Pros And Cons Of Keeping Animals In Captivity

Improved Essays
Title:
Should Animals Be Kept in Captivity?

Introduction:
Nowadays, there are not many people in Hong Kong who have not visited a zoo in their lifetime. People are able to get relatively close to different types of animals though going to Ocean Park, Hong Kong Zoological and Botanical Gardens, Tuen Mun Reptile House, etc. When we are having fun in those places, it is also important to think of the feeling of those animals who are being displayed. Opponents argue that it is erroneous to remove wild animals from their habitat, that they ought to be left in natural surroundings but not used as tools for public entertainment (idebate.org, 2012). Proponents respond that zoos are beneficial both the animals and the public, that they protect species from endangered, and shape the animals as an educational tool to increase public awareness and understanding (idebate.org, 2012). This essay will analyze the pons and cons of keeping animals in captivity.

For:
The main reason that people support keeping animals in captivity is to protect species from endangered. The number of the wild population are losing. In the African Game Trails (Theodore, 2001), the former President pointed out there is no danger that the elephant will become extinct as
…show more content…
Keeping animals in captivity helps to protect species from endangered but limited their freedom. In Hong Kong, the major function of zoos is to provide amusement for people. Nevertheless, it is hard to see how could it be the possible justification for keeping wild animals in captivity. ‘Indeed, couldn't most of the important educational objectives better be achieved by exhibiting empty cages with explanations of why they are empty?’ (Jamieson, 1985). No matter we are for or against keeping animals in captivity, never should we forget the final goal. It is sure that all animal-lovers have one common goal - ensuring the welfare of the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When families go to SeaWorld they are surrounded by sea creatures; some of the main attractions include dolphin shows and sensational performances of the Killer Whales. Audiences view the shows and enjoy tricks that trainers and animals perform. However, they can be dangerous but can still have a playful personality with a lot of intelligence (Kirby, 3). Unfortunately, these large animals are in tanks that keep them restricted from returning to the ocean, thus placing themselves and their trainers in danger. Orcas have been known for attacking their trainers, like Dawn Brancheau in 2010.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animals are treated unethically in zoos around the world, especially when it comes to captive breeding programs that ultimately do not help with reintroduction into the wild. Zoos may claim that their methods are ethical and are beneficial to the environment and the species in question, but their practices end up hurting the animal in the long run. These problems in the system lead to the suffering of many animals in the pursuit of the perfect animal to release. Not only created for entertainment as they claim, zoos have been breeding animals and sending them back into the wild to die. Maybe one day, the typical scene at a zoo will be a tour showing animals in a wildlife preserve- safe, happy, and…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For example, the American Zoo and Aquarium Association commissioned a literature review that investigated the efficacy of zoos and aquariums in terms of education which concluded that “little to no systematic research has been conducted on the impacts of visits to zoos and aquariums on visitor conservation knowledge, awareness, affect, or behaviour”. While the findings that are available have shown that zoo-goers hold the prejudices against animals that are consistent with the general public (Jamieson 2006: 135). Furthermore, research (Ludwig 1981) found that the average zoo-goer only really pauses to view baby animals, or those who capture their attention with a striking behaviour. Moreover, it was reported that the most commonly used words to describe animals being viewed were those such as “cute”, “dirty”, and “weird”, not utterances that spring to mind when one thinks about education and understanding. Consequently, we can reject the claims that zoos offer worthwhile benefits in relation to education that justify animal confinement, given that there is no real evidence in support of this claim, while there is evidence that suggests that zoos and aquariums do not succeed in significantly educating people.…

    • 1982 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zoos can help care for animals in need and can better help their health. Zoos are a safe and happy place for animals to grow and evolve and for children and families to come and experience the joy of a zoo. Animals are able to live their lives to the fullest while being at zoos. In a report from Frontline "A Whale Of A Business,” by Eric Holt, states "Those who work with captive animals in aquariums and zoos have a special obligation to convey knowledge of the natural world to the public, to interpret the lives of animals accurately .." The article talks about how the workers at zoos are prepared to take care of any problem with any animal.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The zoos should make a commitment into changing visitors’ perceptions about zoos and the way people are operating the zoos. Therefore, after listing some of the facts and statistics that can help people to acknowledge on animal captivity topic is not a right act because of using captivity animals as entertainment without having any freedom, confined living spaces, and the suffering of animals’ health.…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Keeping Animals In Zoos

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Animal captivity is a cruel, miserable, and an unhappy thing for animals in zoos. Zookeepers are not feeding animals enough food or giving animals enough space to play in the cages at zoos and aquariums, too. Animals all over the world need more care, more safety and more room to play with their type of species. Animals keep dying because zoo keepers and owners can not take good enough care of the animals, or have the time to feed the animals, or take the time to take good care of the animals. Animals in zoos are trapped in cages, all day every day.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is Animal Captivity Wrong

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Imagine you are at the zoo with your friends or family enjoying the displays of the different species inhabiting the zoo. Now some might think animals being kept in this kind of situation are being treated unfairly and I am inclined to agree to some degree but there are other situations that we need to dive deeper into. Animal captivity can sometimes be a problem but I am going to shed light on multiple situations where animal captivity actually helps the animals flourish. In my opinion, it is fine for animals to be in captivity as long as the captivity isn’t harming the animals, using the animals solely for entertainment purposes, or is helping create better lifestyles for the animals that are being held in captivity or even out in the wild.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine a person spending their entire life kept in a cage -- away from home, where they are meant to be. Animals in zoos and circuses should not be held captive. Notable reasons why I believe animal captivity is wrong are due to the size and limitations of the living areas these animals are in, the danger these animals possess to humans, and because they are taken from the wild at an early age. Every day, all around the world, animals are held captive under no free will, and every one of those days is a waste of a healthy life for these animals. At SeaWorld San Diego, the parking lot is about twenty times larger than the actual tank the killer whales reside in.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Zoochosis In Zoo Animals

    • 1815 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Stepping inside a zoo is like setting foot in the wild; with the only difference that the animals are enclosed behind bars and some are within a distance for public safety. Zoo animals, who are held in captivity, are restrained from having the freedom they were evolved to take advantage from because they are preserved for public education and amusement. What may seem like a friendly establishment for wild animals is in reality a park where animals: are used for “educational” purposes, are deprived from having an adequate environment where they can act like animals, suffer from stereotypical behaviors where their behaviors alternate, and are considered to be money makers rather than animals who are being preserved. When humans enjoy visitations…

    • 1815 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal Cruelty In Zoos

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Imagine a young helpless animal being taken from its home in the wildlife and held in captivity, behind bars and gates, held a prisoner to the world. Each year, thousands of animals are ripped away from their homes and their families and are used for entertainment. Zoos are a popular attraction for kids and adults; it gives people the opportunity to get up close and personal with some their favorite animals. Zoos even allow people to feed and pet the animals, which make zoos very well-liked and enjoyable amongst all the animals’ lovers. What people tend to overlook when visiting these zoos is all the nutritional and emotional deprivation the animals go through each day, nor does anyone know the animal cruelty that goes on when the zoos are closed.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So that there were no more animals in cages/spaces too small for them and species were no longer used for tricks to boost entertainment. This would still not be justifiable for having animals in cages. When on a large majority, once the species is in captivity the behavioural traits and domestication that occurs despite all attempts to avoid them, stops the primary aim of restoring biodiversity. Therefore, it can be seen that they are being kept in captivity for no valuable reason. However, this view is different when compared to rehabilitation centres for animals that are injured or threatened.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Have you ever realized how zoo animals live? Imagine seeing an elephant in the zoo just standing there doing nothing, but then in movies and pictures you see them always walking and playing just always doing something. They don't have that choice in the zoo. Animals should not be kept in zoos or in captivity because they don't have the life they would have in their natural habitat, they are not taken care of well and they are not happy.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From zoos, to aquariums, to petting zoos, and even our own pets, humans have always been fascinated by animals, and have gone to certain extents to use them for learning purposes, preservation, survival, companionship, and occasionally entertainment. Menageries allow people to learn about animals from a safe distance and see some animals which they would never have seen if it were not for wildlife parks. Many argue that captive animals are not happy in their environment, and should be set free from zoos in their natural habitat. Although many find captivity cruel and unnecessary, having animals in captivity is beneficial to our society as well as to captive animals because when done right, endangered species are protected and well taken care of, people are able to experience beautiful wildlife,…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is animal captivity wrong? The answer to this rhetorical question can diverge into many directions. The world has been eagerly waiting for the answer from the researchers. The public has been protesting against animal captivity but how long will the protest last for? Will there ever be a change?…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Importance Of Zoos

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Animals need to have access to enrichment activities that allow them to express their natural behavior. These enrichment activities or toys aim to encourage natural behaviours such as hunting, use of scent and hiding food, provide animal welfare by increasing exercise, satisfying ‘behavioural needs’ and stimulating animals, and to promote visitor education so that visitors can gain a better understanding of their natural behaviours and interests. An example of enrichment provided to animals in captivity is the lions. Lions are given ostrich eggs or pumpkin seeds to spark their curiosity, fragrant herbs and oils to excite the senses and specially made toys to encourage natural behaviours such as hunting and stalking. Another animal which receives enrichment is bears.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays