Rhetorical Analysis Of The Left Handed Commencement Address

Improved Essays
Award-winning author and feminist Ursula K. Le Guin delivered a rhetorically complex speech to the Mills College graduating class of 1983, comprised almost entirely of women. Her speech came at a challenging time for women, as second-wave feminism began to dissolve into a myriad of disagreeing factions. The title of the speech, the “Left-Handed Commencement Address,” is a reference to her book The Left Hand of Darkness, which follows an androgynous race of space aliens. This foreshadows the content of her speech, wherein Le Guin discusses gender norms and the importance of women forging their own paths in a male-dominated society. Le Guin uses strong ethos to connect with her audience successfully, though I believe she uses her credibility …show more content…
You can’t even get there by selling yourself out: because there is theirs, not yours” (Le Guin). The beginning of this line is a reference to an old Phillip Morris ad for cigarettes targeted at women, while the end – “but no way is long enough” – is of Le Guin’s own devising. With it, she implies that while women can gain space in a male-dominated world, as they did with cigarette ads, this fight is futile because “there is theirs, not yours” (Le Guin). No carefully carved-out space in the male arena will ever be fit for women, because such spaces were inherently forged with men in mind. While Le Guin did not pen all of these words herself, the pronoun built into the phrase “You’ve come a long way, baby” is still rhetorically effective for Le Guin. As opposed to calling women “we,” the use of “you” gives Le Guin authority. Celebrated in her field – science fiction writing, a traditionally male-dominated field – Le Guin understands the challenges of the women in the audience. She has fought for success in “the language of our tribe… the men’s language” (Le Guin). This “you” is personal, if almost intimate, especially in the final line “You can’t even get there by selling yourself out: because there is theirs, not yours” (Le Guin). This usage does separate her from her audience, but by evoking the concept of “theirs” in the same breath, Le Guin creates an “other”. The “other” she creates with the phrase “there is theirs” is men, whom she separates from the “you” of women. By separating out men and women into “their” and “you,” Le Guin maintains the dichotomy she created earlier with the use of “we,” allowing her to still connect with the women in the audience while delivering authoritative advice with the pronoun

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Chaucer had pointed out some of the personality characters of the wife of bath to imply that she was wrong and needed to be criticized. Nonetheless, the empowerment of female sexuality is entirely portrayed through the wife of bath when she insists that certain negativity should not be associated with women, there should be marriage hierarchal system that considers both genders equal and the need for men to be submissive to their wives for them to avoid sexually and physically abusing women. In brief, the wife of bath presents some of the dysfunctional social issues that were never addressed and seemed to be a hindrance to women’s life. Through expressing the need for women to have the right to sexuality, independence, and safety, she can be viewed as a significant feminist during the medieval…

    • 1752 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As seen in the case of Caster Semanya, once male build is taken from men and given to women, the women is not given power but rather is ridiculed for not being feminine enough. Beyoncé is voicing that she believes that women should be respected more for respecting themselves enough to engage in that kind of behavior.…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She is not a representative of feminist ideals for a couple reasons. First, she totally depends on her husbands for financial support. Second, she has little respect for her body as she is willing to share it with anyone regardless of them being short, tall, dark or fair. (CT. 624) If we compare the feminist view of women and Alison’s behaviour, there are a lot of contradictions. The Wife of Bath’s goals are to rule her husbands and profit from them, however the way she does it is simply through sexual gist.…

    • 2458 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    After having a closer look examining each role does one not get a sense of the empowerment radiating from each action of our ladies? Of course, it is obvious throughout the Epic of Gilgamesh that men are the main controllers of power (such as Gilgamesh himself) but it is their ‘mere’ female counterparts that persuade the men from stopping king Gilgamesh to helping the king. From beginning to end, indirectly and directly the role of woman is of great significance in the Epic of Gilgamesh. The story may not be written to develop themselves, they may not hold any remarkable qualities (excluding the divine Ninsun), and they may not be the heroes but these women help set the foundation of the story for Gilgamesh and Enkidu. Often kicked to the dirt and downplayed the role of woman still stands in triumph and…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This attention gives women the feeling they are enough and the desire for progress or growth is eradicated. In Wollstonecraft’s opinion, this lack of growth can be changed if this growth is no longer unnaturally stunted by a society that intends to keep women as ignorant and obedient as possible. Women have just as much potential as men and should be granted to ability to fully utilize this potential. Women are also often told their easily influenced hearts, fragile feelings are admirable and attractive, but Wollstonecraft sees them as epithets of weakness (308). Men use these supposedly admirable characteristics in a condescending fashion to convince women they are objects of pity and their education is unneeded.…

    • 1559 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Woolf is very blunt in saying that women were capable of doing everything a man could but society does not accept it. Gilman is not very blunt about it but uses the story filled with satire to show how women had no rights. Furthermore, the wife is treated like a child representing the fact that society did not think women could do anything. Woolf is discussing women in real life verses women in plays. As discussed before women in plays were almost worshipped for their looks when in real life “respectable women could hardly show her face alone in the street,” (Woolf).…

    • 2215 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The way the “hero” dismisses “feminine” roles and relegates them to women. The fact that not a single women is in the entire advertisement whenever there is no reason to target men specifically for a low calorie soda. It purposely tells women what they are allowed to enjoy and what they 're not allowed to enjoy. The unnecessary over representation of men inadvertently leads to an under representation of women. Although we have come a long way as a society in terms of gender roles and identities, this advertisement shows that there is still a lot of work needed before women are respected as true equals that they are.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She also argues that a woman should have the right to explore her sexuality and be her authentic self. In not having the freedom to be who and do what is desired it gives more of a reason for woman to become oppressed within society. This is one of the reason why woman and man alike choose not to be defined it is a way to maintain possession of their power. Moreover, Diana L. Hayes, in her work Standing in the Shoes My Mother Made she speaks about the power of naming and when one is named or labeled as a particular thing you take power over them. Women allow themselves to remain free and empowered by taking away the means to be defined by others.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Radical Feminism, a term used for feminists who took the ideals of equality and constructed them into a product for hate against equality and the patriarchy, and abided for the suppression of men, has become the prime example for those new to feminism. Most women do not know what Feminism actually represents, and people choose not to partake in feminism because they believe that feminists “‘…are men-hating lesbians who 'd sooner burn a bra than buy one.” This is extremely falsified, in fact, feminist of today promote the re-education of feminist philosophy and the preliminary rights that all human beings should expect, “feminism is not about overpowering or emasculating men in…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a result, the advertisement supports gender stereotypes by perpetuating males with domineering attitudes while women are left to be passive and helpless. Although the woman may appear to be allowing this kind of behavior, this is only portraying the woman as a target due to her feminine figure being shown in a degrading manner. She is viewed as less than due to the position she is in, all the men are overlooking her and she quickly becomes the target for the men. Jean Kilbourne in the article "Two Ways a Woman Can Get Hurt" goes into great detail explaining how advertisements can affect females in society. Kilbourne states that "It is hard for girls not to learn self-hatred in an environment in which there is such widespread and open contempt for women and girls."…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays