Juveniles Should Be Tried As Adults

Improved Essays
percent increase in juveniles arrested for robbery. This included 90 percent of boys that were under the age of 16 (Hope #). This increase of arrests also correlates to an increased number of juveniles that are waived into the adult court system. Every year around 200,000 juveniles are sent directly into adults prisons (Hudson, Juveniles should not be treated as adults #). As these numbers of arrests increase in different states, states continually add more criminal offences that can be waived into the adult system (Hudson, Juveniles should not be treated as adults #). According to the campaign for youth justice in 2007, there are 7500 youths that are being permitted into adult jails at any day (Locked up: Should teens be tried as adults?). …show more content…
One side of this issue believes that juveniles should be tried as adults for their crimes for numerous reasons. To being, the juvenile system is viewed as ineffective, firstly that it is too lenient of violent offenders and is not equipped to deal with the more violent offenders that it sees in today 's times. As written by Linda Collier, “This system was developed with truants, vandals and petty thieves in mind. But this model is not appropriate for the violent juvenile offender of today” (Collier 40). Even though the severity and amount of crimes has changed, the juvenile justice system has not been reformed to meet these new changes. The punishments that can be assigned and the proceedings of the court have not evolved with the times which causes violent youth offenders to receive minimal punishments and continue to commit more crimes. The devastation that can ensue when a criminal is not punished severely enough can be found in the Darryl hall and Loette Jr. cases. Twelve year old Darryl Hall was abducted at gunpoint by three teenagers in southeastern …show more content…
This is illustrated by the Justice Abe Fortas, “There is much evidence that some juvenile courts... lack the personnel, facilities and techniques to perform adequately as representatives of the state in a parens patriae capacity, at least with respect to children charged with law violation” (Huson 15). The goal of juvenile facilities is to attempt to rehabilitate troubled children, instead of locking them up for the rest of their lives. This holds good intentions, but in many cases the offenders that are put into the rehabilitation program are violent offenders who either cannot be rehabilitated or committed crimes that should have earned the long sentences behind bars. Instead, the criminals are released from the rehabilitation program and go out to commit more crimes. This failed rehabilitation of violent youths are demonstrated in the Jesse Timmendequas and 2007 police officer murders. In 1997 Jesse Timmendequas was released early from a juvenile facility, within the month Timmendequas raped and murdered seven year old Megan Kanka. These event prompted the creation on Megan 's law in New Jersey which requires the advanced notification if a sexual predator, no matter the age, is released into a neighborhood (Collier #). The ineffective attempt at rehabilitation caused the death of Megan Kanka, similar events occurred in 2007 when a twenty-six year old

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Trying juveniles and sentencing them to 1o years in prison for a petty crime, as was the case in Sean’s story, is bordering on “criminal” behavior in our justice system. There is a clear difference between being a threat and dangerous, and just being a teenager. It is no doubt that maturity takes different amounts of time for everyone, and it is also clear that the brain has not finished developing until the late 20’s. Why should children be treated as adults when they clearly do not have the same rights or privileges as them (smoking, alcohol, voting, joining the military)? The answer is simple: because it is recognized they are not always capable of making rational adult decisions.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Over 200,000 juveniles are charged in adult courts every year in the United States and should not be (Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults? 11). Even though juveniles are capable of committing violent crimes they should not be tried as adults…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A juvenile has not developed their cognitive skills to fully understand the severity of committing crimes. However, over the years, they have ruled the sentencing of charging a juvenile with life without parole unconstitutional.In a way, this helps to give a juvenile another chance at life. Sometimes, people need that one events that will wake them up and realize that there is more to life. Juveniles are also easily influenced and will feel peer pressured into committing crimes to be accepted by their peers. Guardians also huge role in a juvenile 's delinquent…

    • 1312 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Crime is a tremendous issue in the United States, but it becomes controversial when the age of offenders drops at a massive rate over the years. The United States has tried Juvenile offenders as adults for committing heinous crimes. However, citizens all over the country have argued that juveniles are too young for such punishments. The United States has developed the juvenile court system to trial minors, under the age of eighteen, differently from those in adult prison. However, the crime rate for juveniles has become massive, and in a large degree.…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile Crimes

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages

    When they say “I am just a child, I did not know” for the majority of the time it is a lie or some form of excuse but that response cannot be tolerated. Limiting the danger to people is the number one thing on the list because some of these juveniles are a threat to society. In the same article, it states, “But youthful offenders sometimes commit heinous crimes…Many do so with full knowledge of the wrongfulness of their actions...” (Billitteri, 2010). A juvenile who knows what they are doing, but never learn from the errors of their ways only leads to the crime becoming even more horrific than it already…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The juvenile system serves a critical role in the consequence lives of juvenile lawbreakers. As a result, its eradication will cause negative effects on the society at large. If juvenile courts are eradicated, young lawbreakers will begin being tried in adult courts. For young wrongdoers to be tried in adult courts it means that the required rehabilitation, as well as treatment process that as young juveniles should pass through, will not be attained. In adult courts, there are no programs that are fit for the rehabilitation of young evil doers.…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile Court System

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Should Juveniles be tried as Adults? Draft #1 Juvenile court systems are the first line of defence against youth crimes. This system is quickly failing to produce the appropriate punishments for major youth crimes passing the responsibility to the guardians and off of the child. Supporting the trial of juveniles as adults is imperative in creating a safe and secure society. The Juvenile system is often criticised for being highly flawed, the system based off of rehabilitation minimalizes the seriousness of the crime committed.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The opposition believes that juveniles should be allowed to be sentenced to mandatory life in prison.the opposition claims that recent brain research made on teen brains has nothing to do with teens committing crime. Author of On Punishment and Teen Killers, Jennifer Jenkins claims that, “ Advocates often repeat, but truly misunderstand brain research on this issue. The actual science does not… in any way negate criminal culpability” (Jenkins). The idea behind this statement is that the recent research on teenage brains is invalid for proving a juvenile less innocent. This idea is highly disagreeable because juveniles are nothing like adults especially in decision making.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moreover, many of the younge criminals come from families without education or where daily violence within the family is present. They may have been influenced by family members or friends in committing a crime and do not have the maturity to understand the actions. They may have been helping a crime to be committed without committing it themselves. It is cruel and unusual to leave young individuals within prison walls for their entire lives. Indeed, the aim of being imprisoned should not be punishment but to reeducate them in order for them to understand what the correct values to follow are and to give them an opportunity to improve themselves.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile offenders should not receive life sentence because they have not experienced life long enough to realize what they have did was wrong but, the juvenile’s in my opinion should have to a sort of community work or program to see the real views on life to understand what they did was wrong. Sending juvenile’s to prison is not the answer for many reasons including the violence that happens in prison’s, there is also a higher returning rate after juveniles have went in once, lastly, teenagers aren’t fully developed. Some people can argue against juvenile offenders receiving life sentences, it will keep the teenagers detained so they are not able to commit more crimes and a risk to the public. Violence in prisons is very serious. When juvenile…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics