Robot Assisted Surgery Essay

1243 Words 5 Pages
Te chnology i s revolu tionizing the me dical field with the cre ation of robotic devic es and complex imagi ng. Mini mally invasive su rgery, or robot a ssisted surgery, is a co ncept surrounding many common proced ures that existed prio r to the i ntro duction of robots. The g oal of us ing robo ts in medic ine is to prov ide imp roved diagnost ic abili ties, a less invasive and more com fortable experie nce for the p atient, and the abi lity to do smal ler and mor e precise int erventions. It is used for proced ures that req uire long cuts by enter ing the body thro ugh small entry inci sions in stead, surgeons use long-ha ndled instruments to op erate on tissue within th e body, avoiding …show more content…
The da Vinci system, the device that is mostly used in U.S. hospitals, costs between “$1.1 million and $2 million, with an additional cost of $100 thousand to $180 thousand for maintenance annually” (Rabin). Due to the cost, not all doctors or ho spitals are onb oard with buying the device. Since the cost of the device is high it causes the price of the surgery to increase. According to a study published by surgeons in Boston, they calculated the total averages of surgery prices for diff erent types of hysterec tomies, “$49,526 for a robotic procedure, $43,622 for abdominal, $28,312 for laparoscopic and $31,934 for vaginal” (Pinkerton). Shown here the cost to perform a hysterectomy, which is a su rgery to remove a wom an 's uterus, is higher when using the robotic device. There is no go od data proving tha t robotic hysterec tomy is even as goo d as or better than exist ing, and far less co stly, mini mally invasive alte rnatives.The cost is too expensive for it to be beneficial to the patient. The reason as to why the cost of robotic surgery is higher is from “the cost of acquiring and maintaining robotic equipment and instruments” (Keisler). Doctors are increa singly evaluating care in te rms of value, defi ned as the quality of the me dical outcome divi ded by the cost of treat ment. The higher price doesn’t bring down the risk with using robot assisted surgery. The technology hasn’t evolved yet …show more content…
Robotic devices that are being placed in operation rooms is not a necessity, surgeons are doing what needs to be done fine without a robotic device such as the da Vinci. A study has shown that “there is no significant difference between robotic and open surgery, the length of hospitalization was largely the same” (Keisler). The main goal of robotic surgery to improve precision and to prevent blood loss. With the study showing no significant difference, robotic surgery ultimately is useless as of now. Many surgeons are happy with no robot assistance in the operation room, as they have been taught how to perform certain surgeries in certain ways for many years, with new technology coming in, surgeons don’t have much knowledge on it. Although surgeons are required to take a course before being able to use any robot device, the course only takes one to two years which is not enough time for a surgeon it fully learn about robotic surgery. Surgeons are being rushed to learn about it and aren’t learning it in-depth. For patient safety, the surgeon must feel comfortable with using the device and many aren’t. The media portrays that robotic surgery is the way to go, “aggressive direct-to-consumer marketing of the latest medical technologies may mislead the public into believing that they are the best choice” ( “Robotic surgery linked to 144 deaths in the US”). The purpose of surgery

Related Documents