The Rubber Room Analysis

Great Essays
Within the second quarter of the semester we have worked continuously with three main authors. Steven Brill did an amazing job with the production of his article “The Rubber Room”. The article was published by The New Yorker and was electronically available on August 31, 2009. When this work came out Steven Brill raised a lot of eyebrows. He gave people insight as to what they education system really does and how all its branches work. We then moved on to analyzing and observing the works of Dana Goldstein. She produced and article “Can Teacher Alone Overcome Poverty? Steven Brill Thinks So”. This work was published by The Nation website and helps us to get a clear picture of her argument against Steven brills “The Rubber Room”. Steven brill …show more content…
If a child lives in poverty they can be neglected of the right essentials to life. If a child’s parents are on a fixed income it is less likely for a child to be place in a well-educated facility. Goldstein ranks poverty high on her list because if a child’s family is poor this will bring about more consequences such as, malnutrition and not being able to attend a higher educated school system. With this being said she states the claim that “poverty exerts a crushing influence over children’s lives”. This is true because if a child sees their parents struggling finically they will believe that there is no way out for them and that going to school would not matter if their parents are continuing to struggle. Davis Guggenheim might challenge this claim because he thinks those teachers are a leading cause in the problem the school face. He thinks that we need better staff in facility to allow children to be properly educated. Guggenheim commonly referees back to the ideas that teachers need to be evaluated and if they do not pass the evaluation that they should be fired on the spot. Guggenheim states that “the difference between good and bad teachers is the ability to raise the grades of students.” This statement can be true in some case but not all. Once in a while, you come across excellent teachers that no matter what the circumstances are they are able to communicated and get through to the student. But …show more content…
If a child has a strong support system it is likely for him or her to exceed great expectations. Dana Goldstein would agree with this claim because she thinks that counseling is strong aspect in child’s education. Counseling will allow kids to become aware of their problem and seek a support group for help. I firmly believe that if you have a strong relationship with your family you will be able to overcome any challenged that one maybe face in life when pursuing an education. Dana claims that “counseling (how we prepare young people, professionally and socially, for adult life”. She thinks that once we cover the three c’s method that it will allow for people to reform education. Counseling goes way beyond the wall in which the talking stage occurs. When you are counseling someone you in return offer problem solving strategies, help and provide assistance and other tactics in which a person can use to overcome obstacles. This is beneficial to s student because all throughout your academic career you are faced with obstacles that you need to overcome and you can’t always overcome then alone. Steven brill would argue that it is the child will to do well, not the surrounding environment he or she has. In the article “Waiting for a School Miracle”, Diane Ravitch claims that “to prove that poverty does not matter political leader points to school that have

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Parental involvement in schools is not always an easy task yet, it is very beneficial for everyone involved in a child’s educational development. Students must see that parents have an invested interest in what transpires at school. When parents are involved at schools they become more aware of how to best help their child at home. In addition, “students are more inherently interested in learning, and they experience higher perceived competence” (Gonzalez,-DeHass, Willems and Holbein, 2005, p. 117). Parents and teachers must create a positive partnership or teamwork to show the student the importance of learning in and outside of school.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many different things can contribute child’s academic and physical behaviors. Although, a student may be academically strong with a stable home, teachers matters most. It is clear that most teachers want to make some type of positive impact in a student’s life. It is important that teachers care for their students dearly. They want to see them succeed and are willing to help them with their goals in life.…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the flip side this could expose a lot of the terrible teachers and show schools what type of people they should and should not hire. Just because you have a degree in education does not necessarily mean you are cut out to be a good teacher. Another reason teachers should get evaluated is because even though they teach well, they can not control their students in the class. Some students may have behavior problems but their education is important. I feel as though that it is up to the teacher to find a teaching style that grasps some of the ill mannered children’s attention so they will not be as prone to act up.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The thing is students can’t just pick these up; they must be taught. The big problem is the teachers themselves must be held accountable for this, and are hardly held so. So as long as America keeps raising the standards trying to “up the annie” on education, students will continue to learn just to forget. Student must want the ability to knowledge and this is hardly ever the case because, they just don’t care. They’ve been judged so much that when they get to high school, it’s expected of them to be stereotyped into classifications that seem forever bound to them.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students are in constant need of validation. Validation of their rankings in class, their accompanying grades in addition to an acceptance into a post-secondary education. Students need this justification because their grades are solid proof of their success, while learning is not tangible and cannot be measured. “When "get results now" prevails over "achieve excellence," it 's very tempting to renounce our integrity”, says local New York journalist Steve Byrd. The reasoning behind this grade based society is partly because learning and knowledge cannot be used as evidence, but results and grading can.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Academics and getting a proper education are far more important than participating in any sport. The reason why is because, if a student’s grades are not up to par, it does not matter how good of an athlete they are, the college of their dreams could turn them down. Even if students receive scholarship opportunity, they still have to meet grade point average requirements. Also, your grades and school performance follows you all through your life, even as an adult. If your GPA is low, then most likely you will have a hard time finding a good job as an adult.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The flip side of this situation is that a student from the low-income area may be more encouraged to find work and help supplement the family’s income and help provide necessities. Students cannot perform well in an environment where teachers expect them to complete coursework outside of school, but are also expected by their guardians to be employed outside of school. This system, Common Core, would force these students to become overworked and overwhelmed. It is not capable of catering to low-income schools, and would further increase the achievement…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Title “Don 't try to fix the students, fix ourselves first. The good teacher makes the poor student good and the good student superior. When our students fail, we, as teachers, too, have failed.” ~Marva Collins There will always be a student that will be struggling and as a teacher you should never give up on the student and help them succeed. In becoming a teacher, I will need a certain amount of education, understand what my responsibilities and requirements will be ,and make sure the job fits in with my future lifestyle. When going into any career, it would be helpful to know the requirements needed for the career.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Factors

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, there are factors that they cannot control such as the number and kinds of learners they may have in the classroom, the class size, time spent with each child, and the availability of equipment. With all of these factors weighing on the teachers mind it is no wonder that when looking at the survey discussed in class, it was found that these issues do not leave the teacher’s mind. We always want the best for our student so we will continually worry as to whether or not they are receiving the best education possible. Our personalities alone are not enough to carry the weight of a poor school. We must combine it with our knowledge of the content and our experience level to create a favorable outcome for the…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Why School Is Important

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This will also distract their focus. This means that the school’s leaders need to step up and take care of the problem when they have the chance. Also, fair assessment is necessary. If a student is not being evaluated on the same level as the others in your class, then they are less likely to try. They will give up because they know that they will never get as good of a grade as somebody else.…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays