While one is awake he or she has control over his or her decisions he or she may make throughout each experience, but while dreaming, there is no control in the choices made and the dreamer lacks sense of touch. These signs contradict the second premise that one cannot distinguish between experiences, therefore refuting Descartes’ dream argument. René Descartes was born in France in 1596 to a family of mainly doctors and lawyers. As an adolescent, he obtained a solid background of education in the liberal arts, and later received a degree in civil and canon law. After working on different essays and his methods, he started working on the Meditations on First Philosophy in 1639, and Meditations in its entirety, which is composed of six Meditations, was first published in 1641, and a second edition in 1642 (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Descartes is often …show more content…
And because of this, there is no definite way to distinguish between each of the perceptions. Many other philosophers have studied this premise, including John Locke and Thomas Hobbes. Thomas Hobbes believes that the biggest key to distinguishing a dream from waking consciousness is the “absurdity”. “An absence of absurdity in waking life”, describes how one may realize a perception is a dream through a perception that is extremely abnormal, where he or she is positive that is not occurring in real life (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy). For example, if one dreamt of talking to and spending time with a dead relative, he/she knows that is impossible, or in Hobbes’ mind, is “absurd” and therefore distinguishing the difference between dreaming and being awake. John Locke also objected Descartes second premise by pointing out pain in a dream versus pain in real life. He asked Descartes to analyze this difference, and claims “we cannot have physical pain in dreams as we do in waking life”, therefore undermining the premise that the difference in consciousness is indistinguishable (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy). While Descartes first premise says that experiences in a dream versus reality are generally similar, experiences involve not only abstract perceptions and sensory touch, and the ability to control one’s experiences.