Why Is School Is Bad For Children By John Holt Essay

Improved Essays
There are many writings which can be taken two different ways. Either it can persuade the reader to his or her opinion or turn them away. The strategies used in an essay can have an effect on the reader. In the essay “School Is Bad For Children”, written by John Holt, a valid argument is made that school takes away almost every child’s individuality. The children apparently do not get the chance to express themselves or show their skills. Although the argument is acceptable and well written, there are a few flaws in the strategies Holt uses. In this particular essay, holt has over exaggeration, is bias against the schools, and his use of statistics is flawed. Holt over exaggerates on many of the issues he believes that school causes. Holt …show more content…
If a reader studied closely, they could tell the information was not properly viewed. One should do research before arguing against a major topic. In his essay, Holt claims,”You may say that school is a long lesson in how to turn yourself off, which may be one reason why so many young people, seeking the awareness of the world and responsiveness to it they had when they were little, think they can only find it in drugs” (74). This exaggeration is a little extreme. Trying to state that children turn to drugs because of their experience in school is a stretch. The National Institute On Drug Abuse proves that not all students turn to drugs because of school. There is an estimated seventy percent of students who have tried one form of alcohol or drug substance during high school, but this is not all from depression. Some is said to be from peer pressure, to fit in, their neighborhood, community, family, bullying, or just for fun. Drugs would only allow a student to have a one time emotional “high” experience. After a first experience the user will never have that same emotional state as before. Another misunderstood point Holt makes is,”Right answers are what the school wants” (73). This statement is directed toward the teaches more. Trying to claim that teachers are not smart enough and do not care about what the students is wrong. This statement proves that he did not do the research. Holt would have had to ask teachers if they just …show more content…
He says,” Let work together, help each other, learn from each other and each other’s mistakes” (75). He thinks that most schools make all the students do all of the work on their own. Stanford University performed studies on cooperative learning in a classroom environment. There are more and more teachers who are starting to perform this. Teachers have already applied this form of learning. Whether it be a small in class assignment, a week 's project, or a semester one. He can be agreed with on this part as well. Students should have group assignments to allow different habits of learning to be

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    How public education cripples our kids, and why” that in today’s society, schools have trained the students mind to become slaves of society and its demands by sharing his personal experiences, becoming consumers, and the solution to schooling. In the beginning the “Against School” Gatto describes his own personal experience in the school, which included boredom. He describes himself sitting in a classroom and never paying attention due to the information that was being displayed to him. He wanted to learn, but was not attentive.…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every student learns different ways to analyze and write literature based off what their teachers have imposed on them. In the passage, “From Silence to Words: Writing as Struggle” by Min-Zhan Lu the author informs the reader about her childhood growing up in China during the revolution. She expresses the multitude of problems that come up while she tries to balance learning English at home and Chinese in the classroom. Growing up with these two different lives, the author dignifies that learning two different methods of interpreting literature left her with conflicting perspectives. At school it was frowned upon to speak English, but at home her parents had the opposite attitude and prioritized the learning of English.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reflection Essay Taking English 105 has made me grow as a writer. I have learned an extensive amount of information about writing papers, critiquing papers, and editing papers. I have gained new writing skills on top improving my basic writing skills. Working with people and having my paper critiqued by classmates has also impacted my writing.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Lack of Emotion: The Persuasive Strategies of John Taylor Gatto Human beings are controlled by their emotions. How people make decisions and how people feel towards someone or something are based on emotion. This is the one device that author John Taylor Gatto fails to practice effectively in his essay, Against School. Gatto uses historical figures and quotes to persuade the audience that public schooling has corrupted the children that are put through its system.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Education has been shaped by a concern about economic readiness and competitiveness.” Mike Rose stated in his excerpt. Rose’s main idea about “Why School” is not only based on socio economics, standard of schooling, but also focused on how to give students, educators and parents a better system for education that’s beneficial for the whole society of the United States. As an example, Mike came from the working class who has achieved financial mobility through schooling, he knew in fact that education and economic well-being is closely linked. However, he emphasize education method such as standardized testing creates major stress to students and teachers, while it doesn’t necessarily aim on the purpose of public education.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since our first attempt at writing an essay in elementary to middle school, we are told the main components to writing an essay is the ‘beginning’, ‘middle’, and ‘end.’ All of which holds true today, but as we move from one grade to the next, the standards for a ‘good’ essay changes for the better. Rhetorical strategies, devices, and appeals also known as rhetoric, is what we learn in high school (Stotsky 10). The continuation of the expanding knowledge is what makes us alter our writing strategies, from the material taught to us in our adolescent years of elementary school and every year thereafter. It is in high school that we are taught to analyze and dissect the author, as well as the author’s work ceaselessly.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Knowing that illicit drugs are finding their ways into people’s homes and children’s school, “Illicit drug use by school-aged adolescents continues to be a concern for a number of groups including parents, educators, health…

    • 1535 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once in your lifetime, you may have questioned the purpose of everyday schooling; you may have even shown your hate for it. One person in particular took his hate for school to a new level. John Gatto was a school teacher, who absolutely hate the system. Against School is an essay he wrote expressing his hate for it. Against School shows what the school systems of late are about and how, as he says, it “cripples our kids” (Gatto).…

    • 1291 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What was once a grand and open space of ideas and endeavors now seems to be slowly grinding to a halt this space is the American university realm. What has slowly seeped in is the idea that student must be coddled and prevented from being presented with ideas that are quite frankly anti-anything they have perviously experienced, well at least this how Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt view the current trend of the American university system. In a article they penned for the “The Atlantic” they would write a article titled “The Coddling of The American Mind” released in september of 2015 they at the time would highlight all the issues they felt had arisen from the growing trend of being politically correct in order to stave off any student…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Foer's Argument Analysis

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the first essay, the student starts by writing a short summary as to what the article is about. The student then lists the two reasons as to why Foer’s argument is persuasive in a straight-to-the-point, clear, and organized manner. This intro was probably the strongest of the four. However, the second paragraph starts off by writing about how many Americans do not want to accept soccer as a pastime as many other countries have. There is little argument made in this paragraph as to how Foer is persuasive; here it is mostly summary of the article.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    James Wilson begins his argument by informing the reader of his position of power. President Nixon appointed him the chairman of the National Advisory Council for Drug Abuse Prevention in 1972. His primary role was to provide direction on the war on drugs, essentially focusing on the impermissibility of the legalization of cocaine and heroin. Wilson attacks the well-known economist Milton Friedman in his publication addressing the call for the legalization of heroin. Friedman made this claim based on a two-prong argument.…

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Writing a persuasive essay can be done in various ways. In Libby Hill’s essay “Calvin and Hobbes: The Voice of the Lonely Child”, she uses methods such as emotional appeal and testimony to connect to her readers. In Melissa Rubin’s essay, “Advertisements R Us”, she uses a very different approach as to how she persuades her reader. Rubin concentrates on logical appeal and historical facts to prove her claims. Both of these essays present reasonable arguments in different techniques as to what their claims are, how they display their evidence, and how they present the evidence to their readers, but Rubin’s essay is more persuasive because she presents a logical approach to argue her evidence.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nobody Left to Hate and Freedom Writers Cognitive psychology focuses on studying how the environment a person lives in affects his or her behavior. In the mid 1950s, researchers started looking into external factors rather than internal processes to explain why people act a certain way. Cognitive research revolutionized and become the dominant approach in psychology by the late 1970-1980s. Then, many people started creating strategies to influence people’s behavior to change.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his article, “Don’t Suspend Students Empathize”, David Kirp writes of the challenge educators face in regards to disciplining their students. Kirp, a college professor and senior fellow at the Learning Policy Institute, clearly holds education in high regard. The article broaches the topic of suspending students, and Kirp’s strong feelings towards the matter. He suggests instead of immediately suspending students, educators should empathize along with disciplining the students, doing so by teachers trying to view the world from an adolescent’s point of view. The article is published to inform parents and educators, is written using the persuasive techniques of ethos, pathos, and logos, in an easy to read manner and posing questions, creating…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysing Essay Deconstruction The quality, format, and use of communication conventions determines the effectiveness of a formal literary essay. In the essay Studying Literature in Grade 12, by Mrs. Phillips, the text demonstrates an example of a improper persuasive essay. This is shown through the content, incorrect language conventions, MLA citation and plagiarism, as well as the essay structure. Without these details one cannot achieve an effective essay.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays