Sally Satel Organ Selling

Improved Essays
Should organs be legal to sell around the world? Sally Satel, a practicing psychiatrist and kidney receiver, believes so. Satel states that there is a global organ shortage, and that has to do with kidney selling being illegal. In order to make organ selling legal, one would have to price a kidney at $50,000, and implement rigorous health screening. However, what Satel argues in “Why We Need a Market for Human Organs,” reprinted from The Wall Street Journal, is a high risk, high reward deal task in that if everything goes according to plan, everyone is has a new kidney (in theory). On the other hand, if one thing goes bad, then millions can be without a kidney, or worse die (again, all in theory). According to Satel, she claims that Gavin

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In this article, Susanne Lundin talks about the trading and trafficking of organs, and explains why people would want to buy them or sell them. Moreover, to make us understand better the situation the author tells us how the Ethernet is an active tool for trading organs, how the trading and trafficking works, and from where this is all coming from. First, Lundin tell us how people are trading organs on websites. Some people announce their organs on sale via service exchange websites, explaining why they need the money or why they want to trade their organs.…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people would claim that authorizing the sale of organs will take advantage of the poorer people in the third world countries, but that’s already happening. The organ seller does usually collect most of the money promised, but it doesn’t make a dent on their financial struggles. The threat of a $50,000 fine and five years in prison (Finkel 26), the up-to-date ban is not successful in averting illegal organ sales and operations. The underprivileged families don’t need more harsh and rigorous punishments, on the contrary they need just the opposite. If organ sales were made lawful, it could be controlled and supervised by the government.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Third world donors will do anything for money and it could help poverty. Mackay states in the living situations, people are willing to sell their kidneys for 1,000 dollars(159). Mackay’s article then springs into moral issues, she says not being able to sell a kidney violates the basic rights of a donor. Mackay brings up a counter claim from Pope John Paul II when he states that organ sales are morally wrong, she later refutes this argument(158). There is an advantage of government regulation.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You would think that compensating people for their organs would help the shortage and encourage capitalism. After all, United States is built on the free enterprise idea. Create and regulate a free market “in all aspects of organ and tissue procurement.” The free market will be able to match goods and services with those who need them. The free market would also be able to compensate the donors at fair market value and also keep their liberties intact.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joanna Mackay’s essay, Organ Sales Will Save Lives speaks for itself. It is what the world has been going through for more than two decades up to this point. The shortage within the supply of organs, in this case, Kidneys. Kidneys are at a high demand not just domestically but internationally and that is where the problem began to get uncontrollable. In the year 2000, 2,583 Americans died while waiting for a Kidney transplant.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Truth Behind Purchasing Illegal Organs for Transplant The US Department of Health and Human Services reports that an average of 22 people die every day waiting for a donated organ (HRSA). As a result, desperate and wealthy people are willing to pay thousands for black market organs. An illegally purchased kidney alone sells for between 30,000 and 100,000 in America (Interlandi, 2009). However, the donor is likely given less than a tenth of that money.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paper 4 "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" by Joanna MacKay explains the problem that thousands of people are complaining about. This problem is that thousands of people are begging to buy a kidney, but the government doesn't allow people to sell human organs. This outcome causes thousands of people to die each year, creating chaos around the world. Mackay and the other author’s want to convey their message to the government on why this catastrophic problem should be fixed. Since this essay is written on the subject of organ sales and Mackay’s essay was written back in 2004 some information may be dated, however not much has changed to fix this issue.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The black market has valued human organs at five thousand dollars each, so they report. They suggest sales of organ may be for itself. Some people who disobey the laws are increasing to a large scale number. On the other hand, there are those who believe that it might be better to legalize the sale of…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Sales Will Save Lives In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna Mackay, kidney failure is the main topic. In the thesis Mackay says “Government should not ban the sale of the human organs, they should regulate it.” It is supported by the evidence it will save lives. 350,000 people in America struggle with this situation each year.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mackay explains illegal organ sales and how it puts the donor, doctor, and patients in danger. Mackay goes into detail on why the donor goes through the dangers. MacKay whole argument to this article is that the government should not have this ordeal illegal. The government should make it legal so then it will have less risks for the donor, doctors, and patients.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Just because someone is on the waiting list, does not mean that they would have the money to buy an organ. The legalization of human organ sales would create an upper-class dominated organ trade, which would not benefit the poor at all. Legalization of organ sales in the United States would pose threats to the country’s morality in a sense that the poor could be mislead to use the organ market as a short term solution to long term monetary problems. Just as it is impossible to totally rule out immorality in an entire country, it would be impossible for the government to have entire control over a domestic market for organs. There is a trade market that operates all around the world, called the black market, which sells, trades, and deals in illegal means.…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You would do everything in your power to control it, but acts like the National Organ Transplantation are the ones prohibited the action of selling one’s own organs. When reading “Why legalizing organ sales will help save lives, end violence” by Anthony George, I strongly believe it shows that legalizing organ sales in America will not only allow for there to be more organ transplants throughout the years but as well as decrease the amount of violence and crime that is occurring in current trades. Why should we just sit around and watch millions of patients die, when we can help prevent it. Legalizing organ sales will dramatically decrease the number of patients on the waiting list. According to, George Mason University professor Alexander Tabarrok, “Millions of people suffer from kidney disease, but in 2007, there were about 64,606 kidney-transplant operations in the entire world.”…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This brings up the question, who is more desperate, the person needing the kidney or the person selling the kidney? The people who are selling their kidneys are selling them for less than a used car, this says something about how desperate they are for money. The hot spots for kidney trafficking are places that are very poor. “Kavre, a tiny district, close to Kathmandu, and what activists and authorities say is a ground zero for the black market organ trade in Nepal.” This is a where most people don’t make enough money for a meal in a day.…

    • 1685 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Selling Organs Essay

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Should selling organs be legal? Have you ever thought about the possibility of selling their own organs for transplantation? The question, of course is wild, but practice shows that from time to time, is in a difficult financial situation of the inhabitants of our country are beginning thinking outloud about using this opportunity to help others and make some money at the same time. About 75,000 Americans are on the waiting list for kidney transplants. But in the coming year, just 18,000 will get them.(1)…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Deep down inside all of us want to do well and have a better world. So many people are dying today because of the shortage of organ donors and the United States government is doing nothing about it but they are also making a profit from this. Human organ sales should not be legalized; people living in poverty can’t afford to pay for an organ, those who are willing to give an organ may not want to give one because they can sell them and get paid. Lastly, people think they can make a good profit from selling organs because of how their life is. Let’s think before we act and make this a better world for…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays