Republican Democracy Vs Direct Democracy

Improved Essays
A democracy is defined as a form of government in which the citizens rule. However, within this category, there are two different types of democracy; a republican and a direct. The question is, which form is best? In my opinion, a republican democracy is the best. However, it has problems of its own.

Direct democracies and republican democracies have important similarities and differences.To provide a little background, the direct democracy originated in ancient Athens Greece. It is defined as a form of democracy in which every citizen votes directly on every issue. The republican democracy originated in Rome, Italy and is defined as a democracy is which citizens vote on representatives to vote on legislation for them. First, the two democracies
…show more content…
First, a republican democracy is more open to all types of populations. A republic is not limited by the size of a population, while in a direct democracy, large populations do not work; it costs too much money and too much time. A republican democracy also makes better decisions for society. The jobs of the elected representatives are to study specific issues, and, in theory, this means better decisions are made for the country. In a direct democracy, citizens are not always educated on the issues, and decisions are not always made effectively. A republican democracy is also much more practical; voting occurs less. Direct democracies entail constant voting, which limits time; it is inefficient. Even though a republic is better than a direct democracy, it does not mean it is the correct way of government; there are problems within this that need to be fixed. For example, chosen representatives do not always vote on what is best for everybody, but for their party(democratic or republican) or sponsor influence. Republics do not always allow for citizens to share their opinions, or become as involved as they would in a direct democracy. Many republicans today are very extreme and have no in between. To elaborate, in America, there are normally extreme democratic parties and extreme republican parties. This can cause problems among citizens and also encourage corruption. Lastly, the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    they author is saying that we live in a republic and the definition that was given was a system where people choose representatives who make decisions for them. In the beginning, it stated that we say we live in a democracy but we actually live in a republic. The article states that democracy means the government derives their power from the people and is accountable to them for the use of that power but really, we are a republic. James Madison observed that we were trying to refine and enlarge the public…

    • 1705 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    a country. But what if this cherished belief weren’t true? There are those that argue that a single a single person’s vote cannot make a difference. But are they right? Voting in America can sometimes become a confusing concept. We are not a direct democracy; meaning that a citizen’s vote does not go directly towards the president during an election. Instead, they vote for voting representatives in their state. This system is known as the Electoral College. The founding fathers built the election…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Modes Project: Democracy/ 5 Modes of Democracy Definition: Democracy Democracy simply is “a form of government in which people choose leaders by voting” ,according to Merriam- Webster. However, that simple definition is just the building platform for the many ideas that other philosophers and political thinkers have built on democracy. It is hard to find one sole definition that satisfies each idea of all the philosophers, but there are some common characteristics among most definitions. These include…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays