Other than the account of Madison, Jefferson’s “son” who may very well be lied too, there was not much evidence of either options. People had to rely on personal opinion which is not very reliable. That was until, DNA evidence was available. In 1998, a retired pathologist by the name of Eugene A. Foster along with a few of his colleagues tried to prove/disprove the 200 year debate about the origin of Sally’s children. The study concluded that Eston Hemings descendants did have a halotype not seen outside the Jefferson family but it still does not mean that he was fathered by Jefferson. It is possible that a descendent of Eston and a Jefferson did have children but that they considered that “unlikely because of the lack of historical evidence” according to the study. (SOURCE) The only concrete fact they discovered was that neither of the Carr brothers (Peter and Samuel) have fathered Eston. The Carr brothers were the first suspects when it was discovered that Jefferson may have had false children. For years the alternate idea on who fathered who always landed on the Carr brothers. Now that they are removed from the list of suspects who does the blame fall
Other than the account of Madison, Jefferson’s “son” who may very well be lied too, there was not much evidence of either options. People had to rely on personal opinion which is not very reliable. That was until, DNA evidence was available. In 1998, a retired pathologist by the name of Eugene A. Foster along with a few of his colleagues tried to prove/disprove the 200 year debate about the origin of Sally’s children. The study concluded that Eston Hemings descendants did have a halotype not seen outside the Jefferson family but it still does not mean that he was fathered by Jefferson. It is possible that a descendent of Eston and a Jefferson did have children but that they considered that “unlikely because of the lack of historical evidence” according to the study. (SOURCE) The only concrete fact they discovered was that neither of the Carr brothers (Peter and Samuel) have fathered Eston. The Carr brothers were the first suspects when it was discovered that Jefferson may have had false children. For years the alternate idea on who fathered who always landed on the Carr brothers. Now that they are removed from the list of suspects who does the blame fall