Comparing Dostoevsky's In Crime And Punishment

Improved Essays
Mind Games What separates human beings from most of the living world is the ability to be free thinking individuals, to which one can communicate and connect their thoughts to the everyday world. Even though humans may take this gift for granted, it is only when the ability begins to diminish that one seems to understand how crucial it is really is to everyday life. Although, even while losing this gift, the individual may not even know it, for the reality one creates is only visible to that one person, and in turn, that person usually does not realize that this perspective is not what others perceive. It is this phenomenon precisely which grants the full understanding of what the mind, and its established boundaries of understanding, is …show more content…
Petersburg, failing to realize that what he perceives as rational thoughts and ideas are not as concrete as he believes. Throughout the story, Raskonlnikov’s mind proves to hold him back from acting under his own free will, by constantly contradicting himself and applying incorrect insinuations to the everyday world. In one instance, Rodya strolls down the street, muttering to himself, “Am I capable of that? Is that serious? It is not serious at all. It’s simply a fantasy to amuse myself; a plaything! Yes, maybe it is a plaything.”(2) At this point in the story, Raskolnikov reveals a glimpse of how his mind deciphers his dreams and current situations into a blur of tangled thoughts. At one point, the main character receives less than preferred when pawning his father’s silver watch, yet proceeds to give the funds away to a local drunk’s family. Even afterwards as Raskolnikov is leaving the house he admits, “What a stupid thing I’ve done, they have Sonia [their prostitute daughter] and I want it myself.”(23). In this passage, it seems strange that Raskolnikov could be so knowingly destitute that he needs to pawn what items he has left to his name, yet instantly gives away his money only to regret it soon thereafter. At this moment, even he is unaware of the irrational confusion that his mind has set upon him and thus carries about his day as if it were any …show more content…
It is in his case that one can begin to understand the dynamics of a truly free thinking and intellectual being. Nozick’s capability not only seems to complete his perception of the functional world, but also allows him to analyze and discern pertinent information as beneficial, or counterproductive to future progress. In the opening pages of the novel, Nozick states, “the fundamental question of political philosophy, one the precedes questions about how the state should be organized, is whether there should be any state at all. Why not have anarchy? … Those who consider anarchism as not an unattractive doctrine will think it possible that political philosophy ends here as well. Others impatiently will await what is to comes afterwards.”(4) The freedom Nozick implements in his critical thinking clearly shows his ability to think outside the box, and consider multiple perspectives in order to accurately come to a suitable conclusion. Now, that conclusion may not be widely accepted by the masses, but he does make it known that his reasoning is not exactly in line with modern culture and that it is a “justification for resuscitating this

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For example Jane possibly getting molested by her stepfather is one reason boundaries might be very important to holden. Holden reveals himself completely to the reader in this chapter. He is horrified when sunny stands up and pulls her dress over her head. “Sexy was about the last thing I was feeling. I felt much more depressed than sexy.” He keeps trying to establish a relationship with this prostitute who just wants to make money off of him.…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For example, her father told her that child-welfare would take her away and break the family apart; this caused Jeannette to say “I had never hated anyone more than I hated that child-welfare man” (194). Although Jeannette respects and trusts her father at the beginning of this novel, as time progress she begins to lose faith in him. This can be seen when Rex steals her travel fund money, manipulates her to buy cigarettes, and allows a guy to grope her. When Jeannette is helping her father scam a man for money, her father tells her to go upstairs with the man into his apartment room. As Jeannette escapes from the apartment and goes to her father’s car she states “I was so angry at Dad I couldn’t bear the idea of him rescuing me… I felt like throwing my money at him” (213).…

    • 2193 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Torchy’s lust for money and sex deprives him from making a moral judgment. When his reversal of fortune takes place, fate turns against him and take away the fortune that he attained earlier in gambling. In the end, the catharsis show how he gains an insight from realizing his tragic flaw when he decides to visit his grandfather again. It is imperative to understand that tragedy is powerful because it allows humans to approach their shortcomings with caution and…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Furthermore, Lennie has to run off as a result of his childlike state of mind and Curley's wife’s conniving attitude which prompts him to accidentally kill her. This proves how Lennie's mental handicaps lead directly to him shying away from his American Dream as he abandons his plan made with Candy to our run his trouble caused by his mental retardation. Some stories end with a happy ending, however John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men is not one of those stories. Steinbeck demonstrates how unfair the world can truly be as seen with nice Lennie Smalls. He works hours on end and supplies companionship to George, yet in the end George is forced to kill Lennie as a result of his childlike mentality and the encounter with the whore of Curley's wife.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mama mentions in the story that he is a disgrace to his father. Meaning he is making him look bad and the footsteps walter was suppose to keep walking stopped. He had many careless situations like selling the house and having to get it back, Not convincing his wife at first to keep the baby , and with travis not being real not talking with his wife first before giving him money and other things. Ruth said on pg.88 “ ‘ cause after all that liquor you come home with you ought to have something hot in your stomach.” For beneatha she had to find the fake her in order to commit to anything. The girl was a miser made the people around her miserable “ misery loves company “ .…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Daisy’s voice is a motif for the deceptive dream of wealth, which – being life’s great lie – proves both cruelly elusive and casually destructive. He is not alone in this emotional upheaval. Nick suddenly finds his love snuffed out when he comes to the realization that wealth is, like Jordan, “a good illustration” (p. 168), leaving him confused, angry and bereft. Myrtle’s husband hounds Tom about selling his car, desiring this symbol of wealth and escape – from both poverty and his grey existence – which for him holds the answer to fixing his marriage, by taking his wife away. Daisy, having given up waiting for Gatsby years ago in favour of the easy life Tom’s wealth promised, is also upset about Tom’s indiscretions.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She states that if one is to properly persuade anyone, they must do so from a close proximity to their opposition’s beliefs. A small correction to one belief set is still supported by accepting truth, whereas a major paradigm shift is less likely to hold up in from the opposition’s standpoint. This seems to be a pretty basic debate strategy, but suggests a fundamental flaw in the current argumentative tactics. It seems easy to pick a topic wildly different from your own, and shoot holes in it from your perspective, but those on the other side may not accept the arguments that do so, and may fire back in kind, leaving both parties going nowhere, but when one approaches from the same viewpoint, and carefully audits a path, suggesting small adjustments, it is a lot easier to come to a consensus. Here is the major problem with the evolutionary debunkers.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His plan was for them to live off her dead husbands riches, and that cannot happen with another man in the pictures. In sabers mind by not following his plan once again, that she has betrayed him. ‘So Saber goes to Karimas mothers house not worried that the police may be following him. He confronts her about it, she denies saying “you’re an idoit. I risked my life because I love you”.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gatsby knows Daisy married Tom just for his money and thinks that she never truly loved him and tries to get Daisy to admit it. When Daisy will not admit it, Gatsby decides to take matters into his own hands. “She never loved you, do you hear?... She only married you because I was poor and she was tired of waiting for me...”(Fitzgerald 131). Myrtle and Daisy do not care about their morals; they just need to get what they want.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Iago uses Emilia to steal the handkerchief so he can plant it in Cassio 's room. Emilia admits to Desdemona, "But I do think it is their husbands ' faults If wives do fall. Say that they slack their duties And poor our treasures into foreign laps" (832). With this line she explains how she would never cheat on her husband but if she would it would be because he is spending his has forced her to seek for love in other places because has already fallen out of love with her. Emilia is jealous of all the Iago 's attention he is putting into trying to ruin Othello 's marriage and Cassio 's job.…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays