School Uniforms: An Unfashionable Dissent By Dennis L. Evans

Improved Essays
Cons of School Uniform Analysis The article “School uniforms: An ‘unfashionable’ dissent” which was written by Dennis L. Evans, currently the director of UC Irvine’s Administrative Services Credential Program, goes over how the idea of school uniforms does hold some promising features and then the many downsides of those features. This article goes full circle about an internal conflict about conservatism that Mr. Evans is having. Mr. Evans always had thought for himself to be a conservative, but after researching for this article he wrote he feels he is not so sure anymore and criticizes the conservative supporters as hypocrites. Mr. Evans brings up many arguments over his article such as the programs that gain the most parent support for school uniform are from elementary schools, which he states that many of the problems that most of the uniforms solve don’t even exist. This is because the children are not concerned with individuality or personal rights high schoolers are. Another argument the author goes over is the issue of gang affiliation with clothing, although he says that there should already be regulations over this. Therefore, he says that this would make school uniforms irrelevant in this aspect. The author concludes that everyone wearing the same attire could …show more content…
Mr. Evans says that, many young adults do not care about this issue and those who do won’t have their attitudes shifted even with the uniform change. He backs up his claim stating that the uniforms won’t change what cars the students will drive to school, wearing expensive jewelry, or even carrying money around. Another thing is said is that would the school make free of all of the activities such as athletics, prom, and buying school rings or yearbooks? Mr. Evans concludes that economic distinction is a fabric of society and won’t be unraveled by covering students with a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    by, Rob O’Donnell, Linne Hoofnagle, and Alicia Thomas, discusses the facts of why uniforms should not be enforced in schools. First off, Rob O’Donnell talks about how it effects the young person, “How a young person appears makes no difference whatsoever to their education…Schools should be encouraging free thought and self-expression, not suppressing it” (O’Donnell). He is expressing his concern for the students’ freedom of expression. Another reason stated by Linne Hoofnagle is “If we convince ourselves that placing limits on clothing choices will eliminate school bullying, we are kidding ourselves” (Hoofnagle). Bullying is already a big problem in our schools and just because school districts have all kids dress the same definitely, will not make it go away. A point made by Alicia Thomas talks about that point by stating, “While uniforms do assuage the best-clothes competition, they create a new and more painful contest: the best-body competition…They can expect to be ridiculed for not looking as fantastic in their uniforms as some of the better-looking students” (Thomas). She is saying that students could be body shamed for how they look in their specific uniform options. “Uniforms jeopardize the ability of America’s youth to express themselves, to become the people that they want to be” (Thomas). With this statement, she means that students would not be able to express themselves the way the want to with dressing their own ways. Being restricted to few options does not give you very many options to express…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holloman and Sylvan L. Alleyne discuss both sides of the argument on school uniforms. They say uniforms serve as a symbol of the organization/school and reduce the cost of clothes for families. The other side they bring up cultural influences and that uniforms can be targeted toward a certain group of people or clothing item. They also state how public school prohibit certain clothing or grooming practices to address problems with appearance. They pertain to the study of the effects mostly made by dress codes and how they play a role in a community, with and without uniforms. In their journal they describe school uniforms as a intrusion into the private lives of students and has lack of research to show relationships between academic achievement. They conclude with the thought that the community should have a say in decisions such as uniforms…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the districts point of view, they see uniforms as being less of a distraction for students. They don’t want them to place their focus on their social appearances, and get distracted on who is wearing name brand clothing and who is dressed better. The district wants students to attend school and concentrate on their academics. Statistics show that uniforms have had a positive effect on school campuses. For instance, campuses have reported a decline in student’s tardiness, suspensions, amd disciplined referrals. There is even evidence that uniforms have increased pride and unity amongst students. A decline in violence has also been the result from uniforms, because there is no gang identifying colors incorporated into the student dress…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the student essay, United Uniforms, the writer tries to persuade their audience to support the introduction of standardized uniforms for public schools in the United States. The audience for the paper is the American education system and the parents of students. We are given stories of students who took their own lives due to conflicts at school; this is important because schools are often searching for ways to avoid the preventable loss of their students. The paper also explicitly states that parents should support a national uniform policy, directing its attention to this portion of the audience. The writer provided a well-rounded explanation of why uniforms should be supported and why they are important. We are given several reasons for…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pro School Uniforms

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Fifty-four percent of students say their school uniform does not compromise them of their identity, and forty-one percent say they noticed fewer disruptions in the classroom (Lake). The amount of school districts switching to school uniforms is on the rise; however, it is a hot debate right now. A school district is either extremely for or against their school switching to uniforms for many reasons. The school districts that are for switching to uniforms think it will benefit their school by cutting down on discrimination against the low-income students and create equality. They also believe uniforms can help lower the amount of cliques between students, and make the classroom a better learning environment. The school districts that do not…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wardrobe Freedom

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages

    First, spending time and effort implementing uniform policies may detract from more effective efforts to reduce crime in schools and boost student performance. (Starr, Linda) this is saying that spending time getting school uniforms is going to take away effort to abolish crime in schools. Then, more substantive improvements to public education could be achieved with smaller class sizes, tightened security, increased parental involvement, improved facilities, and other measures. (Brunsma, David) This saying that parents and kids will have more time to make their school a better place. Next, Tom Houlihan, former Superintendent of Schools in Oxford, NC, stated that school uniforms “are a distraction from focusing on systematic and fundamental transformation to improve our schools.” (Houlihan,Tom) Finally, school uniforms are not only a distraction, but are restricting kids and parents to make their school a better place to be in, learn in, and feel safe…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Do you think that students should wear, or mandate a type of dress code that aren’t fair? If so, do you think that students will not have the ability to express who they are by wearing certain types of clothes?Do you realize that some parents aren’t able to afford them? School uniforms may be good, but it has bad side effects to it also. Students believe that they don’t have the opportunity to express themselves. “In August of 2007, the district announced: it would relax its dress code for the time being to allow images and fabrics other than solid colors. The district superintendent, while admitting that banning images on clothes raises concerns about the restriction of the political and religious speech, announced his intention to move…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every day students come to school to learn. School makes up about a third of a student's life. Some schools currently have uniforms while others do not. This has been a national debate for years whether it should be mandatory to wear uniforms or not. Although some people believe uniforms don’t benefit students, opponents argue it does and it helps for a variety of reasons. Uniforms should be mandatory because it reduces bullying, gets kids prepared to learn, and it unites the kids together.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the specified springboard selections, there are several opinions concerning school uniforms, some expressing dislike and others showing appreciation. However, the authors of Uniform Opinion and A Blessing in Disguise share an agreement on how school uniforms’ effects are positive. In Uniform Opinion, mentioned is evidence from U.S. schools of the great changes that school uniforms can bring, such as decreases in bullying, school crime, and increases in academic performance. The author of A Blessing in Disguise would agree, as this student expresses gratitude for uniforms at his/her school. The student explains the great benefits of uniforms, similar to the first selection, and how they are convenient, inexpensive (compared to a school wardrobe),…

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Uniqueness is an aspect of life every human being should have the opportunity to feel, but no person can feel unique if he or she looks exactly like the person to his or her left or right. The debate of school uniforms is a problem that causes controversy between different people, groups, and organizations in the world. In “School Uniforms” published by Proscon.org it states the different issues the children and their parents have with uniforms. The uniforms causes different issues for a student and even the parents. The society as a whole also has a problem with the idea of uniforms being needed in school. The idea of school uniforms helping in various ways is no longer being accepted by numerous amounts of people, who find the uniforms…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Haven’t you thought about how unnecessary school uniforms are? I bet you haven’t. Well, it isn’t that big of a deal, or so you think. Picture yourself wearing one. It doesn’t feel like you now, does it? I think so too. Students shouldn’t be needing school uniforms because, one, school uniforms cost a lot of money. Two, the incidents of bullying in uniform wearing schools are 12% higher than the ones with no school uniforms. Lastly, it doesn’t allow individuality.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Several years ago in the United States of America, uniforms were symbolic for a higher socioeconomic status in the private sector of education. Today many public school systems across America have eliminated a dress code and are implementing uniform policies. One in five elementary schools in the United States now requires uniforms, according to The National Center for Education Statistics (“Should Schools Require Uniforms?” 7). On the contrary there has been numerous debates over whether uniforms limits students’ freedom of expression or improves the quality of education students receive. Allowing students to express themselves and individuality is important, however, school should be designed more so as a learning work environment. Mandatory uniforms will help provide a safer environment for students, increase attendance rates and therefore improve overall academic performance.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past decade, there's been an ongoing debate around the school system; uniforms. Many people believe that school uniforms are unnecessary, or that they're simply another item on their kids' back to school supply list. However, statistics have shown that uniforms not only discipline students, but keep them safe, and are cheaper than regular clothes. And while they may not be the most fashionable clothes on the planet, I think we can all agree that keeping our students safe should be valued more than looks.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some parents and students may never like the idea of school uniforms due to students not being able to express themselves through their clothing. However, there are many more positive outlooks than there are negative when it comes to uniforms being enforced in schools. With school uniforms, students can still express themselves through shoes, accessories and hair styles. The enforcement of school uniforms creates a level playing field amongst students, reducing peer pressure and bullying. It also helps diminish the separation of social classes, promotes unity, and helps save parents…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If kids weren’t required to wear a certain dress code, they would’ve the total freedom to come however they feel like. Many people argue that schools who required uniforms are taking the right of the students to express themselves in a unique way; however, schools who don’t require uniforms are promoting students to express themselves by the way they dress and not by who they truly are and their personality, so this makes them feel pressured to dress a certain way to be able to be accepted. This then becomes a social issue that creates competency among them of who wears the best outfit. Some kids may feel superior to others because they might feel “richer” by the way they dress, and the “poor people” start to become excluded from the society. This issue affects parents as well as they don’t want their kids to feel excluded, and be bullied simple because of what they are wearing on the…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays