Response To The Counter Claim Analysis

Decent Essays
My response the to the counter claim is the same response I have for Hardin, in that the logic and metaphors being used are flawed and fail to consider many other significant and integral factors. The poor can help themselves with the aid provided by wealthier nations they just require it in different forms such as infrastructure as opposed to outright resources. Furthermore, the wealthy are more capable of defending their own interests by ensuring the interests of other nations and should also do so simply out of their humanity.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “It is quite obvious that the ethics of none of us are clearly defined…formerly when it was believed that poverty was synonymous with vice and laziness, and that the prosperous man was the righteous man, charity was administered harshly with a good conscience; for the charitable agent really blamed the individual for his poverty…” (Addams, 1902). Unlike Sumner, Addams believes that it does not matter from what social class the individual is from, society requires more than taking care of one-self and families; it is about the social obligation of helping each other. In other words, just like in Sumner’s writing; Addams also believes that such opinions of poverty levels create the different social classes that separates the wealthy from the poor. Therefore, those individuals in the “rich class” can advance logically, materially, and industrially without any problems; while those individuals in the “poor class” are thought to never be able to move ahead and become successful because of their own…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Uniform Bill-04 or UB-04 paper claim form which is used for billing, was established to combine all the claim forms which were once used by hospitals, this was to accommodate numerous diagnoses codes. However, the inpatient reporting differs from the outpatient reporting. Inpatient claims can consist of up to 22 diagnosis codes and 6 procedure codes, of the 22 only 1 admitting diagnosis is allowed, while the outpatient claims consist of up to 24 diagnosis codes with 3 of these codes representing the reason for the visit. In addition to inpatient diagnoses reporting, the present on admission (POA) data element is included to substantiate between conditions present at the time of admission and conditions which may cultivate during the patient’s…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What duty do we have to help those who might otherwise starve without our intervention? Is it our responsibility to help our fellow man in need or are we free to stand on the sidelines? Philosophers Jan Narveson and Peter Singer offer contrasting viewpoints on the moral obligations affluent nations have to aid and support the poor. Where Singer reasons that by having the privilege of living in nations of wealth, this benefit carries with it the moral obligation to help those around the world who are sentenced to live in absolute poverty, if only because of where fate had them born. In response, Narveson argues Singer is mistaken: our responsibility and duty first lies to our circle and we should never insist that others take the responsibility…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “We honor our past because it shapes our future,” this is one of the many quotes that Otterbein University holds dearly. Otterbein University holds this value greatly. Otterbein gives equality to all students, faculty, and others since 1847. Before any women’s rights and the abolishment of slavery, Otterbein University allowed people of color and women to receive a fair and equal education. Otterbein University is a mid-sized college located in Westerville, Ohio.…

    • 322 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Participants The participants were randomly selected and derived from licensing lists from four states. Total of 1000 nurses, 250 nurses selected from each of the four different states, and census regions in the United State of America (Maryland, Massachusetts, California and Ohio), basically to describe and assess the type, frequency, occurring rate of stress of ethical dilemmas encountered by nurses in their everyday practice, (Ulrich, 2010). The second article, a group was selected from teaching hospital in Tabriz in Iran, 345 were nurses, and in-patients were 500, selected to assess knowledge and performance about nursing ethic codes, professional ethical care from nurses' to patients' perspective.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    peacekeeping abroad is able to express the values of their country. Through the years in past recognition, Lester B. Pearson was a well-known advocator in the promotion of peace and security during the Suez Crisis in 1956. Canada’s political views were greatly dominated by Great Britain, but in the event of the Suez Crisis, Pearson allowed Canada’s views to undergo a transition that was promoting the interests of Canada and our urge to act on the international scale (Carroll, 2009). Through Pearson’s ability to establish the United Nations Emergency Force to resolve the conflict of the Suez Crisis and earn a Nobel Peace Prize for these initiatives, Canada was taken to the center stage and was officially viewed as a peacekeeper (Carroll, 2009).…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Life Boat Ethics Analysis

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Garrett Hardin, the author of this essay, is trying to explain this topic as survival of the fittest by saying that the wealthier countries and the people that…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jared Diamond espouses the view that the “root of inequality” is the geographical location of a country and the resources it possesses. According to Diamond, all societies in the world were equally wealthy at one time in history. Unfortunately, global environmental changes made some parts of the world to experience harsh weather conditions that made traditional hunting and gathering inefficient in providing food for households. Regions that were geographically disadvantaged were unable to access adequate resources and skills for their development. Diamond uses New Guinea, which is a poor country, and the United States, a wealthy nation, for his analysis.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, he states that he is not bent on his real ideas alone to fix the problem. Therefore, he says if there are any better ideas, that others should do it. He did not refute the opposing claims to leave room for those who may have better ideas than Swift and therefore, he is not so bent on his ideas. The weakness in Swift’s argument is that it does not account for how the people would feel about helping the poor. They may not feel the need to do anything for the poor; such as feeding them or giving them food.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What Makes the World Go Round Professor of Bioethics, Peter Singer, explains in the article “The Singer Solution to World Poverty” that all prosperous people should give all money that is not needed for basic necessities to places that are in need of food and medicine. As an American, I have knowledge this argument would shake up America as a whole. This could create a world of giving up the Capitalistic ways of America and the economic food chain. On the other hand, it could create a world of kindness and less violence. Can you imagine giving up your freedom to help others?…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ch17. The Rise of Industrial America, 1865-1900 ~ By 1900, U.S. leading industrial power by a combination of factors : * Natural Resources (coal, iron ore, copper, lead..) * Labor Supplies (immigrants)…

    • 2908 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The central theme of Carnegie's argument about the Gospel of Wealth is that rich people are superior to all others and should be allowed to use their money to help the less "fit" people. Carnegie believed in Social Darwinism. He believed that the fact that a person was rich showed that he was more fit than others. This meant that the rich man was the one who knew the most about how to prosper in society.…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suppose there was a boat with only ten available spots left, the answer for all three suggestions Hardin suggested is simple. First, allow the extra ten people on board, of course with the most sensible selection of those ten. Then let the others know that you will come back for them, meaning you will try to do your best to think of a solution to help the poor. Next, look for others who would be willing to help get the others out of the water. For example, the wealthy should contribute with shelter, clothing and food for the poor.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Poverty, poor, and overpopulation are becoming major issues in today 's society. As time goes by, it becomes awfully clear that these issues are problems we must deal with. While many want to address and solve these issues, there tends to be a divide on how to do so. There are many papers available concerning this problem. The two I find to have the strongest arguments are actually quite contradicting.…

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dexter Sommerfeldt Dr. Alexander Phil 366 11 December 2015 Vogel on the Refutation of Skepticism In the essay “The Refutation of Skepticism,” we see author Jonathon Vogel attempt to deny any skeptic claims about the external world. In its most simple form, his argument claims that to deny skepticism would be the best explanation of the material world. For slight background information, skepticism is the epistemological view that we simple lack the ability to have knowledge of a material world; the reasoning for this will be described later. First, defining Vogel’s complex argument is a necessity, then I will be providing a critical analysis of his essay as well as provide potential objections.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays