Rhetorical Analysis

Improved Essays
Every individual person in the modern world is innately capable of performing similar duties as everyone else, yet people differ immensely in cultures and beliefs. The levels of advancement and innovation are also unmistakably diverse, leading to certain societies dominating and seizing control over others. Recognizing the causes of these economic and social dissimilarities is crucial in analyzing and attempting to find an approach in dealing with world conflicts. Jared Diamond, an ornithologist, was posed a seemingly simple but very complex question by a local politician named Yali. During a casual conversation, Yali simply asks why the Westerners had already developed so much technology and goods when settling, while the Natives in New Guinea …show more content…
In fact, Diamond asserts that the area of New Guinea was actually more intelligent than the highly developed Eurasian area even though the New Guinea societies were notably underdeveloped (Diamond 20-21). He seeks to portray the New Guineans’ superior intelligence by stating that the people who first located the land of Australia and New Guinea achieved a tremendous accomplishment because their migration into the land “demanded watercraft and provides by far the earliest evidence of their use in history” (Diamond 41). Diamond argues that the earliest inhabitants of New Guinea were able to achieve a feat that no one had been able to perform by inventing the first known watercraft. (Diamond 41-42) Therefore, the society inhabiting New Guinea was innately intelligent and capable of innovating, even more so than the currently developed Eurasia. By attempting to provide proof that the New Guineans were more intelligent than the Eurasians, Diamond is expressing that all individuals are born with the same capacity to contribute to their society, regardless of the civilization’s current development in relation to other …show more content…
After hundreds of years, the two civilizations met, and the Maori mercilessly seized the peace-seeking Moriori. Diamond provides the sole explanation that “it is easy to trace how the differing environments… molded the Moriori and the Maori differently” (Diamond 55). The “differing environments,” Diamond claims, directly establish the agricultural opportunities that the Maori and Moriori were able to take advantage of. The Moriori were left with the option of being hunter-gatherers because their area’s climate did not allow for the growth of crops. Meanwhile, the Maori lived among an environment suitable for agriculture and became ferocious warriors because their abundance of food allowed for opportunites on various professions such as weaponry and leadership (Diamond 54-56). Diamond conveys his point that environmental variations limit the society in its focus on production and resources. Eventually, different societies will concentrate on improving their development based on their capabilities and their geographical position, and civilizations with varying speeds of innovation evolve. Diamond’s core argument lies beneath this principle and aims to explain the correlation between the environment and the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond went to New Guinea to originally research birds that lived there. Along his travels he met a man named Yali who he spent some time talking to, who then asked Jared the question Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own? Jared at the time had no answer to Yali’s question, so he decided to do research on the question and wrote a book about it. His theory to Yali ’s question was it’s not the people themselves but the environment.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. For a civilization to conquer another, not only does it require knowledge and strategy, but also the aid of geography. This is a statement that Jared Diamond, an evolutionary biologist and biogeographer, demonstrated through his thirty years of research. His theory explained how human societies differed in regards to advancement and technology as a result of the dissimilarities in their environments. This advancement and technology aided civilizations in conquering others.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1.One of the most commonly espoused answers to “Yali’s Question” is that there is a biological difference among different groups of people, or that Europeans are just superior to other races. Jared Diamond proves this wrong by stating that human differences in intelligence is caused by the difference in technology, that on average modern day people who live in the “Stone Age” are probably more intelligent than industrialized people. Another common answer to “Yali’s Question” is that Europeans were able to use technology. Jared Diamond addresses this by explaining the difference in technology between Yali’s people and Europeans. He refutes this by saying that when given the chance or opportunity primitive people are able to master technology.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond, uses figurehead Yali, a New Guinean politician, to shape his book, Guns, Germs, and Steel. Yali asks an essential question in which Jared Diamond formulates his work around. “Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own?” (14). Even though Yali’s question was only relating the differences between the New Guinean and European lifestyles and success, Jared Diamond was able to broaden Yali’s question to examine why the Europeans became so specialized, powerful, and wealthy while other peoples did not. To find the answer to Yali’s questions, Diamond began the book by mapping out the early migrations of people from Africa to all of the other continents, and from there he chose specific societies to focus on (24).…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out Of Eden Analysis

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Out of Eden” is the first episode which starts off the Guns, Germs, and Steel documentary. This episode kicks off in a country called Papua New Guinea due to the major impact that it had toward Jared Diamond’s findings. In New Guinea, Jared Diamond became inspired to understand why some societies are not as advanced as others. This question has never really entered my mind until I watched this documentary and learned more about Jared’s well thought out theories. In this episode, hunter-gathering, farming, and animal domestication are all examined in order to fully grasp the advancement of cultures.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Diamond builds a very educated tone through the use of an intellectual vocabulary, and his choice of diction helps him convey his claims effectively and clearly. Throughout the chapter, Diamond primarily appeals to the reader’s sense of logos and ethos, and these both strengthen his argument. All of these pieces come together to allow Diamond to build an effective rhetorical argument that adequately explains the factors that led to the present fates of different human…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond’s popular book , Guns, Germs and Steel, argues that Eurasians were blessed with superior environmental conditions. Eurasians were able to utilize this advantage to dominate and colonize other parts of the world. According to Diamond, this environmental theory explains the inequality that has occurred in our world in the past 500 years and is the main reason that our world is the way it is today. Although Diamond’s argument looks to be valid on the surface, when examined, it turns out to be full of fallacies and holes. By only looking at this issue from an environmental perspective, Diamond’s conclusion is inaccurate and incomplete; he has left moral, intellectual and biological factors out and as a result, he has had to modify and twist facts to serve his purpose.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over periods of time cultures continually shift and change. There are different political levels of culture that categorize people groups by their stratification, kinship, and economic stature “When culture first began on Earth, all societies were organized at the band level as foraging societies. Over time, various cultures became increasingly more complex while others remained bands” (“Cultural Anthropology Lecture 2, 2016: p1). Each of these cultural levels has positive and negative social aspects. Some cultures, such as that of the Tiwi people, prefer to live in a simple band level, which primarily focuses on foraging and collecting food.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    are smarter than New Guineans: “However, the differential had little to do with intelligence, and instead involved generic resistance dependent on details of body chemistry.” (21) Moreover, His meticulous academic attitude and comprehensive logic structure shown in him being skeptical all the time. Even questioning whether Yali’s question itself founded or not: “One objection goes as follows. If we succeed in explaining how some people came to dominate other people, may this not seem to justify the domination? Doesn’t it seem to day that the outcome is inevitable, and that it would therefore be futile to try to change the outcome today?”…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    History can be defined as an account of man’s progress: From hunter-gatherers to pioneers of industry, man has evolved from surviving to thriving. Success came to those who used; use the spear to live, use the plow to feed, and use the cage to contain. One could credit the survival of man to our capacity to use. No longer is progress defined by how we survive, but rather how much profit we can produce, how many amenities we can create, and how many unnecessary ‘necessities ' we can mass produce. This is reflective of how much we have progressed.…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Progress can be defined as the development of a more complete or contented form of living. For the Rapa Nui, or inhabitants of Easter Island; however, progress sounded so blissful that they advanced to the point of oblivion. Consequently, the upbringing of their success was the undoing of their very existence. Prior to any settlement, Easter Island was teeming with an abundance of trees, water, and fertile soil (Wright 121). Unfortunately, this period of vivaciousness ceased to carry on once the island’s inhabitants began to carelessly deplete its natural resources.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Developing civilizations since the beginning of time have lacked the sophistication that European empires have exemplified. Pre-columbian indians have been said to come close to the greatness that surrounds the characteristics of a sophisticated society. Though native accomplishments have proven a technological feat, their civilizations didn't acquire the domestication of large animals, steel weaponry, steady production of goods, functioning currency, communication with other empires, or smart military tactics that further define the sophistication of an empire. Pre-columbian civilizations were built on complex systems that seem to only work in such conditions they were in at the time. Beginning with the Inca economic system which had a non existent currency.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Acemoglu Vs. Robinson

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Acemoglu and Robinson make great strides in the institutional argument from North and Thomas’ start in Rise of the Western World. Their case is quite compelling in addressing the question of why are some countries so rich and some so poor. It’s appealing mainly because it all boils down to incentives: if masses are incentivized, a country will grow, if the elites alone are incentivized/hold the power, a country will stagnate. This argument is almost impossible to refute because it’s built on the fact that people respond to incentives to make (primarily) their own lives better — an idea one would be hard pressed to find flaw with. The incentive to “survive better” is the most basic incentive upon which to build a theory.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Progress Trap Of Progress

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the book, A Short History of Progress, Ronald Wright addresses the question of progress and whether it is good or bad. He introduces the notion of a progress trap which is the idea that human progress will lead to the end of our species and maybe even the world. Wright suggests that progress is dangerous and believes that there is such a thing as “too much progress” (Wright 2004: 5). He argues that our modern dilemma is as old as civilization; in fact, it begins with the establishment of civilization. Wright claims that civilization is an experiment that we have not tried nor managed to control.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Review about the documentary “Guns, Germs and Steel” “Guns, Germs, and Steel (2005)” is a documentary which based on Jared Diamond’s homonymic book and was presented by National Geographic. The documentary contains three episodes: Out of Eden, Conquest, and Into The Tropics; it begins with several thoughtful questions: Why did the European conquer other continents, rather than other continents conquer the European? What is secret of their success? Why the world becomes inequality like this way? At the beginning, the documentary overthrew the idea that the power is controlled by race.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays