Pros And Cons Of Animals In Captivity

Improved Essays
When families go to SeaWorld they are surrounded by sea creatures; some of the main attractions include dolphin shows and sensational performances of the Killer Whales. Audiences view the shows and enjoy tricks that trainers and animals perform. However, they can be dangerous but can still have a playful personality with a lot of intelligence (Kirby, 3). Unfortunately, these large animals are in tanks that keep them restricted from returning to the ocean, thus placing themselves and their trainers in danger. Orcas have been known for attacking their trainers, like Dawn Brancheau in 2010. She was pulled into the water by a Killer Whale named Tilikum, who has been linked to two other human deaths, and was brutally attacked by him. She died of …show more content…
They cannot survive in those conditions, they are large mammals who need to be surrounded by their own kind. A solution to this can be ending the public displays of orcas, it is manageable and the economic impact would be meager. With the remaining forty two orcas they can be put in retirement in sea pens, or be in rehabilitation and someday return to the wild. These Orcas can have a chance to live longer, and trainers would no longer have to risk their lives training them. If oceanarias are worried about losing profit they could try redesigning orca enclosures to satisfy a Killer Whales’ needs better (Rose, 10). However, for change to happen it needs to bring attention to the media and public. Raising awareness of the dangers of captivity is surfacing more, documentaries like The Cove and Blackfish showed the public what really is going on to these creatures. Due to those films SeaWorld’s profits have dropped and more companies have broken ties with them. Slowly it is becoming accepted that Orcas cannot live in their current tanks, in the future they could have a better living condition whether in a marine theme park or in the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    While doing some research I found an article about Seaworld and what happens to killer whales there, that usually won’t happen. On average, an Orca’s life span is usually 30-50 years, while in captivity 15 years( 8 Reasons Orcas Don’t Belong at Seaworld, PETA). Like in the documentary it is talked about the collapsed dorsal fin, how that just a little indicator the it isn’t a healthy environment( Blackfish, killer whale expert scientist). It mostly happens to male orcas, and it is from not having enough room to swim and having an improper diet (8 Reasons Orcas Don’t Belong at Seaworld,…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ever wonder what goes on behind the scenes of the killer whale shows at SeaWorld? So much preparation goes into the shows at SeaWorld. This causes frustration within the whales that can result in whales acting out on other whales and SeaWorld trainers. So, is captivity good for the orcas? Despite the fact that millions of people go to SeaWorld every year to see the killer whales, the animals are actually mistreated. If SeaWorld doesn’t change their ways, then orcas shouldn’t be in captivity any longer. Four powerful arguments prove that captivity is not suitable for orcas.…

    • 1603 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tilikum Research Paper

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Killer whales are taken from the wild at a very young age. The helpless mothers cry out to the young orca as they’re taken away, never to be seen again. The young orca is then taken away in a speedboat to perform and die in a metal tank. The deepest tank that the orcas are placed in is only forty feet deep, about the size of a bathtub to the whales.. Many orcas suffer from sunburns because in the ocean the whales can swim to deep depths to hide from the burning sun but they are unable to do so in the tank that they live in. Male orcas have a lifespan of about 60 to 70 years while female orcas can live for 90 years, but those held in captivity see an average of nine years. It is not uncommon to see orcas with collapsed dorsal fins. Most orcas held in captivity are ill and as a result their dorsal fin begins to bend. On top of the terrible living space, the trainers that work with the orcas have limited knowledge in marine biology. The trainers are performers not biologists, their job is to put on a good show not to educate the public. I strongly believe that Blackfish exposed the truth about SeaWorld that was being hidden from the public, it is a business after…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yes they live in these conditions, but that is the trade off for having such clean tanks and easy access to medical treatment. According to “5 Arguments For Keeping Captive Cetaceans,” “The temperature and salinity of the water is controlled. After decades of this, plunging these animals back into the oceans could likely be a death sentence.” The orcas are used to the clean regulated water of their tanks, not the polluted water of the ocean; it might take months of slowly making the water less regulated to get the whales used to ocean water before they could be released. Seaworld is also expanding the orcas’ living condition - increasing the size of the habitats, and adding more enrichment programs for the…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blackfish Research Paper

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Killer whales, also known as orcas, are the largest members of the dolphin family and the top predator in their ecosystem. They are one of the most intelligent marine creatures, especially due to their acute senses of sight and hearing. This mammal has an added part of the brain that allows the orcas to communicate between orcas. This language allows them to be social between other whales and also social with human beings. Their beauty has astounded humans for generations, but for many orcas captivity limits their freedom and their quality of life. The inadequate living conditions for the orcas affect them physically and mentally. Sea World, the amusement park, has been profiting off of the giant mammal since 1965. Even though abnormal behavior from the orcas has been witnessed and there have been deaths to trainers - the show must go on. Should SeaWorld be able to continue their shows despite new information about how these mammals are living?…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Orca Captivity

    • 1844 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As of December 2012, 138 reported cases of captive orca attacks upon trainers and visiting pedestrians at SeaWorld and other marine mammal parks have been recorded, three of which resulted in death. The number of reported cases of orca attacks upon humans in the wild is zero (Orca Home). PETA, SeaWorld of Hurt, the Orca Project, and various other organizations contend that SeaWorld 's detainment of orcas for the purposes of entertainment is abusive and violates multiple animal rights. The Orca Project has found captivity of these whales leads to whale to whale aggression, social strife, boredom, and various health issues that lead to their premature deaths (The Orca Project). However, SeaWorld maintains that captivity of these whales is not harmful to the…

    • 1844 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The filmmaker made the SeaWorld trainers explain how the orcas are suffering and why they should be free. They know more about the orcas then any other people because the trainers work with them. One trainer explained that SeaWorld lie to their customers by telling them that orcas live up to 25 to 30 years because they get proper care and…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The way in which Orcas are trained to perform are disgraceful. Sea world tell their customers that the ‘tricks’ that the whales perform are a natural occurrence and can often been seen in the wild, but these allegations are nothing but lies. The whales are being deprived of food for several days or even weeks if they do not perform the tricks that they are trained to do. This causes the animals to become hyper-aggressive. Orcas are also faced with forced breeding, incestuous inbreeding and are kept together in ways that make them aggressive so that they fight and inflict deep gashes on each other, and sea world does nothing about it.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animals should be allowed to live in their natural habitat. Removing an animal from its environment at a young age is similar to separating an infant from its parents and placing it with strangers. Killer whales live in organized social structures, like we do, and are negatively affected when they are separated from their young. Research has repeatedly shown that orcas held in captivity suffer from elevated levels of stress. A clear example of this is seen in the collapsed dorsal fin of captive male orcas. A collapsed dorsal fin is a sign that something is wrong with the killer whale because in nature this does not occur. Many believe that killer whales in captivity receive exceptional veterinary care that helps them live a prolonged and healthy life. These animals are given daily a reliable food source and are not faced with the predators that they could potentially encounter in the open ocean. Though this is a valid point, orcas pose various adaptations which has helped them survive for so long in the marine environment. These adaptations are what makes them the apex predator of the ocean. Personally, after watching this documentary I would not be visiting an aquarium for the reasons mentioned above. As for the whales in captivity, I believe that they should be placed back in the wild but in a controlled manner. Scientists should first ensure that the whales could…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is it finally time to stop keeping orca whales in captivity? An orca whale is expected to live 30-50 years but in captivity the average lifespan is 13 years, that's a big difference. Keeping orcas in aquariums deprives them of crucial aspects of their lives, and in some cases it can even prove dangerous to humans.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orcas In Captivity

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ever since 1961, humans have been removing orcas out of their natural habitats to go to places such as Sea World, where they are forced to perform tricks for people who pay to watch (Blackfish). Unlike orcas in the wild, captive orcas have been known to live shorter lives and go through traumatic experiences. Also, orca captivity has had negative effects on not only the orcas taken captive, but their families too. Due to the negative changes orcas experience from the wild to captivity, orcas should be retained in the wild, shouldn’t be separated from their families, and also should not be held in captivity to perform tricks for visitors.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They don't want you to act like a creature. They want you to be domesticated. As a result of society's farm like vision they've created more domesticated birds. There's no balance within the current structure of humanity we need more wild animals to maintain the equilibrium of biodiversity. We need more evil. There's too much peace in this world.…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Currently there are 50 orcas living in captivity around the world. Majority of them are living in marine lands and amusement parks in tanks that are not even close to their natural environment. The confined quarters and…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    We’ve known that SeaWorld is this fun and amazing park that has different species of sea animals. They have a killer whale show that the park is known for. But what really happens behind the scenes of this “amazing” killer whale show? SeaWorld is known for abusing their killer whales and not giving them the right treatment that they deserve. It is reported that the killer whales have injured and even killed their trainers during the show. The killer whales release their aggression towards their trainers. This aggression caused the death of a trainer called Dawn Brancheau in 2010. A killer whale called Tilikum dismembered, scalped, and drowned Dawn during a show. Since this incident happened, Tilikum has been enclosed in this tiny enclosure…

    • 148 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Orca Essay

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Large companies such as Mattel and Southwest Airlines dropped contracts with SeaWorld (Roony). The opposing side claims that having orcas in captivity helps humans learn more about the creatures. The problem with that argument is that humans are not learning about the natural habits of an orca. A veteran marine-mammal researcher said, “If SeaWorld didn’t exist, would our understanding of wild killer whales be significantly reduced? I think the answer to that is no, it would not (Raja).” Captive research has become less important as the study of orcas in the wild is becoming less difficult. Items such as satellite tagging and biopsy darts have made collecting data much easier. A killer whale feces has even given scientists large amounts of information about orcas without having to disturb them (Raja). Another argument that is made constantly is that SeaWorld extends the lifespans of its animals. Multiple SeaWorld employees claim that because they have the correct veterinary tools, orcas will live longer (Cowperthwaite). This is not true because the oldest orca to live in captivity is thirty-five and is dying (Berlinger). Tilikum is dying from a bacterial infection in his lungs. Tilikum is also the only orca that has made it to age thirty-five. In comparison to orcas in the wild this age gap does not go…

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays