Restorative Justice Against Women

Improved Essays
Restorative justice focuses on rehabilitation of offenders through community involvement. Victims and offenders sit in front of each other and discuss the situation that occurred. While evidence suggests that “restorative justice is far more effective in rehabilitating offenders than incarceration”, it is still a controversial issue, especially in respect to domestic violence cases (Sottile 2015). This is mostly because women are seen as not “safe” when they are in a room with former abusers, inferring that women are not strong enough to stand up to their abusers, which also inadvertently says that women cannot help themselves. And while the media and society collectively fail women, restorative justice can be one of the ways to empower …show more content…
One of the arguments in the article that opposes the restorative justice approach, says that women are not “strong enough” when they take the stand and speak about the abuse they suffered to other abusers (Sottile 2015). But in actuality, when women are allowed to speak about their experiences, they prove to everyone – and most importantly: themselves – that they are, in fact, strong enough as women and as victims to overcome the abuse. Being face to face with abusers, talking to abusers, and being questioned by abusers allows women to believe in their own …show more content…
The “blame the victim” narrative is most often used in a statement such as, “they provoked it” – “they” being women. Women are defined by emphasized femininity (the ideal femininity that encourages women to be dominated by men), so they are questioned for their every move that does not fit in with definition of feminine. Thus, in domestic violence cases, women are questioned why they do not allow themselves to be dominated by men; in other words, women need to prove that they did not provoke the situation. Because women are given the chance to voice their side of the story in the restorative justice approach, they are able to connect with other women in similar situations, and collectively reassure each other that they were not to blame for the situations that occurred (Sottile 2015). Not only does the restorative justice approach unite victims and abusers, but victims with other victims. And, therefore, because victims are allowed to talk about their experiences, women are empowered and become more than just “victims”; they become

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In Jessica Pishko’s essay, “Serving Life for Surviving Abuse,” she writes about the unfortunate event that happened to Kelly Savage. Pishko focuses on why Kelly got the outcome that she did and what it means for other women. Even though this essay is written in just five short pages, it really serves as an example to show what happens to those who were victims of abuse and how the court systems handle it. Pishko thoroughly explains Kelly’s story, includes eye opening facts about women in prison, and has changed many people’s perspectives towards domestic violence. Hopefully, those who were psychically, emotionally, and sexually abused in the past will be able to seek help whether they ended up in prison or not.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Archbishop Desmond Tutu expresses in the following simple yet elegant phrase the philosophies inherent in restorative justice, “…true reconciliation exposes the awfulness, the abuse, the hurt, and the truth…”. The frank exposure of emotional, physical and psychological injury may, however, adversely impact the victim(s) or alleged perpetrator in the short term. While restorative justice can be a risky undertaking, “only an honest confrontation with reality can bring real healing”. In the criminal justice system today in the United States, “real healing” seems to be a secondary principle; priority is given to proving the innocence or guilt of the accused in a trial conducted by a judge with the services of lawyers and the jury. The main stakeholders,…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "RioLearn." RioLearn. SAVE: Stop Abusive and Violent Environments, 2013. Web. 04 Feb. 2016.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Domestic Violence Survivors Act would allow for judges to consider abuse when giving sentences to those convicted especially when the crimes were directly related to abuse. The act would consider the sentences of those arrested and convicted who defended themselves against their abusers, and those who were arrested because of crimes that connected to the abuse. The Act would also give survivors who have been sentenced to harsh sentences a chance to shorten the sentence, or be granted an early release. After years of speaking openly about survivors of abuse who were formerly and presently incarcerated, the bill has been recognized as an important issue and was approved. Prior to this Act, judges could not consider the abusive experiences…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men are often expected to be assertive and dominant, while women are often portrayed as vulnerable and emotional. These gender roles suggest that men are more likely than women to turn to aggression during times of anger, which has correlation to abuse against their female partners (Campbell and Muncer 286). As a result of domestic violence, women often suffer from mental and health problems such as chronic pain, traumatic brain injury, eating disorders, diabetes, asthma, and if the abuse is severe enough, even death (Tremer). Although there are already certain programs and laws that exist to help women who have experienced domestic and sexual abuse such as the Violence Against Women Act, women’s rights activists work to change traditional gender roles, educate women on how to prevent or cope with abuse, and provide support groups for individuals and families that have been victimized by abuse (Zimmerman, et al.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The rational focus of crime differs for serious crimes as compared to minor crimes. Serious crimes such as sexual assault are more punitive than property crimes. Sexual assault cases are taken seriously, however, the victims are ignored in sexual assault cases. The justice system continues to avoid victims, many victims feel re-victimized because the system denies them from having their voices heard (McGlynn, 2011, p.825). This paper will focus on crimes of sexual assault and the challenges of the contemporary systems of justice and how restorative justice allows for opportunities of healing.…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Wennlock Edge Summary

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Tricks” and Wenlock Edge” by Alive Munro both depict two female characters who are shamed by a male figure. The two female characters, Robin and the narrator, both deal with their feelings of shame in different ways but both wish to conform to societal norms. According to the article “The Lives of Women who Experience Male Violence” written by Helen Baker, “shame concerns the relationship of the self with others in society” (5). These two characters feel shame because they went against societal norms, and isolate themselves in order to prevent their shame from going public. Robin and the narrator’s shame comes from societal expectations that are detrimental to women.…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chisolm's Double Standards

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages

    These abusers were more than likely at home, by husbands or boyfriends. This abuse contributed to ¼ of the suicides by women and ½ the suicide attempts by black women (Jones 47). The abusers were required to be arrested, but did not suffer from the legal or social consequences. This was the same for rape cases, where feminists were criticized for portraying women as victims. Wendy Sanford and and Pamela Berger address the double standard in rape cases in Our Bodies,…

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Restoraative Justice

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages

    One of the significant limitation in evaluating the restorative justice is the fact that there are no clear guidelines in terms of defining the “success”. For examples, does low-recidivism rates among participants of CoSA really represent the success of the program? or does positive personal report from the core members of CoSA can clearly explain the success of the program? As these examples illustrate, there are many different measures that can be used to construct or define “success” of the program. In addition, these evidence-based studies conducted by many professionals do not contribute to the development and understanding of restorative justice and explain the success of CoSA. Many factors measured by the authors from the studies, such as the recidivism rates, competition rates, or personal reports are only the indicators.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is paramount in the restorative justice movement that offenders meet their clients and see the damage that offending has caused to their victims. Furthermore, the movement suggests that it is important to provide mental health treatment to those offenders who are in need in order to help these offenders better adjust to society (Van Ness, Carleson Jr., & Strong 1989). It should be noted that mental health courts, and the restorative justice movement are relatively young and have only recently become popular. Thus, the research base is extremely limited. Due to limited sample sizes most of the reviewed studied do not meticulously define type of mental health treatment and diagnoses.…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. What do we learn from these early pioneers about an event in the history of restorative justice that has not made it to the history books on restorative justice? Historical events, especially ones that do not make it to history books, hold a lot of information about the history of change and the challenges involved. The particular story shared in Chapter 2 shows us that some parts of the criminal justice system have resisted the change brought about by the restorative justice movement. The commissioner of corrections in Minnesota during 1973 fought against the benefits of approaching offender rehabilitation from the viewpoints of restorative justice.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Duluth Model

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ellen Pence is best known for her advocacy and batterer programming with the Duluth program on behalf of women’s experience with abuse (Gondolf, 2010). Ellen’s activism all started with a generic community organizing training that opened all the possibilities that contributed to social change (Dasgupta, 2010). From there, Ellen began to work in anti-domestic violence and that’s where she and her colleagues developed the Duluth model (Dasgupta, 2010). The basis of Ellen’s advocacy in anti-domestic violence was to increase the awareness of gender oppression (Gondolf, 2010). In the culture of domestic violence, gender oppression has been nearly taken over by the notion of victimization.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Restorative Justice

    • 1822 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Restorative justice is based on resolving conflict and making everything connected to the crime whole again, thus healing the effects, restoring back to original condition, and making amends to all affected by the crime. Diversion is a means in which appropriate measures are put in place in-order to deter young people from travelling down the long path of the juvenile justice system. In this essay the key will be to explore links between youth work practice, diversion and restorative programs. This will be done by outlining and sharing key strength areas where youth work practice comes in contact with assisting young people in relation to restorative practice and diversion.…

    • 1822 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S., Quiroga S. S., (December 2000), Meeting the Needs of Survivors, Department of Status of Women, City and County of San Francisco. Retrieved August 9, 2014, from http://sfgov.org/dosw/violence-against-women-girls-san-francisco This source is a survey conducted by members of Department of Status of women, city and county of San Francisco regarding why women don’t fight back against domestic abuse. This survey was conducted via telephone interviews with approximately 25% of the female population in the county participating. Results clearly showed that females tolerated the abuse to attempt to maintain a stable relationship, and positive appearance to society.…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (1) Using at least 250 words, explain each of the guiding principles of restorative justice. Restorative justice is a process in which the offender repairs wrongdoings that were done to the victim and to the community. Instead of a traditional trial, the offenders are encouraged to take responsibility for their actions by expressing remorse and even apologizing to the victim. The restorative justice process gives the victim the opportunity to meet with the offender so the victim can explain the impact of the crime to the offender, while also giving the victim the opportunity to forgive the offender.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays