Self Portrait In A Convex Mirror Analysis

Superior Essays
“Self Portrait in a Convex Mirror” by John Ashbery is a work of convoluted reflections engaging Renaissance painter Parmigiano, his painting “Self Portrait in a Convex Mirror”, Ashbery himself, and the soul. The poem’s source of inspiration is a physical piece of art, suggesting the poem belongs in the ekphrasis tradition. Immediate tension arises as the painting and the poem belong to vastly different traditions. The technique of ekphrasis in a postmodern tradition has challenged scholars as it appears the muse and the product regard different things. However, rather than consider the works as dichotomized entities, the shared titles suggest the two must coexist and function together despite appeared incongruity. The paradoxical nature causes …show more content…
The poem is defined by abstractionism yet it is rooted in the unchanging entity of the portrait from which the poem departs and returns. The syntax of “Self Portrait in a Convex Mirror” diverges and wanders from Ashbery’s initial inspiration as a way of including that which is left out of the portrait – the effervescence and elusively of the soul. The half globular shape of inspiration - a wooden sphere cut in half - suggests there is a half missing. Ashbery’s poem is the completion of the sphere, creating a microcosmic globe representative of all art and life. Textual discrepancies – the merging of syntax, paradoxes, and a delineation of time – serve to deconstruct typical ekphrasis to merge the painting and the poem together and invite viewers into active …show more content…
Due to the poem’s length, vague syntax and semantics, and author’s history, there is an array of interpretations and critiques. Scholars often fall into two camps regarding “Self Portrait in a Convex Mirror”: deconstructionist or meditatives. As Looper says: “the words of the poem are not synonymous with or tantamount to that spoken of – any more than the painting is equivalent to that which it depicts” (451). The question then is if there is any true meaning or if meaning is created; the latter being the answer implies that all meanings have validity if there is no objectivity to return to. Looper believes the paradoxes within the poem are not working in relation to the painting, but working to implode the poem and make it incomprehensible to the reader and himself. (451). The reality of the poem is that poem still exists and readers find meaning despite confusions, nullifying possibility of a neat answer to this poem. Likewise, Davidson views the paradoxes and subordinate syntax as an attempt to defer closure (75). These perspective looks at the poem outside of the context of the painting when the two exists symbiotically. Heffernan points out” the poem has begun by suggesting that Parmigiano’s way of representing himself might serve as a model for the poet’s own project in self-representation” (185), suggesting there has to be visible relationship

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    William Wordsworth once wrote “There neither is, not can be, any essential difference between the language and metrical composition” (147). In his book, “Preface to Lyrical Ballads”, Wordsworth argues for a poetry in which the poet puts an emphasis on emotions, rather than intellect, and on resemblance to common life. He uses these ideas about poetry to claim that prose is essentially no different from poetry. However, many readers might find this idea troublesome; certainly short stories differ from poetry. In this paper, I borrow Wordsworth’s ideas about poetry and explain how William Maxwell’s “Love” can be evaluated as poetry, because it results from Maxwell’s overflow of emotions recollected in tranquility.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    T. S. Eliot Modernism

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He argues that personality of a poet is not important, but the poetry he or she produces is. Famously, he observes: “Poetry is not a turning loose of emotion, but an escape from emotion; it is not the expression of personality, but an escape from personality” (156). This is directly opposed to William Wordsworth’s viewpoint expressed in the ‘Preface’ to his Lyrical Ballads (1800) and the Romantic notion that “poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings”. Chinitz notes in his article that “the rift between popular culture and high culture is indeed, for Eliot, nothing less than a further development in the general dissociation of…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Artists can paint life, but they can also portray fantasy or non-reality as a means of expression. The spectator, however, holds the consciousness and decision to interpret the piece of art in his or her own way. Humans see what we want to see. And so most of the time, art reflects our desires instead of life and reality. In the novel, The Picture of Dorian Gray, characters like Lord Henry, Dorian and Sibyl confuse and even manipulate the nature of art, who ultimately are convinced by their own interpretations of a work of art, base their life on that interpretation, and so become troubled when they are exposed to reality because they do not know how to handle it.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Of the content, Hegel believes it is wholly accidental and the only important thing is the poet’s treatment and presentation of such ideas (p.. Here I wonder, as Hegel never explicitly argues on implied meaning, whether the reader is meant to disregard their own relations and derivations of the poem’s meaning and submit to the poet’s intended meaning? If this is true, then I feel strongly that this is a shortcoming of his theory, as the pleasure in reading The Disappointment is directly correlated with the associations and relations of each of the particular aspects–form, content, sounds, rhythm. The mood or general reflection aroused poetically by the external object forms the centre of the “spirit”,…

    • 1070 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sidney acknowledges the charges that poetry is an inferior school of learning, that poetry is a false representation of reality and that poetry is an effeminate pursuit. These accusations against poetry reflect the social context of the time regarding the dominance of philosophy and history as schools of knowledge, Plato and Gosson’s authority on the standing of poetry and the fear that poetry could corrupt the morals of the individual. Disputing these accusations, Sidney argues that history and philosophy and wrongfully hold their status as superior forms of knowledge. Sidney removes the authority of poetry’s critics by emphasising how poetry works as a genre and uses persuasive techniques, such as repetition, metaphor and highly logical language to manipulate the reader and balance his controversial…

    • 2396 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Text means tissue” Roland Barthes once stated, emphasizing that a text should not be viewed as a finished product “behind which lies, more or less hidden, meaning (truth)” but rather as a fluid entity which “is worked out in a perpetual interweaving” (64). Thus, a text does not hide one single truth, waiting to be discovered, but – in perpetual interaction with its readers – creates or at least permits a multiplicity of meanings. Symptomatic of the complexity of meanings woven into a single text are the diverse theoretical approaches that were applied to Margaret Atwood’s poem “This is a Photograph of Me” and the very different interpretations they provided. While some critics interpreted the text as an illustration of the visual power of…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates Poetry Analysis

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ion has no knowledge of Homer and poetry because if one can point out flaws and excellences of one poet, they should also be able to point out the same for another, otherwise their argument is invalid. Moreover, poets are said to be interpreters of the gods, making Ion to be considered an interpreter of an interpreter. Socrates believes that these interpretations get farther from the truth of nature, which aligns with his argument supporting the banishment of imitative poetry. I agree that Ion cannot make a judgment about one poet if he has no knowledge of other poets. If one does not have knowledge of a subject, the argument of superiority is not valid because every aspect of that subject is not known.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He complicates the task more by claiming that poetry must strive to stay away from common language and overused phrases. How can this be achieved while remaining “perspicuous” to the audience? This seemingly contradictory charge reveals the difficulty of writing poetry and creating art. The poet’s job is find balance between the two; a poet must remain understandable while avoiding common language while also conveying ideas in elevated style. Addison conveys this idea by staying that “the judgment of a poet very much discovers itself in shunning the common roads of expression without falling into such ways of speech as may seem stiff and unnatural” (Addison 430).…

    • 1783 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Frost applies his ideas about form to the art of poetry, he shifts his concern with universal chaos to the “wildness” of the creative impulse (Harris 5). A poet should not attempt to place content in a chosen form, rather allow the ideas and thoughts come naturally, a technique Frost exercised…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through his approach, Shelley argues against institutions that dismiss the cognitive prowess of poetry, and develops a principle that supports his belief of poetry being the wheel that turns society. Poetry involves the synthesis of imagination and reason, and with these conditions analysis begins. The mind undergoes a process of thought by mixing principles such as elements, nature, and many other representations to form a perception that explains general results. Although imagination and…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays