Rocket Man Knows Better By Uri Friedman Analysis

Improved Essays
Compare and Contrast Essay There is a possibility of nuclear war between America and North Korea. Uri Friedman and Blaine Harden both wrote articles on this subject. Uri Friedman wrote the article “How to Tell If North Korea and America Are Actually Headed to War”, and Blaine Harden wrote the article “Rocket Man Knows Better”, a similarity between the articles is that America and North Korea will not go to war, a difference is that Friedman focuses more on the present and Harden focuses on the past, another similarity is that they both give reasons why the two countries have not gone to war, where Friedman focuses on the future, Harden focuses on the past. A similarity between Friedman and Hardens articles is that they both believe America …show more content…
Friedman talks about how the choices the two leaders make could lead to an accidental war. The egos of the two leaders can have a negative impact on this situation. Friedman states in his article that “while words matter, they aren’t all that matter”.(Friedman pp.2)The actions of the two governments could be a good indicator of what could happen next. He gives a better view point on this situation than Harden does. Harden mainly focuses mainly on North Koreas past and the Kim family decisions. Harden talks more about the Korean War and the consequences of that than he does about the situation that is going on now. He believes that “the United States has largely forgotten the lessons of the Korean War,”.(Harden pp.2) He uses the Korean War to explain why Kim will not use his nuclear weapons. He has learned from his Father and his Grandfathers mistake. Harden believes that if North Korea does go to war with America he will have no backing from other countries. Harden states that “America should be prepared for an extended cold war with North Korea.” (Harden pp. …show more content…
Friedman gives multiple indicators as to why America and North Korea have not gone to war. An example he gives is that the U.S would be evacuating America civilians out of South Korea. (Friedman pp.3) He also states that America would be mobilizing troops. Which neither of these indicators has happened. Friedman also gives indicators that North Korea is not preparing for war either. An example of this is that Korea has not mobilized their troops or Navy either. He states that “ in order to keep accidental war from happening Korean soldiers are to report up the chain of command”.(Friedman pp. 4) He believes that if Trump keeps threatening North Korea like he has he will prevent an “accidental war”. Harden also gives reasons why America and North Korea have not gone to war. One of these reasons is the Kim family past experience with conflict. Harden believes that Kim “knows better” than to start war with America.(Harden pp.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    I don’t think that publishing the document would undermine the ongoing operations and endanger lives. Therefore, I recommend publishing “A Growing Threat” document. • A Regime Weakened: SUPPRESS THE DOCUMENT My recommendation for dealing with “A Regime Weakened” document is to suppress the document. The government told us not to print the story on regime tensions, lest that lead to a purge in North Korea that could eliminate key sources of information, or incite regional instability. This document deals in detail of tensions between Kim Jung Un and the North Korean military.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The wars in Vietnam and Korea, during the Cold War, were both attempts made by the United States to stop/slow the spread of communism in East Asia. During these two wars, the US was unwilling to partake in total warfare, yet was not prepared to lose in battle. Due to this, limited options were available for the US to remain in their position of dominant world power, achieved in their victory during the Second World War. How did the United States position as dominant power in the World coming out of World War Two modify their foreign policy, thus changing their tactics in the Korean and Vietnam wars? The United States achieved modified victory based off of foreign policy, through strategy change and ideological change to remain the dominant…

    • 1074 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sovereignty In North Korea

    • 1858 Words
    • 8 Pages

    They have found this hatred mainly from the cold war. This started in the year of 1950 and it ended in 1953 this ended up splitting Korea into North and South Korea. King John Un has a fear that the United States are going to disrupt their sovereignty because they are a community that is run by Communism. However, this is not true the United States does not want to fight because they do not see the reason being fit. However, North Korea has recently been threating us with their nuclear capabilities that can supposedly reach the U.S. mainland’s.…

    • 1858 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The army of the United States was marching forward to the North Korea disregard of China’s warnings, supposing that China will never take action against them. Then war was waged. If the United States would perceive precisely how much possibility that China will take to take part in the war, the United States will probably stop where it should stop and therefore prevent the war from happening. According to above we can learn that as a result of the information asymmetry and actions like keeping private information, misrepresenting private information, etc, the both parties cannot effectively form a bargaining range ahead of the war, which means as Powell(2004) argues that war is a strategical replacement of negotiation, and game interaction ends once the states decide to…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However they have to help us stop North Korea if they are serious about this proclamation. As I’ve said before, the only countries that are going to get harmed from this war are North Korea and us, so we have to let the north Korean government know that, and stop them from proceeding with their…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The U.S. should make it very clear that these strikes are limited in scope, the strikes are in defense of North Korean threats, and the U.S. will not seek regime change. The U.S. would also need to persuade China to assist in preventing North Korean military escalations. Although Kim Jong-un may retaliate on a small scale, he understands that war will ultimately lead to the demise of his regime. The above preconditions are a starting point to make this a supportable option. Compelling regime change is also an…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Apart from the domestic factors, what are the external causes for the Korean War? → First, the U.S. withdrew its troops from South Korea by the end of June 1949. South Korean President Syngman Rhee insisted on the necessity of the U.S. troops in Korea as a deterrent to aggression and consequent civil war. However, the Truman administration made a decision of withdrawal and it was based on the conclusion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, in 1947, that the U.S. has little strategic interest in maintaining the present troops and bases in Korea. (pp.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example with North Korea, they do not respond to talking and threaten the United States with nuclear threats, talking with them will not work and could just result to an attack on the U.S. War is oftentimes necessary because sometimes violence is necessary, there are positives to declaring war, and it can get things done faster. A reason that war is sometimes necessary is that sometimes violence is necessary. If terrorism threatens a country, military action will most likely need to be taken (“Violence Sometimes Necessary”). If terrorism or a terrorist threaten a country, like 9/11, war may have to be the only option, because otherwise whoever is attacking your country will not stop unless you put a stop to it. The U.S probably would not…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When China asked North Korea not to launch the ballistic missiles, they did not proceed to listen (Perlez, “China Struggles”). China wanted to stop this launch from happening because they knew that it was going to start up a controversy about North Korea. Since China is allies with North Korea, they want to still have a close bond with them so interaction will not be blocked off from them since North Korea got in trouble. This did end up happening because the United Nations came into the situations and suggested to put tighter sanctions on North Korea (Perlez, “China Struggles”). China is afraid to follow through these tougher sanctions regulations because they do not want their uncooperative ally into a worrisome enemy (Perlez, “China Struggles”).…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    they were unable to veto the original plan to intervene. But later on the U.S.S.R. re-joined and began to oppose all the plans of intervention the U.S. had put forward in the U.N. As the back and forth between the two Veto empowered countries continued, the more evident it became that the United Nations was not the idealistic institution imagined, but rather the U.N. had become a tool for countries (sitting on the Security Council) to pursue their own interests, in this case the power struggle over the disembodied Koreas. The creation of the United Nations can be held accountable in the further empowerment of the Members of the Security Council. During the Korean War the U.S.S.R. were able to do as they wished without any interference through the United Nations, they were enabled through their Veto power, the same argument can made for the intervention of the United States during the crisis. Seeing as the United States was so resolute to retain South Korea as democratic nation contrarily to the North Korea, which had laid claims to communism largely influenced by the U.S.S.R. Arguably, it was the fear of communism that drove the Americans to demand action on behalf of the United Nations, only to push forward their own political philosophy.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays