Should College Athletes Be Paid Analysis

Improved Essays
Should Athletes Be Paid There are many different arguments going on right now in colleges about student athletes. The main one is if athletes should or should not be paid. In the article titled 7 Common Sense Reasons Why College Athletes Should Be Paid (According to Jay Bilas), Peebles interviews Bilas on the controversial topic: payment of college athletes. Many people believe that scholarships, grants, and loans are enough for the athletes. However, Peebles and Bilas are strong believers of college athletes being paid. Even during the interview he uses the opposing side to prove his views on paying college athletes. This statement works well because Bilas’ arguments in Peebles’ interview are well supported with great ethical …show more content…
In the beginning of each point he uses the counter argument. Then after the counter argument he disagrees with it and urges that colleges should pay their athletes. Bilas urges, “Boy, we pay the athletes and all of a sudden everybody is going to drop every sport” ( Peebles qtd 8). This is the counter argument for his fourth point. In the counter argument he says that all of the sports that do not get as much money, like the rowing teams, as the bigger programs will lose athletes like the rowing teams and the sport will become less popular, but Bilas declares: “ That’s a lie. It’s all a lie” (qtd in Peebles 8). After, he says this they will not cancel the programs if it is in the universities’ and athletes’ interests. He continues to talk about the the interest of the universities’. Next Bilas pronounces, “First of all people will say ‘What's next?’ Do you want to pay high school players next?” (Qtd in Peebles 4). Following this he talks about how high school athletes are not a multi-billion dollar industry, like college sports are. He continues by talking about how the athletes and premonitions are nowhere near the college level, but there are some similarities. The ethical appeals work really well with the interview. It works well with Bilas’ interview because he points out the counter arguments and …show more content…
The appeals that he uses all refer back to why athletes should be paid. Peebles starts off with an excellent logical appeal in the introductory paragraph. In the introductory paragraph he points out that the college coaches are making millions. In this section Peebles outlines, “The head coaches of the championship game, Mike Kryzewski of Duke and Bo Ryan of Wisconsin, made a combined salary of $12,628,032 this year” (Peebles 2). This appeal works to help prove the point perfectly. It shows that the coaches are making a ton of money and that the colleges could do something else with that money. He continues by proving that NCAA and colleges make billions of dollars, and the players make none. Proving that the NCAA and colleges makes a ton of money and the players make none. It really helps him persuade the people reading that there is money that the colleges have plenty of money to be pay the players. For Bilas’ first point he refers to the NCAA as a machine. Bilas shares, “If you’re an athlete that happens to make the schools in the NCAA machine billions of dollars, then the athletes are told, ‘You get only your expenses’” (qtd in Peebles 3). This quote works really well because it basically says that the NCAA and colleges are making a surplus of money and then the athletes are told that they just get expenses from scholarships. He also uses it throughout the interview, by calling the NCAA

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Without their talents, physical and emotional sacrifices, the institutions will not be able to establish all of the above programs or benefits for the athletes. The argument is not about the benefits, reward or how much they should be paid and who should be paid more. It is about establishing the groundwork for college athletes to be paid for their labor. Their high work that has become a multibillion dollar business nationwide in everything. The TV programs, ticketing, clothing (uniforms, T-shirts) and other elements, therefore the college athletes should be…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College sports provide a huge source of colleges’ income. The school takes in money from ticket sales, television contracts, and sport-related merchandise etc. The athletes receive their scholarship and little more. While receiving a free college education is something few people would complain about, when the issue is more closely examined it becomes obvious that it is not enough. The colleges are utilized athletes, and recently the problems that this creates have become more famous.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The NCAA is a member led organization that overviews anything that a college athlete. The NCAA is a billion dollar organization that makes money straight off of college athletics. Even though it is a non profit organization it still makes billions. It maintains this non profit title due to a common academic mission which it shares with the universities and colleges. But the real problem…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many complain for various reasons, as mentioned above, how allowing collegiate athletes to be paid will ruin the point of college. In reality, these athletes are just receiving what they deserve. The NCAA is a billion dollar industry that has more than enough money to pay athletes. The athletes sacrifice countless hours, work themselves to exhaustion, plus carry the burdens of a regular student all in the name of a game-without them there would be nothing. College athletes deserve a portion of the money that they help generate.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay Money in college shouldn’t be a big issue in college they are there to learn a way to make money not to get money easily. There has been lots of talk about this issue because if the NCAA tournaments and all the money that Is being made. People say that not only are players putting their bodies and health on the line be they work really hard for them not getting any part of the money that is being made. The NCAA brings lots of money but athletes are there to represent the college and make some sort of money for the school and to keep the school on the charts. Athletes are hard workers but most of there college is paid of with scholarships this is only one way that athletes get paid and there are other reasons and ways they get paid.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These college athletes are used as employees by the universities to produce a product on the field which can cause them serious injury and brings in profits that they do not see in return. I understand that many people feel like a college scholarship to play college sports is enough and that the universities have stated that they cannot afford to pay all of the student athletes and that it would be unfair to only pay men’s basketball and football teams. That is why I believe that the “Olympic Model” is the solution to this issue because now it gives all college athletes from all sports to get paid, it takes pressure of the universities to pay the athletes, and is completely separate from the financial aid aspect. The “Olympic Model” is based off of how Olympic athletes make money for a living because they get paid very low sums of money by their countries and it gives them an opportunity to gain financial security based on their individual performance. By introducing this into college sports you would allow for college athletes to get money from endorsements, autographs, jobs, and control their own image.…

    • 1793 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a lot of controversy revolving around if college athletes should be paid for playing. I 'm here to tell you that I believe they should be paid for their services. There are many reasons why this should be in effect real soon and I 'm going to explain why. First off, I think the biggest reason of why they should get paid is that these colleges make large revenue off of these athletes’ talents these colleges are making millions of dollars a year in revenue and refuse to pay these athletes. The NCAA is a multi BILLION dollar industry and the people who help generate this money don’t receive a dime.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paying College Athletes

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to some, getting a full ride to a college isn’t enough. Many think that college athletes should be getting paid because their sport, is their job. Others think that getting a full ride to go to school is enough and college athletes get enough benefits as it is. College athletes may take an educational decline to support their team but these athletes have many tools for success that everyday students are having to pay for. College athletes shouldn’t be paid to play sports because many are already getting scholarships to help out the financial aspect of college, recruiting athletes would be even more based on having a powerhouse, wealthy school than it already is, and these athletes are given an opportunity to become professional athletes,…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the reasons is that students are already receiving scholarship for playing sports in college. Some analyst argues that fiving them full scholarships for the college is enough for them. “Scholarships granted to student athletes cover tuition, fees, room, board and textbooks, according to the National Collegiate Athletic Association website”(Block). Students are already receiving the basic necessity for their college; furthermore they should not be paid. Being a college athlete, it’s basically a VIP treatment for them; they have more advantage than their comrades.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For many years many people have debated on whether or no these college athletes should be paid or not. With the amount of income that NCAA has been generating. Student athletes should not be paid because they are receiving a free education, free products, and free publicity. With college sports being one the most watched sports it has made a lot of income. Being that so many people watch college sports and there is so many NCAA teams out there in this country, the NCAA organization has generated over millions of dollars becoming one of Americas billion dollar industries.…

    • 2261 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays