Theories Of Functionalism

Superior Essays
Functionalism is one of the most recent theories of mind, and as such, it has been a target of much criticism. While it is certain that functionalism is a theory that contains a number of flaws as a result of its contemporary nature, it is apparent that a lot of the criticisms it has received are misguided.
The modern theory of functionalism proposes that mental states of humans should be identified by the function that those mental states sever rather than the material composition. To demonstrate functionalism, pain is often used as an example. Suppose that pain is a mental state associated with bodily injury. If functionalism were true, then a creature with a completely different physical constitution could be in pain assuming it possessed
…show more content…
The two most commonly cited criticisms of the turing test are: The Chinese Room criticism and the Blockhead criticism.
2
The Chinese Room argument closely relates to the Turing test. Published by John Searle in 1932, the thought experience describes a situation where
Searle is locked in a room and is then passed Chinese characters under the door. Searle does not understand any Chinese, but by manipulating symbols and numerals and matching them with the symbols and numerals he has in the room, Searle is capable of correctly responding to any query received from the outside. The conclusion that is meant to be constructed from this argumentisthattheTuringTestisinadequatetodeterminewhetherasystem is intelligent, because the machine (or Searle himself in the Chinese Room example) does not possess the knowledge of what those symbols actually mean. The Chinese room argument has gained an incredible amount of traction in the philisopher community, and as such it has faced numerous objections. “The Systems Reply” is perhaps one of the strongest of these objections. What that reply suggests is that while it is correct that the
…show more content…
However, another thing that becomes apparent is that being able to pass it does not in any way imply intelligence.
Many arguments against functionalism do not distinguish functionalism from computationalism. While it is not wrong to assume that functionalism and computationalism are very closely related, there are some signifact dif- ferences between the two that are seldom mentioned when discussing either one of the disciplines. Functionalism describes the mind as a collection of mental states that are functionally equivalent to the system found in the
6
human brain. Computationalism is a view that the functional organization of the brain (and all the systems that are its functional equivalents) is compu- tational. A computational system implies that the mind works in a similar way current sofware does, with explict step-by-step procedures for solving tasks.[ 8 ] This is the view that is often associated with the “mind as software” analogy.[ 9 ] A lot of the criticisms that are commonly used against function- alism are, in fact, better suited for critcizing the computational theory of mind. Functionalism may be a theory that has it flaws, but the Turing Test should stop being used as a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Functionalists use their own terminology for instance; functional and dysfunctional are terms used to describe the effects of basic principles in society.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since 1990's multitasking has turned into a piece of the majority of our lives. Multitasking puts us under a great deal of stress and makes us less productive. It is a fantasy that multitasking encourages us do diverse things at the same time where in reality we are giving up center. Contingent upon what we do, on the less intellectual errands multitasking can make us more imaginative by using distinctive psychological capacities. We can't separate our consideration regarding diverse assignments we can simply move it forward and backward between undertakings.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shortly after the 2016 election, President Trump signed an executive order on January 27 suspending refugee admissions from seven countries for 90 days. These countries included Iran, Iraq (which was later removed momentarily), Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen. Immediately following the executive order, many district courts appealed the order for they felt it was unconstitutional. States have argued that the executive order has violated, The Immigration and Neutrality Acts and was motivated by a discriminatory animus (McCarthy). Not only has the order produced many appeals, it has also created a large amount of protests outside airports and major cities including the Capital (Newman).…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kayla Steinmetz Dr. Lalita Hogan English 112 25 September 2017 Focusing on Distractions Everyday our brains are constantly processing a massive amount of information that is constantly being attained through various technological platforms. With this abundant flow of information, the question of just how productive and how much of this information is actually being processed beneficially is posed. While more ways to obtain information may mean the attainment of more knowledge, it also poses the threat of more ways to distract ourselves. In Sam Anderson’s article “In Defense of Distraction”, Anderson explores the various challenges placed on our brains daily to not to succumb to the various distractions that reduce productivity. He is able to…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A. Exploring the Unconscious i. Freud used free association, in which he told the patient to relax and say whatever came to mind. ii. Called his treatment techniques psychoanalysis iii. Beneath our awareness is the larger unconscious mind with its thoughts, wishes, feelings, and memories. 1.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Third Wave: 1915-1960 The Black Working Class Meets the Aristocracy As the century came to a close, the old black elite was losing their position due to the rapid economic and social changes in America. A newly developing black middle class that excelled based on economic and educational achievement began integrating with the previous black upper class. This new group still consisted of blacks that worked as businessmen, professionals and in white-collar jobs from the previous elite, however with the looming anger over emancipation for blacks, many whites consistently shut blacks out of jobs. They preferred to be served by the new generation of white workers as well as the European immigrants…

    • 1087 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    RHETORICAL ANALYSIS- “IS GOOGLE MAKING US STUDPID” The world of internet has made the flow of information very easy and the entire globe is just a click away from you. But there has started surfacing a school of thoughts which believes that availability of vast sea of information on the internet using search engines like GOOGLE is also making people foolish. Nicholas Carr, the writer of this article belongs to same school of thoughts. His belief is that excessive use of GOOGLE is replacing our power of contemplation with lethargic approach of just achieving efficiency and saving the time.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Functionalism is the first macro perspective that as developed as a systematic method of analysis by Bronislaw Malinowski and A.R. Radcliffe-Brown. A principle approach was any social pattern or institute that does not serve a function will cease to exist and any pattern found among people is believed to have innate human needs. (Westphal & Levenson, 1993, pp.44) Malinowski believed that all human needs were satisfied by a way that does not cause social chaos, such as sex drive, hunger, and the need to relieve oneself that satisfied in ways controlled by society. As explained in the textbook a need requires a social pattern or institute that has consequences that satisfy the need.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Functionalism attempts to bring everyone together and create equality and that is also the purpose of…

    • 2014 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Question 1 – Describe the theory the researchers explore. What are the key constructs in the theory? How are they related? Identify which ones are cause, effect, mediating, or moderating constructs. How are the constructs operationalized?…

    • 1069 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Author believes in the power of failing students if they don’t master a skill. “Educational repair shops” refers to the adult literacy programs. Stating that one’s education is broken and needs to be tweaked or repaired. The author is somewhat mocking the situation by revealing the fact that it even has to exist. These adult literacy programs are the technicians of education.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Computers and Craniums: A Continuing Cycle of Connections The enigma of the human mind is a puzzle that has fascinated many great scientists. From the earliest musings of the ancient philosophers to the advanced neuroscience research going on today, many intelligent people have worked to understand what is going on in our own heads. In an interesting phenomenon, our understanding of the mind is intimately linked to the technology that is used to study it, and the new findings that arise feed directly back into the development of new tools. As scientific equipment has become capable of better observing the brain and human behavior, the mind has come to be understood more as an incredibly complex machine than as an incomprehensible mass residing…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans are peculiar creatures. We are born with personalities and predispositions that make us “who we are”. That determine how we approach the world. But so much of our behaviors are learned, acquired and developed. The question is “how”?…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Studying the complex nature of globalisation through the lens of paradigms may, to some, seem outdated. However, but by analysing globalisation this way, we see underlying structures that link seemingly unrelated aspects, thus allowing for a more robust understanding of the wider globalisation phenomena. The nature of these underlying structures is a point of ongoing contention for sociologists. Functionalists argue that although society is made up of individual actors making decisions for themselves, the move towards globalisation is society as a whole coming to a natural equilibrium, with mutual benefits for everyone. Conversely, conflict theorists see globalisation more sceptically, pointing to the exploitative nature of modern globalisation…

    • 1615 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is useful because the human mind and computers have some similarities: they both have inputs, outputs, memory stores and a limited capability for how much information they can process at any one time. A computer’s behaviour is determined by the information it is given and the way it’s been programmed, so a person’s behaviour is also determined by a person’s environment (how they were brought up ); how they have learned to process information and the capacities for information processing innate in the kind of brain the individual has. The cognitive approach is a reductionist as it reduces the functions of humans to that of a machine disregarding emotions and social influence. Unlike the computer which needs to be updated from time to time, people can learn, unlearn and relearn. It also does not take into account genetic factors even though it studies the effects of brain injury and neurological illnesses.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays