Jewish People Dbq Analysis

Improved Essays
When speaking on anti-Semitism the great despair.com describes the treatment perfectly when they say “the secret to success is knowing who to blame for your failures”. Throughout history, Jewish people have been the scapegoats for unexplainable social acts, like the disappearance of children, and the entire Jewish population is scapegoated, instead of the group, or person thought to cause it. However, in some documents the Jews are scapegoated for unexplained social issues, while others depict Jews blamed deliberately for political reasons. These documents illustrate how the entire Jewish population has been blamed for unexplainable social problems, as well as the scapegoats for political issues, this scapegoating has stemmed to blaming for …show more content…
In document one created by Wolgermut, depicts members of the Jewish culture in formal religious wear torturing a boy. A Christian boy, St. Simon of Trent disappeared and was never found again during the Jewish holiday, Passover. The Christians of the town believed that the Jews took, and killed St. Simon to celebrate Passover. They did this to explain how a boy could disappear, without having the proof to explain what actually happened. In the 16th Century there was a myth that the Jews were taking Christian boys and using their blood to spawn the devil. Again, the Jews are scapegoated for the disappearance of children and shown as committing evil acts (Holy War). Document 4 depicts the Jewish man, Leon Trotsky, as a devil. This piece of propaganda was created by the White Army to attack The Red Army and the Jews. The White Army opposed Trotsky and the Red army in the Russian civil war. They created this piece to condemn the Red army by showing them as the cause to the brutal Russian Civil War. They blamed the Jewish people and Trotsky of causing the civil war by showing that the Jews and the Red army sided with the Chinese. Trotsky and the Jews were not the sole cause of the Russian Civil War, but the White army used them as scapegoats to explain why it occurred. These images show how Jewish people were scapegoated for unexplainable …show more content…
Anti-Semitism changed when Jews were not only blamed for unexplainable social acts, like the disappearance of Simon of Trent, they were now scapegoated for political acts for the sole reason that they are Jewish. Scapegoating the Jews for political reasons stems from the early examples of Jews being blamed. For example, in document one the Jews are blamed for the disappearance of a Christian boy. Document two also shows the Jews being scapegoated as Satanists and killing Christians. In the 19th century, the France government accused Dreyfus as guilty, just because he is Jewish. The man who accused Dreyfus knew he was innocent, but used Dreyfus as a cover up. It was believable because of the terrible acts that Jews have been blamed for in the past. Document four shows Leon Trotsky as the cause of the Russian Civil War. The White Army needs someone to blame to rally their supporters, so they blamed the Jews as the problem. The White Army knew that the Jews were not the sole cause of the Russian Civil War, but blamed the Jews anyways. Because the Jews were blamed for horrible social acts in the past, future leaders believed that the Jews could be the scapegoats for any problem. This is where the cases of Dreyfus and Leon Trotsky are shown. Past the 17th century, Jews were deliberately blamed for political acts, because society

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This event was the Russian revolution, an event in which thousands of Russians turned against and defied their government. Hitler believed that the Jews were the cause of this revolution and wanted them to pay. Reuth says that this was one of the most clear and present causes for Hitler’s hate for Jews at the time as he preferred the old way in which Russia was run and not the way that the revolters were advocating for (Adolf). As justification for this belief, Hitler quoted the Nobel-prize winning author Thomas Mann who also claimed that the Jews were responsible for the Russian Revolution. This tended to be an adequate appeal to an authority to get others to believe such claims.…

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Propaganda Poster Analysis

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the Germans who did not join the bandwagon of using Jews as scapegoats, this poster was supposed to convince them that Jews were evil and they should condone the violence Jews faced as well-reasoned and deserved. For the Jews who did nothing to deserve this hate, this poster was supposed to degrade them, make them feel weak and inferior. For the Europeans who did not know of the senseless dislike of Jewish heritage in Germany, this poster was supposed to tell them that this is what Jews represent: the devil and communism. A confusing aspect of this poster is the writing on it. The message is clear, “Satan is throwing off his mask!” but why is it not in German?…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hitler even convinced soldiers returning from the first world war, that the reason why Germany lost was because the Jews had stabbed them in the back. This was a very good way to get followers. The soldiers had risked their lives for their country, but the politicians, many of which were jewish, had stabbed…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Nazi regime used propaganda for targeting, influencing hatred of people of a certain culture or religion, and in hopes that it would help create their perfect society. Although the Jewish people were the common victim of the Holocaust genocide, “The Nazis did not just target the Jews”(“Defining the Enemy”). The Nazi propaganda also targeted gypsies, homosexuals, those who opposed Hitler 's rule, and those who did not fit into the perfect society the Nazis intended to create. These ‘inferior’ people were the mentally ill, people with physical disabilities, the deaf and the blind. The Nazis influenced hatred among the nations.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At this time Jews were frequently believed to have been the cause of social and economic problems in Germany, which was certainly the myth perpetuated by Hitler, therefore propaganda was implemented to ensure they were shunned by society. Importantly, those who sought to assist the Jews, who were involved in opposing Nazi policies were threatened and arrested. The Nazis did not want Jews to have rescuers, to have hope. Polarization was the way to succeed in this…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other Europeans and U.S. citizens believed the Jews had caused some of the economic problems, but they did not punish them in the way Hitler did. Hitler built on this small belief some had and turned many against the Jews, thus beginning the Holocaust. Throughout the Holocaust Hitler controlled the Jews socially, by fear, and cruelty. The first way Hitler controlled the Jews was social. Hitler created his army by turning many people against the Jews.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By means of the printing press and commissioned illustration, which in the period was varying graffiti and image based booklet propaganda, affluent individuals used imagery to put an improbable ideal in the commoner’s head of what a Jew embodied. In this way, Jews were politically and socially attacked by Christian officials or elite who could not openly show disdain towards Semites, but rather privately through this media form. Ultimately, hate was shown in production of artwork which portrayed the people as these aristocrats designated. These works were to allegedly punish Jews for their crimes against Christianity and force blame for fiscal and public failures on the lesser race. Jews were depicted as often conspiring with the anti-Christ, satanic, hooved and horned, and or malformed in ways such as verrucae, emaciated bodies with disproportioned features, or with tails.…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Passion Narrative Essay

    • 2543 Words
    • 11 Pages

    In the Synoptic Gospels in Matthew 's Infancy narrative, King Herod already had planned to kill Jesus, who was heard to be the “king of Jews.” The disapproval against Jesus begins early in the Gospels, mainly because he breaks the Sabbath laws. But, furthermore, the New Testament shows that religious leaders hated Jesus so much that they arrested Him, tried Him, and brought Him to Pilate to execute Him. Don Stewart in “Blue Letter Bible” talks about the many reasons why the religious leaders wanted Him dead. Jesus made many claims, deeds, threats to their religious system and way of life, hung out with low class people, and didn’t respect their religious ways and all of this filled the religious leaders with anger and fury. The claims that Jesus made proved that His authority was much greater than theirs and the religious leaders could not accept this.…

    • 2543 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Shylock feels hatred towards the Christians and wants revenge. Thus, discrimination could lead to conflict. This incident is similar to the Holocaust because of the dehumanization and discrimination of Jews. For example, the Nazi forced the Jews into extermination camps. This shows that Jews are mistreated multiple times.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His words appealed to those living in poverty and also the middle class. He wanted His racial policies included the removal of anyone not of Aryan blood, but his largest target was the Jews. “To them he ascribed the blame for all of Germany’s misfortunes, especially the loss of World War I” (Brockington). He successfully removed a large portion of the Jewish population through the brainwashing of his Nazi followers. However, he was unable to win World War II because of his failed attempt to take over Russia.…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays