Restorative Justice System Analysis

Improved Essays
Jackson and Bonacker (2006) note the evolving use of restorative justice in victim services. "The goal of restorative justice is to create conditions whereby the victim or representatives can dialogue with offenders in order to repair the harm or resolve the conflict" (Jackson and Bonacker, 2006, p. 302). The most effective ways to implement this, as explained by Jackson and Bonacker (2006), are through victim impact statements, victim impact panels, and victim impact training. The level of involvement by probation officers is rapidly progressing as this new role combines offender supervision with restorative justice. Jackson and Bonacker (2006) suggest the importance of restorative justice when discussing victim services because it recognizes …show more content…
Providing victim support and services are both major aspects of a probation officers job. Bradford (2011) describes the role of victim support as "reducing the distress, poverty and disadvantageous effects on victims and witnesses of crime and other forms of harmful behavior"(p. 347). This method can be looked at through the procedural justice model. The procedural justice model is used to gather an understanding of the public’s opinion and ensure that procedural fairness is consistently being conducted. Bradford (2011) notes that in a successful procedural justice system, there are 4 crucial concepts. These concepts are, victims having a voice in interactions, neutrality by authority, treatment with respect and dignity, and trust. Bradford recognizes the importance of victim services when predicting satisfaction with the criminal justice system and indicates that contact with victims, along with allowing them to have a voice in the process, is a good way to make certain their needs are being properly addressed. Bradford's findings conclude that confidence in the effectiveness of the criminal justice system, available victim services, and overall fairness are all necessary factors in providing the victim with the necessary information and services they …show more content…
Understanding the limits as a probation officer and being able to effectively establish boundaries with the victim early on can prevent future dissatisfaction (Enterkin & Crawford, 2000). Victims want good quality and timely information regarding the offender, court dates, and sentencing. Enterkin and Crawford indicate that relevant dates, contextual information, and explanations of the criminal justice system are all appropriate to share with the victim. On the contrary, detailed information about the offender’s location, as well as treatment programs should be kept private.
"Whether probation services establish victim contact work within a discrete unit, or through another mechanism, there is a pressing need to ensure that the service, as a whole, is appropriately guided through clear policy delineation, training, and documentation" (Enterkin & Crawford, 2000,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    117). In the following essay, in addition to further discussing the characteristics of successful probation supervision, I will discuss motivational interviewing (MI) as an evidence-based approach to supervision, and its effectiveness. By implementing motivational interviewing into their practices of supervision, probation officers enable themselves to build interpersonal connections between themselves and probationers, and properly consider the specific needs and risk posed by probationers through conversation in a way that demonstrate both control (through change) and assistance (through assessment), thus satisfying the three characteristics of successful probation supervision. In successful probation supervision, a probation officer will ensure the establishment and maintenance of rapport. Rapport encourages the offenders (probationers) to open up to the officer, which enhances the officers capacity to effectively monitor the compliance of probation conditions and intervene on a continues basis to prevent the escalation of problems (Skeem & Manchak, 2008, p. 224).…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Klockars’ typology work styles describe the personalities of officers. These work styles include law enforcers, time-servers, therapeutic agents, and synthetic officers. Klockars’ law enforcers stress the legal aspects of their jobs. Time-servers do their jobs but in the fastest way possible and don’t strive to excel in their job. Therapeutic agent is the work style that officers provide treatment to their offender.…

    • 165 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Examines the offender’s background to provide the sentencing judge with facts needed to make an informed sentencing decision. It also involves a dispute-settlement process during which the probation officer works with the defendant and the victim to resolve the complaint before sentencing (Schmalleger, 2015). In the Coatesville Fire Case, the offenders the prosecuting attorney would look at the evidence, testimony of eyewitnesses, and the confessions of the suspects to provide the sentencing judge with the facts to decide on the case. Determines whether the case should be referred for formal court proceedings or held open for adjustment services (Schmalleger, 2015).…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Christine’s perceptions of how others involved in the criminal justice system that have contact and work to assist victims is improving. Christine said, “First responders, such as police officers can set the whole tone”. To elaborate, she explains the improvements such as the police displaying a compassionate response, and professionally building a case by properly handling evidence. Christine expressly said in her own words, “I see judges who manage the courtroom without making the victim feel like her or she is the one on trial; who follow the law, even if the decisions are not what I would want.” “If I know they are following the law, I can help the victim understand”.…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Global Issues: Presentence Reports and Intermediate Sanctions Review of Subject Probation officers have an important role in the criminal justice system, and their supervision and investigation skills contribute greatly to the sentencing phase of an offender. One of the many tasks of a probation officer is to generate detailed presentence investigations (PSIs). In order to have a comprehensive presentence report, a probation officer must interview the offender, evaluate the offender’s criminal history along with facts of the crime he or she has committed (Clear et al., 2013). A presentence report will help a sentencing judge decide what type of punishment is appropriate for the crime that an offender has committed. There will be situations…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, Jacquie’s mother was murdered by first time offenders who were convicted and imprisoned. However, Jacquie was emotionally devastated due to continuous court proceedings in which she had to express her victim impact statements. The restorative justice model incorporates personal values, so it was a valuable opportunity for the offenders and Jacquie to gain insight regarding the reasons for the murder and the sharing of compassion and emotions that was not possible in the state-based justice process. According to Jacquie, the experience with the restorative justice model was accommodating because it allowed the offenders to show empathy, mutual understanding, and accountability for the crimes that they have committed. Jacquie was extremely fearful and suffered from anxiety before engaging in a collaborative interaction with one of the offenders, but she noticed that the offender demonstrated great remorse and shame for his horrendous involvement.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consider a probation officer contemplating a decision to seek revocation of a client's probation. What theories might underlie such a decision? What are the goals? What kinds of information should the officer seek? What kinds of feedback might the probation officer want to influence later decisions?…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Probation Officers Goals

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The most challenging issues faced in the probation industry are dealing with the parolees not willing to help themselves into a better rehabilitative state. Probation officers can help probationers better their lives by following mandatory protocols depending on their charges such as goals of probation, risk and needs assessments, programs and approaches and cognitive-behavioral therapies. Probation officers goal is to determine what they are attempting to achieve through supervision. Because there are many programs and conditions that influence if the individual is going to be successful being on probation, leading to success is a complicated task and very challenging.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zehr worked with the residents in “victim-offender reconciliation” after the home burnt down (6). Zehr facilitated meetings between offenders and victims, along with the support networks of each and impacted community members. This aspect remains in restorative justice approaches today. Restorative…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prison Reform Case Study

    • 2161 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Prison Reform: Avoid using Excessive Force and Establish Resources for Ex-offenders There are many problems with the United States criminal justice system. People of color are arrested more frequently than any other race. The majority of people of color that are arrested are poor. The poor people can not afford a paid attorney and end up with free legal aid attorneys.…

    • 2161 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Diversion and Probation Diversion programs are available to certain defendants who are classified as unable to comprehend the punitive system. This can be the mentally ill, or someone who would benefit from treatment other than imprisonment. According to Schmalleger and Ortiz Smykla (2015), Diversion is a program created where the accused chooses to participate by undergoing treatment, such as drug or alcohol, mental health services, employment counseling, and education and training.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This policy proposal includes a brief introduction of restorative justice particularly focuses on youth justice conferencing. This paper will explain the penoligical principles underlying in restoration, and discuss the strength and weakness of youth justice conferencing. Finally, this paper will conclude with recommendation for future practice. Restorative justice is a framework that recognises accountability and the need to repair harm caused to victims and communities impacted by crime. It is a reform that seeks to engage all parties such as (victims, offenders, both their families or support persons, police officer and the facilitator) comes together to discuss the offence, its impact and what should be done to repair the harm, and resolve…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many parts of the criminal justice system have been set up to seek justice for families and victims whom have been negatively impacted by crime. The criminal justice system seeks to find and fairly punish criminals for the crimes that they have committed. The system however, while having many good factors, also has some negative ones. There are problems within the police force, the court system, prison and jail, and the rehabilitation process. Movies and television shows can lead to people having a misconception of the truth of the criminal justice system.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Restorative Justice Case Study

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 18 Works Cited

    By restorative justice having such a profound impact on the way in which crime and justice is viewed, this could transform public debate completely. People will be more inclined to adopt a more restorative approach to punishment as opposed to a retributive approach. There have been many proven benefits that come with the restorative approach, as highlighted in a Home Office report by Marshall (1999). It was stated that the majority of victims offered the chance of meeting their offender would like to do so and that having been given that opportunity, the great majority looked back on the experience as well worthwhile. Also stated in the report was that research carried out by Umbreit & Coates (1992), Umbreit (1994) and Umbreit et al (1997) showed that there were extremely high levels of victim satisfaction with mediation.…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 18 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction Criminal justice is an important aspect in our society, which it functions to organize the public and enforce justice. Many criminal professionals have studied to identify the best possible criminal justice approach to handle criminal problems we face. As a result, professionals have developed the restorative justice as a new alternative for the retributive justice where it primary focuses on executing the punishments. Restorative justice has gained popularity over the past decades in our society that many criminal related institutions have developed programs that are based on the restorative justice framework. CoSA, or also known as Circles of Support and Accountability is an good example of the community program that is based on the concept of the restorative justice to resolve the problem arises by the crime committed and promote the peaceful criminal justice.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays