Cluny III Case Study

Great Essays
Introduction
Cluny III is part of a Benedictine commune in Burgundy, France. Cluny is remarkable for several reasons, namely for the sheer size of its church. Its vast size secured it as the largest building in the world until the rebuilding of St. Peter’s, which was constructed to intentionally be a few inches larger than Cluny III. Due to its 1000-foot height, some even considered it to be the “angels’ courtyard” should the inhabitants of heaven “content themselves with our terrestrial dwelling.” Aside from its size, Cluny was the first monastery to enjoy the right of being its own autonomous state that only had to refer to the pope. “Cluny sought to implement the Benedictine program more fully by achieving independence from secular authorities,”
…show more content…
Architecturally, the center of a building could be the section that is most captivating, houses the most activity, or has the most significance to the buildings purpose. In the case of Cluny III, the center is the eastern side of the church, specifically the chevet. Even though it is at the end of the building it is eye-catching in its beauty with its rounded walls, layers of windows, and assumed acoustic qualities. The roof was intentional constructed in a dome-like way to allow for better acoustic properties to enhance the beauty of the Benedictine chants that took place there. The cascading effect of the roofs make this end of the church particularly visually interesting and beautiful. One can only imagine how the sound of the monks chanting could entirely envelope a person in the church. The other area that I find particularly interesting in this part of the church is the ambulatory. There was a previous tragic incident in which pilgrims were trampled when trying to observe the holy relics housed in the particular church. This was in part due to the poor layout of the area that housed the relics. Cluny III sought to avoid this tragedy happening again, which resulted in the rounded ambulatory. This, paired with the aisles alongside the main nave allowed for unobtrusive and functional observation of the relics. This is just one of the many examples …show more content…
This was standard practice of church and cathedral building during medieval times, stemming from the belief that the Messiah will rise from that direction upon his return. The beautiful chevet was also built facing the east so that the light from the morning sun could pour in through the many windows, washing over the people as they recited their morning prayers. The transepts, however, interrupt the east/west orientation and instead hold a north/south position. They are constructed to form a cross shape, which was a common design of the basilica. Cluny III uniquely has two transepts on its east end, creating somewhat of a double cross shape.

Conclusion Cluny III was much more than merely the largest church in the world. This incredible abbey defied structural limitations of the time, provided an organizational structure to the scattered Benedictine priories all over the French countryside and utilized a seamless mix of Romanesque and Gothic architectural qualities, proving that styles are not merely frozen in time. “In itself it was no more than a small, enclosed world…yet its shadow reached out to the most distant corners of the continent, and even beyond.” It is a beautiful thing when architecture can pull of such an amazing

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    1. The Abbey Church of St. Denis was originally a martyrium located in St. Dennis, France until it was rebuilt there as a church beginning in 754 CE. Around 1135 CE Abbot Suger commissioned the reconstruction of the church into the gothic form it has today, the last aspect of his recreation being completed in 1144 CE. While the identity of the architects are unknown, Suger was involved in the reconstruction’s design. Later, Abbot Obo Clement would rebuild the nave in 1231 CE.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    No matter where you look in today’s cities, towns, and communities, one can see similarities of the architecture to those of ancient times. Many of today’s building all across the country have similarities to buildings of the ancient world and does not just appear in the realm of religious institutions, banks, or government buildings. Buildings at Colleges, insurance companies, banquet halls, auditoriums, palaces, temples, castles, monasteries, and even convention centers for example are designed and built to resemble and lay tribute to structures of the past. When exploring the Cathedral of St. Raphael in downtown Dubuque, it is evident that the design and architecture was inspired by ancient structures from the past. The Byzantine period…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This integrated, “pointed arches, ribbed vault, and flying buttresses” (Doc. 14). These innovations of construction allowed architects to make cathedrals both more open, and brighter. This helped to reflect the Catholic Church in its message, but also represents the time period:…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marvin Trachtenberg, “Suger’s Miracles, Branner’s Bourges: Reflections on “Gothic Architecture” as Medieval Modernism”, Gesta, 39.2 (2000)m 183-205. In his article, Marvin Trachtenberg aims to redefine our understanding of words like “modern” and “historicism” in regards to Gothic architecture. To prove his point, he uses Suger’s St. Denis along with Bourges Cathedral as examples, but he begins with a lengthy investigation into the language we use to describe Gothic architecture, including the word itself. Trachtenberg proposes the elimination of the “Gothic architecture,” as a label and instead adopting the term “medieval modernism” to describe the architecture we see from the time period.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Additionally, the buildings themselves are impressive. Although architectural styles different from place to place, building to building, there are some basic features that were universal in monumental churches built in the Middle Ages. The prototype for that…

    • 164 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    7.4 Identify the distinctive features of basilicas and central-plan churches, and discuss how the forms of these early churches were geared toward specific types of Christian worship and devotional practice. After the Edict of Milan was issued, early Christians were allowed to meet freely for the first time. They needed a place to gather, and their churches were based on two types of pagan roman architecture, longitudinal and central plans. This was not the first time Christian art and architecture was based on previous pagan structures, for example, orant figures, people worshipping with their arms stretched out, can be pagan or Christian or Jewish.…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gothic cathedrals and Greek temples are both considered sacred architecture. Scared architecture (or religious architecture) is dedicated to the design and structure of places of worship. This beautiful type of architecture is developed in its own unique way that has spanned over years and years of time. Creative minds, hard working people, and the people of the time helped contribute to these magnificent buildings, and even today these structures are an important part of human history. Gothic Cathedrals are intricately designed architectural features, which date back to 1144 and earlier.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Brief Glance at Rostin Yates The cathedral was the only unrefined building for fifty kilometres. Grasping at the sky, the peak of the church clawed the clouds, a shard against smooth architecture. It was dingy and the walls were covered in years of smog. It had fallen into abandon, its large oaken doors cracked and chipped.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Filippo Brunelleschi

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Walking through one of the basements of a dorm building on the UMN campus, the first thought that came to mind was the placement and pattern of the tile. Unlike most tile, this flooring was a particular pattern that’s use was essential in building one of the largest domes in the world; herringbone or spina pesce meaning “spine of the fish” (Great Cathedral Mystery). The largest masonry dome in the world sits on top of the Santa Maria del Fiore cathedral in Florence, Italy and was built mainly by the master mason—and later capomaestro, an architect-in-chief—of the name Filippo Brunelleschi. Ingeniously designed, the dome continues to awe scientists and tourists alike—in addition—archeologist, architects, and engineers alike question the process…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This space served a monastic function for the members of the Capuchin Order, to which the church was assigned (footnote). The nave was congressional and served the Doge’s need for a grand processional space. The tribune and side chapels served the votive function. These spaces are clearly separated − the nave from the tribune by colossal piers that seem to frame the altar; the choir from the tribune by a screen, or exedra, of four columns that still allow for the passage of light. However, this sequence of magnificent spaces was not in line with the beliefs of the Capuchins, an austere offshoot of the Franciscan Order founded in 1520 with the goal of returning to the original tenets of…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Gothic Cathedrals

    • 2265 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Bishop Maurice drew a plan on the ground with a stick to show the builders his dream of the cathedral that would rise above Paris and when they told him that there wouldn’t be enough space, he demanded that they pull down the surrounding houses to make room. Bishop Maurice was a rich man, so he paid for the best stonemasons, the most skilled carpenters, and the finest painters to be summoned from all over France. As the walls of Notre Dame rose from the ground, people began to realize how special it was going to be. Like most Gothic cathedrals, the building of Notre dame was done by the entire community, where all of the classes took part. Everybody wanted to make an equal contribution to God and Mary, so everyone did their best to help out.…

    • 2265 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pantheon Odyssey

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Pantheon The Pantheon, which means “all the gods”, is a Roman temple that was commissioned by Emperor Hadrian, says Cartwright, in honor of Marcus Agrippa. Today the Pantheon is a major tourist attraction because it is the most well preserved building of ancient Rome, during the years 118 - 125 A.D. From the very front, the Pantheon building comes up to a point, making an obtuse triangle. Bellow one will find an inscription saying “M. AGRIPPA L.F. COS TERTIUM FECIT”, which reads, “Marcus Agrippa, son of Lucius, three-time consul, made this” (Cartwright, "Pantheon”). Dr. Harris and Dr. Zucker inform that there are monolith columns, with no fluting, supporting this triangular shape. These monoliths are important because even though the Pantheon…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparing and Contrasting: The Basilica of Saint Sernin and Cathedral of Chartres Centuries have passed and to this day churches tower above France, marking the astonishing legacy of the Romanesque and Gothic styles designed in the Middle Ages. A Romanesque church example is the Basilica of St. Sernin in Toulouse, France 1080-1120 (fig.1) and an example of a Gothic church is the Cathedrale de Notre Dame de Chartres in Chartres, France 1194-1260 (fig.2). Much like their periods, the Basilica of Saint Sernin and the Cathedral of Chartres have many similarities regarding their styles, function, and context; however also have many differences. The Basilica and the Cathedral both had radiating chapels and apse; vaults, arches; vault supports;…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Basilica of Our Lady of Peace Located in middle of an African coconut plantation, the world largest basilica of the world seems to be the monument towering the horizon. This article written by Tim McDonnel will give an insight on the history and describe the edifice. From the first paragraph, we can clearly see the purpose of the author to show the location of the largest church in the world and some details about what make it so special. He began by giving a description of the landscape surrounding the Basilica. The author, journalist at “climate desk” wrote this article for the public.…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Paul’s to be intentional in conveying what it finds to be theologically significant. Ruth Duck writes that church architecture is a place of encounter between humans and God. Space can set the tone for worship long before an key on the organ is played. The design of the interior St. Paul’s sanctuary puts the altar as the focus of the worship liturgy. Similar to a Gothic Cathedral, St. Paul’s interior seems to express what Duck calls “a sense of transcendence and light.”…

    • 2396 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays