Martha Stout's When I Woke Up Tuesday, It Was Friday

Great Essays
The Extremes of Self Discovery
An individual may struggle all of his or her life to figure out who he or she is as an individual for the duration of his or her life, usually beginning with one’s past. The past always has a way to seemingly define a person’s personality and characteristics. As a result, depending on the type of past that a person has experienced, as an individual matures he or she will try to go against his or her upbringing and family situation while other individuals may attempt to hold on to the past in order to discover his or her roots. This notion of self-discovery was explored in “When I Woke Up Tuesday, It Was Friday” by Martha Stout in relation to trauma victims. Stout, a psychologist, interviewed trauma victims, in
…show more content…
In particular, Stout explored the mental disorder of dissociation that a victim of trauma unconsciously utilizes to protect his or her mind from the horror of the trauma that a victim has experienced. While this method of self-protection may seem ideal, for a trauma victim he or she may suffer moments of time where he or she may completely blank out from reality. This phenomenon hampers a trauma victim’s efforts as he or she may try to retrieve one’s repressed memories to uncover parts of his or her identity. Another psychologist, Leslie Bell, also studied how people go to extreme lengths to change how people depict an individual’s character based on deemed societal norms. Bell wrote about her findings in an essay “Hard to Get: Twenty-Something Women and the Paradox of Sexual Freedom,” where women, in particular, often suffer from the dictated norms of society in regards to sex.. The women that Bell interview portray their journey of splitting, in essence creating another identity consciously, in an attempt to satisfy their sexual desires. Both texts thoroughly explore the struggle of an individual attempting to discover who he or she may be. However, regardless of a person’s past, those experiences aid in defining a …show more content…
Any individual experiences moments where he or she cannot seem to hold on to who he or she may be as a person. This divide is more extreme in people who suffer from dissociation and splitting. For these people the question of how to approach rediscovering his or her identity can be difficult. Another one of Stout’s patient’s, Seth, recounted how he was able to maintain his consciousness in the present and did not succumb to dissociation. This was a major feat to accomplish. Seth was able to accomplish this “By trying with everything [he had] to concentrate on [Stout], and what [Stout] was saying and on the things around [him] in the office [t]here” (Stout 434). The level of concentration required for a person suffering from dissociation is immense. While an individual is trying to keep his or her conscious in reality he or she is actively attempting to overcome his or her separation of consciousness. When this step is taken, an individual may then remember the importance of living in the present and not unconsciously being consumed by his or her memories. This action will then help an individual to reclaim the lost parts of his or her identity, thereby gradually overcoming his or her oppressing traumatic memories. Even in a situation where an individual is conscious of separating one’s identity may also experience a sense of loss from the extremes of one’s

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Vulnerability is a personal human flaw that people try to fix through drastic individual changes. When a person feels vulnerable, their attempts to hide their vulnerability come at the price of psychological alterations, ranging from abnormal personalities to complete lifestyle changes. Leslie Bell 's Hard to Get: Twenty Something Women and the Paradox of Sexual Freedom presents the scenario of altering one 's personal life to avoid feelings of vulnerability in relationships. This, in turn, gives the individual a false self-esteem due to attempts to mask a flaw, as demonstrated through Jean Twenge 's An Army of One: Me. These psychological alterations stem from the fundamental human desire to have positive views of personal life experiences,…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Herman argues that the symptoms of survivors that endure perpetual, chronic trauma are far more intricate. This intricacy comes in the forms of characteristic personality changes in addition to relationship and identity issues. In terms of childhood abuse survivors, they too suffer from these problems, along with their susceptibility to self-harm as…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This also occurs in horror stories, where the main character suffers through a traumatic experience which results in the change of their mental state leading to the loss of reality. In the short story The Real Bad Friend, the main character George Foster Pendleton “didn’t like to think about the service, or going haywire there on the island and trying to strangle the sergeant, and ending up in stockade” (Bloch 321), changing his environment from a suburban lifestyle to a cold stoned cell. Likewise, this change of environment is a prime cause in George’s loss of reality due to the fact that his normal mental state cannot cope with the idea of being in solitude. In the film The Others, the protagonist Grace and her children uncover the truth in which there are ghosts present in their household. Grace slowly loses her sense of reality and she makes an unexpected action by strangling her daughter Anne after mistaking her for one of the visitors - who Anne explains earlier in the movie is an old lady with cloudy eyes (Amenábar 2001).…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Everyone has their different ways of escaping. As to what, and how one escapes, however, is left to the individual, but solace is found regardless of the method employed. In chapter 4 from lines 35 to 51 of Tracy Lindberg’s novel, Birdie, the reader is engulfed by the poignant stench of gin as Bernice’s thought process and seduction techniques are revealed through first person narration. Comparatively, the damaging manner in which she conducts herself exemplifies the behavioural impacts intergenerational trauma has as a result of the adverse environmental conditions she faces as an indigenous woman. Subsequently, through a cross-examination of Bernice’s behaviours, actions, and thoughts in her sleeping and waking state, Lindberg suggests that…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jack Wolff Identity Essay

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The summer of 1955 is an unordinary summer for Jack Wolff. Trapped in the transitioning body of an eleven-year-old boy, Jack is drowning in the emotional trauma of a violent home life, illegal activities, and a lack of emotional support known as his childhood. This is a major period of change for any young boy, and dealing with the extensive distress does not allow him to mature in the conventional manner. Due to his abnormal progression, a common theme arises within the first part Jack’s life: a lack of identity and a lack self-worth fuels the constant need for power.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thurman's idea of selflessness, from the beginning, seems similar regarding the issue. Thurman's practice, be that as it may, would not be useful to the individuals who experience the unpleasant effects of dissociative disorder like Stout's patients. Or maybe, it is sadly unable to face the fact that it neglects to address their situation and to give a reasoned arrangement. Robert Thurman writes, “You have a terrorist in your own brain, coming out of your own instincts and culture” (Thurman 452-53). In his opinion, the “self” is holding the mind hostage, keeping it from completing the thing that it needs to do and constantly forcing it to fit in with social standards.…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    People whose minds resort dissociation may see stressful situations as an out of body experience, as though they are just watching and it is not them being affected by the situation at hand (“Effects of Complex Trauma”). As Perry’s story unfolds throughout In Cold Blood, by Truman Capote, the reader clearly sees the foggy thoughts of children with histories of trauma, Perry easily talks using many words, but is unable to make sense of a situation or see the consequence of his words. To others it may seem as though a person in a state of dissociation is not paying attention or is “spacing out;” this affects victims by making it more difficult to learn, engage in social interactions, and conduct appropriate classroom behavior. The mental stress of maltreatment as a child can greatly affect behavior while growing up ( “The Effect of Childhood Trauma on The Brain”); adolescents and adults can be effortlessly triggered, and will likely react in a vehement manner. Behavior issues can also be characterized by: poor self regulation and impulse control, the ability to think through consequences before taking action, and behaving in what seems to be an unpredictable, volatile, extreme way; a child feeling powerless and fearful of authority may react defensively in response to blame or attack.…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Truth In The Liars Club

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The discovery of oneself occurs in the memoir of Mary Karr’s The Liars’ Club, which is based on a true story as far as the author can recall. The focus is not a whole life account like an autobiography, but a story in the author’s life. The memoir asks the reader to take a lens into truth, memory and how the past connects to the future. Mary Karr’s The Liars’ Club events matter to the reader because they deal with rape, alcoholism and a mother that is nervous in East Texas. So, what matters and doesn’t matter about truth may all be in the perspective of the author, narrator and most importantly the reader.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Recovered Memories

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Believers understand that memories are pushed away as a survival mechanism, and therapeutic assets assist in finding them; not simply creating them. Eileen Franklin’s case proves this. Over the course, Eileen’s memories came back. It was instantaneous as people believe. Instead, it came from similar instances to the main event and came back in pieces.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dissociation Of Identity

    • 1688 Words
    • 7 Pages

    When people are aware of what they want and what is going on around them, their abilities to control their lives are increased. The choice of splitting and dissociation is no longer a threat to their lives; instead, it serves as a coping mechanism to protect and develop themselves from past experiences. In Bell’s essay, Jayanthi split herself from being “good” to “bad” because she wanted a different life from her traditional family and a crazy history about herself. Bell argues that her choice of being a bad girl “allowed Jayanthi to control her identity, rather than having it controlled by either her family or the men she encountered” (Bell 34).…

    • 1688 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is the environment? The environment is everything that surrounds, such as office, colleagues, school, classmates, and the city. When the environment changes, people need to figure the way to fit in; if one cannot adapt to the changes, he or she will be eliminated. Leslie Bell, the professor who taught courses on women’s development at U.C. Berkeley and the author of “Hard to Get: Twenty-Something Women and the Paradox of Sexual Freedom” uses the word “Splitting” to argues that young women usually unconsciously divide their true feeling while exploring the unsettled nature of adulthood. In Bell’s essay, she also split women into two categories.…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lost Identity When faced with a traumatic situation, an individual may experience a loss of identity or have a sense of depersonalization. In the photo captured and edited by Thomas Bouillot entitled “Idea #108”, a feeling of isolation is shared among viewers. The photo represents an individual who has suffered a loss of identity after experiencing a trauma or being put into an unfamiliar situation. When facing an unfamiliar situation, a series of changes may occur to the individual such as their perspective on themselves and people around them and experiencing feelings of isolation and desperation. At one point in my life, I was put into an uncomfortable situation where I experienced all of these changes, resulting in feelings of depersonalization.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Many Faces of Alice Alice Lee Hudson, while technically not the main character of her featured film, is the primary subject of which the movie is based around. Surprisingly enough, John Carpenter’s The Ward stars everyone but Alice as the women of North Bend Psychiatric Hospital fight for their lives against an unknown demonic entity. As each of the girls begin disappearing from their ward one by one, it is revealed that the aforementioned entity is actually Alice and that the other patients are nothing but delusions representing the various pieces of her fractured personality. The main problem Alice faces from the experiences depicted in the film is her ability to remain in control of her own body, ultimately finding herself overpowered…

    • 1898 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On Becoming a Person is a book written by Carl R. Rogers it is a simple text on Humanistic and Existential psychotherapy. The book is written about work Rogers carried out during the nineteen fifty’s and sixty’s. The book has many interesting idea’s and perspectives on personal growth and development. In the book Rogers talks about the idea of oneself getting in touch with there emotions so that he or she might go about there life based on there real self rather living a life based on there false self or who they perceive themselves to be. The conflict between these two selves according to Rogers is a major cause of personal suffering.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Naguib Mahfouz’s, Egyptian writer who won the 1988 Nobel Prize for Literature, short story, “The Answer Is No”, published in 1991 addresses the topic of consent and asserts that traumatic experiences in the past can affect future relationships. Mahfouz supports his claim with foreshadowing about the outcome of the story with the title, similes to compare the rapists overbearing character to a violent current in the ocean, and concrete language to express the emotions the woman is experiencing throughout the story. Mahfouz’s overall purpose is to inform the general public that because one painful incident can negatively impact women, the road to recovering is difficult, as they try to let go of the memories and move on with their lives. Mahfouz…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays