Respect For Autonomy: Ethical Dilemmas In Nursing

Good Essays
a) What are the ethical issues?
This scenario exemplifies an ethical issue where there is an ethical dilemma between respect for autonomy and beneficence and non-maleficence
Respect for Autonomy
Autonomy can be defined as the person right to make an informed decision about the treatment and other decision in regards to their care. In this scenario, the hospitalized patient wants his partner to be involved in his care. Although this decision may have serious consequences ( such as an increased risk of spreading the infection), it is the duty of the nurse to educate patient about the risk and benefits of their decision thereby promoting their autonomy and informed decision making. Nurses need to be sensitive to the decision of their patients even when they feel that it goes against their values, the nurse should explore the culture of the patient in regards to the importance of family/loved ones in order to provide a more culturally congruent care. For example, for this patient the presence of his family member/partner in the room may help him recover faster from this infection or it may help improve his emotional well being, hence, by promoting the client’s choices the nurse is providing culturally congruent care. The concept of autonomy as moral self-evaluation
…show more content…
Leininger’s model for providing a cultural congruent care serves as a guide to nurses in caring and decision making in order to provide a culturally congruent for their clients. There are 3 main components of providing culturally congruent care
Cultural care preservation: Cultural care preservation is integrating the patient’s cultural preference int the plan of care for the patient.
Cultural care repatterning: Cultural care repatterning is a form of culturally congruent care where the nurse works closely with the patient to develop new patterns that may extend beyond the patient’s culture while still respecting their cultural beliefs and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Nurses as important health service providers in the health care system, are required to give care to patients based on ethical values or established standards. Nurses therefore requires ethical knowledge in order to manage situations and give safe and proper care. By using this framework, nurses seek the best way of taking care of patients while respecting values and beliefs, and in the process, establish a therapeutic nurse/client relationship. Nurses also require successful collaborative practices that facilitate better patient outcomes. After exploring the story of the patient Jane Doe(patient X) and her relationships with her healthcare professionals, I now understand that using ethical practices to respect the client’s values and beliefs, and working in a collaborative atmosphere is an important and efficient way to care for a client.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It should be done using a gradual approach especially since the issue is sensitive to the patients. Significantly, it is part of getting to know patients on a personal level and exercising empathy as well. Patients and their families should understand that they are not alone in the medical scenario wherein the health care team will be there to come to their aid. Strategizing on how to communicate this to parties is a skill nurses must learn wherein they are able to form trusting relationships with the family and patient involved. It is the act of showing genuine concern that is most vital to Michael’s condition.…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The next concept, client well-being, is described in this paper as putting the quality of life they wish to have over what you or other professionals view to be appropriate such as tube feedings and respirators. This concept is closely related to client choice as being able to choose and also have quality of life are vital to the patient. Privacy and confidentiality are very important roles for a nurse in this situation. A patient who is discussing their wishes should feel confident that their nurse will not discuss or share this information with others unless it has been discussed and consent is given. Clients are very vulnerable in this time along with their families; they need to trust their nurse.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Contexualism In Nursing

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The second component is identifying the morally relevant facts which include the key players, the newly hired nurse, the senior member of the nursing staff, and the patient. There are also legal and medical implications in this scenario. As the nurse, I would evaluate the ethical problem, by examining the dilemma and knowing what is right for the patient by using the key principle of justice and nonmaleficence (Hood, 2013, p.72). As a nurse, being taught a way that promotes patient safety is always of priority, although having conflict within the workplace could potentially hurt my career. I would then need to identify and analyze the action alternatives and determine if with the path I choose, what could be the potential outcome (Hood, 2013, p.70).…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Moral Model In Nursing

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As a nurse who advocates for the patient, especially for the under insured or uninsured patients, there may be the use of multiple models in order to defend the rights of the patients and ensure he or she gets the desired care. With the use of the Moral Model, a nurse may be able to protect the patients choices and right through the use of the MORAL Model (Guido, 2014) Ethical dilemma In my personal experience practicing nursing, the ethical dilemma I have most experienced is the issue of caring for the under insured or uninsured. The under insured or uninsured patients are most likely to be seen at the hospital as the sickest. They present with chronic illness that has been left untreated too long as a result of lack of access to the health…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One of the ways in promoting autonomy is the informed consent where clients are informed of the procedures to be taken, the risks, the possible outcome and some alternatives where they can either accept or refuse freely. It is also part of their right to be informed and be educated in the care that they will receive as we cater their health needs. As for the minors and mentally-ill patients, it is almost the next of kin who sign the informed consent and in some cases parentalism is being followed where the health professional does the decision making. A problem to be avoided in the observance of patient autonomy is when we nurses assume that the patients has the same values and goals as ours that might lead to wrong conclusions. Secondly, nurses should also aware that every person has different thought processes.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Altruism In Nursing

    • 1355 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For example, a nurse should uphold a bond with the patient by entering a room and knowing the patients history, checking on them frequently, and learning the personality of the patient. By doing this, the patient will feel important and know he or she is in good hands. Saving the life of sick patients also compares to the values of nursing. This compares to the values of nursing because the nurse should have knowledge of what to do in an emergency situation. Having human dignity expresses respect to the patient if the person is facing life or death situations.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nurses can incorporate culturally appropriate assessments and provide healthcare information for ethnic minorities and thus assist in reducing health disparities (Ingram, 2012.) Campinha-Bacote’s theory utilizes the mnemonic device of ASKED, which serves as a reminder on what is required for culturally competent care. It breaks down the process for nurses. It addresses each aspect from the basic of becoming aware of your own cultural biases to possessing the actual desire to be culturally competent. Nurses must be interested in their patient to actively learn and journey to cultural…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is important to work with families to determine safe and appropriate care options that will maintain independence in self-care and work with the patient and family to make the transition to dependency less traumatizing. Orem’s theory provides a good basis for nursing practice and guidance to ensure people are learning to care for themselves yet receive support when they are not able…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The nurse must determine what are her or his cultural beliefs and how do they dictate to the nurse what is normal and what should be done to deal with life situations. This includes an honest look at the nurse’s prejudices and acts of discrimination. Once the problem has been realized, the nurse can work on overcoming it. This is accomplished when the nurse leaves his or her own cultural baggage behind and by learning what culture the patient has to provide support. This leads to the concept of culturally congruent nursing care.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays