Durbin, (Democrat) from Illinois has co-sponsored a bill proposed to Congress to do just that stating that “The judicial system has been a critical element in keeping violent criminals off the street, but now we’re stepping back, and I think it’s about time, to ask whether the dramatic increase in incarceration was warranted” (Eckholm, 2015). In fact, many Democrats under the Obama administration along with Eric Holder have outspokenly called for a reduction in prison sentencing emphasizing the disparagement of the current justice system in place today. Commonly associated with their prison sentencing cut proposals is economic progress the country would make in simply reducing time served by any given inmate. To explain, by simply cutting the average nonviolent offender 's time in prison in half, the prison population would be reduced by about a quarter over the course of the next six years (Ehrenfreund, 2015). Although this policy initiative remains …show more content…
Recently, Senator Charles E. Grassley, (Republican) out of the state of Iowa who was recently appointed as Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee has taken a hard stance against any notion of “broad reductions” in prison sentencing. Although in an interview with the New York Times Grassley affirmed that “there are a lot of ideas — prison reform, policing, sentencing — being discussed now that wouldn’t be if we hadn’t had this drop in the crime statistics” (Ehrenfreund, 2015). Ultimately Grassley cites the effectiveness of the standing policies and otherwise stripping away their effectiveness would simply revert crime rates back to the years prior to the big push for tough on crime policy. Still, flexibility in the form of Republican state policy makers exists in the form of committing to reducing state prison populations. Republican Governor Bruce Rauner out of Illinois has implemented flexibility granted to local officials in the form by reforming local jail administration and giving cops alternatives to making arrests when they encounter nonviolent, habitual lawbreakers on the street. Through this approach, Rauner asserts that local officials can limit incarceration without damaging public safety, in turn cutting down on prison populations and aiding in the performance of law enforcement

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Alyssa Mattson 2A Current Event #3 Despite mutual agreement between the Republican and Democratic parties, the Senate still could not pass a bill enacting criminal justice reform. It was believed that this overhaul bill would be the “bipartisan success story of the year”, according to New York Times writer Carl Hulse. However, this was not the case. Some Republicans Senators disagreed with the idea of reducing minimum sentences, as well as providing President Obama with a “legacy victory” nearing the end of his presidency.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    INDIANA SENTENCING REFORM: TWO YEARS AND STILL NOT WORKING In an article I published this past January (“State Sentencing Reform: Reducing Recidivism OR Costing Indiana Counties More Money?”), I argued that the new sentencing reform bill, which radically changes the way criminal courts sentence offenders, could actually cost local communities more money without doing much to prevent recidivism. Under the new guidelines, offenders sentenced to a year or less in criminal court would not see a state prison. Instead, they would carry out their sentences in the communities in which they were convicted. If offenders had to serve jail time, county lock-ups would serve as their prisons.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sharon’s drug addiction began at the age of 22. She started drinking alcohol at parties, not thinking of its future consequences. Drugs soon replaced the alcohol and began using marijuana. She thought it of no harm to her because she did not consider it a “hard” drug like cocaine or morphine. Although she swore to herself to never use such drugs, Sharon soon started using crack cocaine to deal with her personal and family problems.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mandatory Minimums

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With a total prison population of 2,217,000 people as of 2013, the United States continues to have the highest prison rate in the world (Institute for Criminal Policy Research). In light of these numbers, it is clear to many that the United States is in need of some kind of reform in the way it responds to crime and carries out justice, however, there is much disagreement on what aspects of our criminal policies need to be reformed and in what way. Many factors play a role in the enormous prison rates in the United States, however, some of these factors raise concerns not only about the prison populations, but also bring up questions regarding economics, ethics, and the overall effectiveness of the United State’s current criminal justice policies.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Looking back at the memories with my grandparents now, the words that come to mind are “home cooking and warm embrace”. Can’t picture grandma and grandpa doing hard time for murder. Just can’t seem to process people in their 60’s and 70’s as being hard cold criminals. They should be on some porch somewhere enjoying the sunrise with a cup of hot coffee. How we easily forget that before we become old and wise we must first be young and stupid.…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    An escape from the tyranny of an oppressive king was the cornerstone of the the founding fathers drafting of the Constitution. All men are created equal and in turn should be afforded equal justice. However, legislation from both the federal and state governments could threaten that very premise. Three strikes sentencing laws seek to break a cycle of recidivism from career criminals, but ensnare minorities and the poor at a disproportionate rate when compared to those not in need and whites in the United States. In order to understand the how these laws affect minorities and the poor it is important to first understand the history behind why governments pass such harsh sentencing laws.…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Injustices of Mass Incarceration of African Americans Since 1980, the United States has seen an unprecedented rise in incarceration rates. The United States is only 5% of the world population, yet it has 25% of the world’s prisoners. Currently, the US is the world’s leader in incarceration with 2.3 million people currently in jail and prisons. That is a 500 percent increase over the last forty years. These incarceration rates, mostly which runs independent of crime rates, are suggested to be the result of policy changes over the last 30 to 35 years.…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crime In Prison

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Presidents Nixon, Reagan, and Clinton all used “tough on crime” approaches in their campaigns, and at a time when crime was on the rise, citizens were attracted to these approaches. This led to increased amounts of police officers, and increased populations in jails that were already overcrowded. In fact, in a Texas prison in 1998, over 1,000 inmates were sleeping on prison floors already holding double the acceptable amount of inmates (Campers 15). The recent issue with prison overcrowding stems almost entirely from the war on drugs and war on crime. Tough on crime approaches, surfacing in the late 20th century, are one of the major causes for prison…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With recent talks on Capitol Hill of an upcoming criminal justice reform, it is not surprising to see topics on sentencing structure, police ethics and practices, and the future of the criminal justice system in the news headlines. One of the biggest topics is the overwhelming prison population in state and federal prisons. This has been a prominent topic for some time now. While some want to curtail the prison community others seem to think there is not a visible complication. Those who sense the prison population or the amount of people under supervision of the criminal justice system is of no concern, more than likely do not understand the impact the population has on criminal justice professionals or where the funding for these institutions…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reagan ranted and raved about the War on Drugs, started the ridiculously ineffective “Just Say No” campaign, and significantly increased the budgets of many federal law enforcement agencies; it was pure hypocrisy (73). The populations of jails and prisons increased exponentially all across the country, becoming incredibly overcrowded. The War on Drugs makes it nearly impossible for people like Susan Burton and the many women she has helped to break the cycle. A profoundly flawed criminal justice system, systemic racism, redlining, education policy, and poverty are surely all to blame (8). It is a system that survives on a culture of power, a system that runs on the “idea that punishment was always the answer and was always deserved, that getting tough would solve everything” (123).…

    • 2110 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By decreasing the minimum amount of time prisoners are required to serve for their criminal acts and providing them with the opportunity to earlier release granted good effort on their part than the rate of overcrowding would be limited.…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Why Prisons Don’t Work,” Wilbert Rideau claims state prisons will never improve the lives of criminals and lower crime rates in other states. There are four reasons to consider for dramatic shift to make prisons legitimately functional: 1) Resulting with a “silver bullet” instead of turning a criminal’s life around, 2) Keeping a prisoner long enough can make a man embrace inmate life, 3) Not focusing on the main threat of the young potential criminals, 4) Not giving enough opportunity of giving a convict a second chance at rehabilitation. People who come into a prison may never come out of the rest of his unchanged life. Putting a “silver bullet” through criminals does not keep society safe.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inside Injustice Every political figure faces the struggle of law violation and hence, criminal regulation. In the ongoing election of 2016, contenders debate the subject of criminal reform that assists non-violent offenders of the law. Two out of five primary presidential candidates voice their view on criminal reform support the REDEEM and Justice Safety Valve Acts. These acts remove records of non-violent offences on the federal level of juveniles under 15 and allow judges to regulate the minimum mandatory sentence of non-violent offenders to their best interest. Anti-reformists contend that laws exist to maintain order in society, with punishment being the main—if not only – factor that preserves the effectivity of the legal system.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prison Reform Essay

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A recent magazine by Mrs. Flores on November the tenth talked about certain key points of prison reform that Obama was talking about. There are three main key points: “low-level drug offenders (with no ties to large organization, cartels, or gangs) will no longer be charged with offenses that include mandatory minimum sentences. The justice department has updated its frame work for evaluating compassionate release for inmates facing compelling circumstances; including old age. DOJ will also expand the use of ‘diversion’ programs such as drug treatment and community service that could be used instead of incarceration. ”(Flores Reena)…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    While there is wide consensus that tougher penalties are necessary and appropriate for those convicted of serious violent or sex offenses, many policymakers are questioning the need for long prison terms for people convicted of less serious crimes such as nonviolent drug offenses. Some of these provisions were reversed during the fiscal crisis earlier this decade, resulting in severe prison overcrowding. States are also presented with a growing number of elderly and chronically ill prisoners whose ongoing care requires significant resources. To address these issues, officials have added or modified the laws and policies that determine the amount of time people spend in prison. These changes have the potential to lower prison populations, allowing states to close facilities and reduce corrections expenses in the longer term (Scott-Hayward,…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays