Jay Heinrichs 'Rhetorical Argument From Strength'

Improved Essays
Section One, Intro/Offense: Jay Heinrichs points out how rhetoric is an incredibly useful skill that dates all the way back to being started by the ancient Greeks and perfected by the Romans. As time progressed in about the 19th century rhetoric increasingly became less popular and has not been a large part of education. Heinrichs would like to show to people just how important rhetoric truly is. Rhetorical arguments are all around us, as the author notices the company that makes his wrist watch uses a form of marketing called “argument from strength”, simply meaning if something works in the rough it will work in the smooth. Heinrichs leads into a vey important part of a rhetorical argument, persuasion. Persuading is the act of convincing …show more content…
There are three questions to be asked to determine weather a statement is a logical fallacy; Does the proof hold up?, Are the right number of choices given?, and finally , does the proof lead to the right choices?. Using these questions will often protect you from the “beautiful variety of ways that people cheat, lie, and steal.”. The first “sin” is the false comparison. This is when you compare something positive, to something negative, making the negative thing looked at better. Another kind of false comparison is the appeal to popularity, when assuming something is far more popular than it is, you make a false comparison. False analogy is also a form of false comparison. False analogy is doing one thing well, so you then think you can do something completely unrelated just as well. The second “sin” is the awful example. This is when people generally from little to no evidence. The third logical “sin” is ignorance as proof, this is when you misinterpret the data in your favor, or as Rumsfeld says “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.”. Similarly, reaching a vast conclusion with less than stellar data is known as hasty generalization. The fourth is tautology or just repeating an idea or premise. The fifth is the allusion of choice, or false choice. The sixth logical sin is called red herring. This tactic involves brining up something completely unrelated distracting the audience. Finally there is the wrong ending. Wrong ending is when you get a completely false conclusion from the given evidence. Aristotle definition of virtue is, a state of character, conceded with choice, lying in the mean. When using ethos in rhetoric the speaker needs to realize what the audience needs. For example a sales man selling a pool table would realize that a wife is buying something to make her husband happy, the salesman can then play into her need and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    We then had to decide whether these appeals ultimately worked to convince the reader. Lastly we developed a thesis, where we took a stand on whether we believed the article was effective in its use of rhetorical strategies. After writing a rough…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis Rough Draft To Jay Heinrichs, author of “Thank You for Arguing”, rhetoric is a persuasive essential; and while used in the art of influence, it provides an undeniable amount of credulous logic. The rhetoric used in the time frame of this book pertains to many political debates and presidential campaigns. Politicians need to use the tool of rhetoric to sway their audience’s opinion. The communication made from a speaker to an audience is illustrated dealing primarily with credibility, and the logic concerned with the writers argument; rhetoric is the most powerful argumentative tool.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Book about Rhetoric: is it Worth Reading? Jay Heinrichs is a New York Times best selling author thanks to his book, Thank You For Arguing; what Aristotle, Lincoln, and Homer Simpson Can Teach us about the Art of Persuasion . He is a leading expert in the study of persuasion and applies his knowledge of ethos, pathos, and logos to construct his position. Heinrichs also brings to play what he has learned from his 25 year long career as a journalist, as well as his lifelong study of rhetoric and applies it to his book.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The study of rhetoric today is dying. Thank You for Arguing wants to change that. By introducing rhetoric as a useful everyday tool Thank You for Arguing hopes to revive the mass knowledge and use of rhetoric in everyday conversations. Thank You for Arguing is an excellent book and by giving excellent examples combined with emotion and tools to use logic in an argument it excels in introducing such a vague concept as rhetoric and should have continued use in schools. Thank You for Arguing, written by Jay Heinrichs in February of 2007, brings rhetoric into another light that appeals to the common person that continues to hold a place on Harvard’s top 10 reading list because of its value.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When Grasses Turn Dormant and When Cattle Are not Ruminant As one of the forms of writing art, rhetoric usage relies on different genres and emotional appeals to communicate with the audiences and to achieve the goal of persuasion. Successful and effective application of rhetoric skills in an article will make it shine. This paper will focus on the rhetorical choices that Michael Pollan made when he crafts his arguments. To be more specific, this paper will shed light on what rhetoric methods did Michael Pollan use such as various rhetoric appeals, facts, images, word choices, and narratives so as to persuade the audiences to buy his arguments. In general, this paper can be divided into two parts.…

    • 1606 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In everyday conversations, people communicate using rhetorical strategies without knowing it. It is a natural communication skill everyone develops throughout their lives. For example, they may successfully lie to their bosses that they’re sick or tell their parents why they came home late. Similarly, written works contain rhetorical strategies to make convincing arguments. For example, William Zinsser wants to tell parents, professors, and college administrators what they may not know about the conditions of students.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thank You For Arguing Analysis Essay In the book Thank You For Arguing , author and narrator , Jay Heinrichs lives his everyday life through a rhetoric standpoint. Rhetoric is the study of argument and persuasion. Heinrichs uses rhetoric as a way of helping himself , those around him , and also for him to better understand what goes on in the argumentative world. Heinrichs feels that rhetoric is the tool people should use to help them succeed and improve their everyday lives in a situation, no matter what the circumstance may be.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rhetoric is defined to be the art of effective persuasion within speaking and writing. The importance of a rhetorical situation was to have the ability to manipulate the audience with persuasion and to think of the certain topic that was once given in the current event. Rhetoric can be acted within the bounds on interaction the speaker (rhetor), audience, current issue, and the medium. As a result, these actions, conduct to creating a rhetorical situation. Also, the rhetorical situation was further defined by rhetorical theories.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rhetoric is the act of persuasive speech or writing involving the use of knowledge and figurative language to make a specific form and function of speech or writing that would best fit a person’s goal in convincing their audience. For example, you are watching your favorite TV show and the TV show goes straight too commercial. The commercial’s objective is to give awareness on smoking, which portrays cigarettes as monsters containing over 7000 chemicals. The commercial is using symbolism by representing cigarettes as noxious monsters to alarm minors and smokers how critical smoking…

    • 94 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    For one, the red herring fallacy was the most common fallacy that these two candidates displayed in their arguments. The red herring fallacy is a fallacy that utilizes other appealing information to draw away the audiences attention, in order to distract them from the main argument. The audience continually asks the candidate a question and the candidates deflects the question with ease. In the debate, an audience member asks, “Do you feel you are modelling appropriate and positive behavior for today’s youth? (CBSNewsOnline)”…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the last few months, I have read and annotated Thank You For Arguing: What Aristotle, Lincoln, and Homer Simpson can teach us about the Art of Persuasion by Jay Heinrichs. After being a journalist and publishing executive for 25 years, Heinrichs is now the professor of Rhetoric and Oratory at Middlebury College in Vermont and travels the world as a presenter and persuasion expert. Published in 12 languages and 3 editions, Thank You For Arguing is a New York Times bestseller, along with being one of the top ten books assigned at Harvard. My analysis of Thank You For Arguing made me uncover the lost art of rhetoric, the steps in creating an excellent persuasive speech, and identifying the three methods of persuasion in everyday arguments.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Everyone uses rhetoric whether they realize it or not; argument would simply fail without it. Moreover, a strong foundation in rhetoric is the key to successfully joining any community. For example, I joined my high school’s engineering club during my junior year. I didn’t really know anyone in the club besides a few friends and the club sponsor who happens to be my engineering teacher. I knew I had to go above and beyond to become an inner member, so…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jerit discusses the use of rhetoric through a political lens based on the effectiveness of arguments. She constitutes effectiveness as the sustainability and repeatability of techniques used to deliver the points of the candidates. The reason for negative appeals is that, “candidates have strong incentives to evoke emotions such as anger, fear, and anxiety; thus, appeals that are high in emotional content will survive longer than other types of arguments” (564). When using emotional appeals, it is easier to deliver a simple and uniform message than to speak on specific issues. How persuasive a candidate is perceived as depends on their delivery techniques.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He explains that rhetorical devices can be used in a variety of circumstances to prove a variety of points. He advises, “if you find an opportunity to follow up with a great retort, go for it” (101). Rhetoric is not something that should be used passively. Persuasion does not wait for the right opportunity to make itself clear rater it is in every aspect of day to day life. Heinricks teaches the universality of rhetorical devices in order to teach that rhetoric can and should be used in a day to day lifestyle.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is evident that he wants his audience to see him as a credible writer, and what is the best approach to ensure a strong ethos? Present credible and trustworthy sources and evidence to support the argument, which Johnson does from the beginning to the end of his piece. His first use of ethos presented itself as he described the TV show called 24 shown on the Fox Network (Johnson, p. 828). Not only did he include this source, but he went further on to add the details: the network, the day, the length of the show, the audience’s reaction, his argument and the counter-argument made by the audience. In this situation, he used sourced detail to incorporate ethos into the…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays