Rhetorical Analysis Of Lost In America By Douglas Mcgray

Superior Essays
In his article “Lost in America,” Douglas McGray highlights the issues of isolationism in the American educational system and lack of focus of the American educational system on the learning of foreign cultures in order to prove that the American educational system needs improvement. The article was issued by Foreign Policy magazine in 2006 in which involves a broader audience. However, McGray’s target audience is people that can make changes in the educational curriculum, which signifies that his intended audience includes American legislators involved in American curriculum policies. McGray, who is co-creator and editor-in-chief of Pop-Up Magazine, claims that Americans are neglecting a valuable resource that is essential for the future generations’ …show more content…
McGray inspires his audience to take action, stating, “The United States can no longer afford an isolationist education, any more than the world can afford an isolationist American Public” (McGray 359). Through this quote, McGray alerts American legislators that a curriculum that lacks multiculturalism will make the country fall behind other nations and subsequently compromise the future of the United States of America. McGray triggers American legislators’ emotions, pushing them to think carefully about the enhancement of the American education curriculum to a one that incorporates the foreign language, world’s history, geography and cultural diversity. It perfectly addresses American legislators since the curriculum they expect to be perfect on teaching students the most significant subjects and to be appropriate to the globalized world we live might have become a threat to America’s society future. Consequently, it provides to American legislators the massive responsibility they have. McGray purposely uses this rhetorical choice to encourage his audience to be ambitious and rethink about the type of future Americans may have if they do not embrace world’s knowledge. In addition to that, this rhetorical choice was intentionally positioned at the end of the article to convince …show more content…
In addition to that, the author delightedly persuades his audience through the use of hyperbole making a deep comparison between American education and other nations. McGray is also victorious in motivating American legislators to take action to implement multicultural studies in the America educational curriculum through the use of a call to action as one of his rhetorical choices. In my opinion, McGray’s solid arguments and efficient use of rhetorical choices are triumphantly persuasive to induce his target audience of American legislators to change the existing situation of the American educational curriculum to a one that incorporates history, language, geography and ethnicity of cultures all over the world. Furthermore, according to my understanding, through “Lost in America” McGray reinforces not only to American legislators but also to society in general, the value of a eligible education and strengthen to students their significant position on the America’s future.

Works Cited
McGray, Douglas. “Lost in America.” First-Year Writing: Writing in the Disciplines. 9th Ed. Texas Tech University. New York: Pearson Learning Solutions, 2015. 351-359.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Critique of a Thoughtworld 1.) In Hirsch’s “critique of a thoughtworld”, from The Schools We Need and Why We Don’t Have Them, he begins by talking about what he believes to be is the “one true belief” among mainstream educationists. He believes that the “one true belief” is characterized as a “constantly repeated catechism” that has “currently no thinkable alternative”(Hirsch, p.69). What he means by this is that for quite some time now educationists have been using the same old out dated logic in our education system, and they will not look at any different options, because they will not accept that their “one true belief” could be wrong. If they could just put their beliefs and pride beside then we would be able to reform our schools and…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This quote shows his different tone which is one of his rhetorical choices in “Lost in America”. For other examples of the problem, he does not show his emotions or opinions after he mentions the problem. However, in this quote, he successfully demonstrates his idea that Americans` inward-looking perspectives is an obstacle to be globalized, and he conveys his feeling by using negative word choices such as “anachronism” and “provincial tendency’. By changing his neutral tone to negative tone at the moment, this quote stands out in comparison to other quotes, help the author show his disapproval, and his primary audience, American educators, parents who are concerned their children`s education about foreign languages, and government officials would change their perspective of foreign…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To further analyze American history, and eliminate the truths from the myths, Loewen takes us through a journey of revealing the mindless optimism, blind patriotism, lies and misinformation that cloud most history books. He analyzes the information contained in 12 high school history books and s analyzes this information, providing what he believes is the truth, and separating it from the lies. Loewen provides an honest evaluation of the history of the United States, giving life and value into a history that had become very boring and monotonous. Introduction…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In his article “Lost in America,” Douglas McGray focuses heavily on the problem of isolationism and a lack of worldwide perspectives in the U.S. education system in order to prove that changes in the education of young Americans must be made. “Lost in America” was issued by Foreign Policy magazine in 2006, which reveals that McGray’s audience includes American legislators involved in the elaboration of American curriculum policies. In order to support his argument for this audience of policy makers and legislators, McGray builds credibility through the use of anecdotes that surprise and shock his audience, hyperboles to overemphasize his points, and a well-elaborated call to action to encourage his intended audience. McGray effectively employs…

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First, Let Teenagers Have a Fair Shot at Adolescence Across the hypercritical and interconnected global society that exists today, a multitude of notions and opinions constantly stream from every source imaginable; however, Leon Botstein’s analysis of education in America stands out among the most profound. Bluntly writing in a piece entitled Let Teenagers Try Adulthood, Botstein proposes, “the American high school is obsolete and should be abolished” (153). This provocative nature of Botstein’s writing leads to polarized views of the education system that could ultimately result in alienation of individuals or groups with more moderate views. That is not to say Botstein lacks valid points.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Teach Diversity – with a Smile,” journalist Barbara Ehrenreich explains the current conflict between people who would like to replace our Eurocentric bias in education with a multicultural approach and those critics and conservative scholars who are leading the backlash against multiculturalism and “political correctness.” Writing for readers of Time magazine, Ehrenreich uses her own experience growing up in the 1950s to explain that her narrow education left her a “victim of monoculturalism,” ill-equipped to cope with America’s growing cultural diversity. Ehrenreich applauds multiculturalism’s goal of preparing people for a culturally diverse world, but she is impatient at the “haughty stance” of the P.C. people because they mistake “verbal purification for genuine social reform” and they arrogantly bully people and “correct” their language. Since actions speak louder than words, Ehrenreich argues, the multiculturalists should focus more on genuine social reform – paying equal salaries to men and women, creating access for people with disabilities, and reducing date rape and alcohol abuse. The solution to the problem,…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Barber shows how foreign students receive better education than American ones when he cites, “American children are in school only about 180 days a year, as against 240 days or more for children in Europe or Japan.” From this, it can be seen that America does not prioritize education as much as other countries do, and is currently being left behind. With increasing dropout rates, lack of basic literacy, and de-emphasis on getting a good education, American students are being deprived of their civil right to be able to become well-informed and cognizant people, which later on will prevent them from being successful in…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zhao summarizes the chapters with a somewhat simple solution, “In order for America to compete in a global society American needs to be more American”. He again references the fact that this a mindset changes away from centralized policies that include sameness among all educational institutions. Because of this Zhao states we are seeing more teachers teach to the test because of the high stakes involved with standardized testing. To expand our diversity, we have to step away from emphasizing the importance of success in the areas of math and reading. The shift to a more personalized learning educational plan is what Dr. Zhao supports.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Seok Hee “Christine” Hong Williamson AP Language and Composition 29 December 2016 2008 Form B FRQ Q2 What’s wrong with being intellectually curious and academically serious? Apparently everything, as far as society’s concerned, but Fridman thinks not. In the article “America Needs Its Nerds,” Leonid Fridman criticizes American society for its anti-intellectual values and emphasizes the need to stand against it through the use of rhetorical strategies such as exemplifications and comparisons.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Karissa Mata Globalization has been the major dimension of change in American education. American education has reflected public concern about the nation 's role in the world. Back-to-Basics was represented by the conservative ethos in Reagan’s election. It called for an end to liberal policies associated with the 1960s.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The role of education is to teach students about the unique and exceptional historical events that made the United States of America the greatest nation humanity has ever seen.” This statement, although many would like to believe in it, is a lie. For centuries Americans have declared the United States “the greatest nation in the world,” “leader of the free world,” a place of “life, liberty, and happiness,” a place where anyone could achieve the “American dream.” This mindset, is the belief of American Exceptionalism, a dangerous myth that allows many Americans to ignore evidence that America is not the virtuous nation who respects all human rights or law or peace in history or contemporary America. Although many may not believe in the harm…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consequently, writers, such as Ronald Takaki would influence future generations on the aspect of a more diverse America. As an educator of ethnic studies at the University of Berkeley, Professor Ronald Takaki wrote an award winning novel titled, A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. Takaki’s most predominant argument was that our history was written wrongfully and as a result, education was flawed by the lack of inclusion of various ethnic groups. We had set a…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The future leaders and educators of America are in the school’s classrooms. Among these students are immigrants, primarily Syrian refugees seeking educational opportunities through our education system. The history of immigrants in America’s schooling has shown that students enrolled into courses are an attempt to gain opportunities in our country. The role of American schools is to educate its students, and immigrants are major participants to the student population. Despite the difficult ability to acquire an educational opportunity in the United States, the immigrant population continue to struggle in successfully assimilating into the American culture by facing a language barrier while having an inadequate access to resources of human capital and cultural capital.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Loewen’s Lies My Teacher Told Me is a vital piece in understanding the negatives of American exceptionalism on students throughout the nation as well as developing an opinion on educational reform. Within his book, Loewen reveals various “fact versus fiction” instances of American History allowing the reader to discover how they have been manipulated since a very young age into believing the “super hero” alter ego of the US and it’s historical figures. Some of these figures include George Washington, Woodrow Wilson, Abraham Lincoln, and other significant American icons. In his introduction, Loewen states “Not understanding their past renders many Americans incapable of thinking effectively about our present and future.” ¹…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Americah Analysis

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Americanah by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie is a novel, which is a cultural opprobrium of Nigeria and America. This novel points out the materialistic desires of Nigeria—how women want to marry rich, and the wealthy are supposed to be automatically respected. As well as the racism, racial hierarchy, and real struggles with American freedom that Ifemelu faces when she comes to the “Land of The Free.” These cultural criticisms support our American exceptionalist views; therefore, considering the other novels and film we have explored and discusses in class, Americanah would fit into the class curriculum and support the exceptionalism America has.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays