Reforming Immigration For Good Analysis

Improved Essays
I am writing in response to a request from The Shorthorn’s editor stating the opinions of publishing or not publishing Mae M. Ngai’s “Reforming Immigration for Good.” The author claims the government 's approach to protocols regarding control of present immigration are failed ideas. She inflicts emotion to the reader on why illegal immigration will not stop, by stressing the need to give more opportunities and to be “flexible and fair.” I consider the topic at hand appealing to the demographic of international students at UTA, but I do not support her article. Ngai’s writing brings forth ideas of why actions of legalization happen. Her overall reasoning is the loss of money regarding border control, adding on to the true problem but not halting …show more content…
Besides her accomplishments relatability, her manuscript shows it is what she relies on. Ngai also disregards the audience and any other argument that contradicts hers. Having no rebuttal cripples your argument and conveys your claim is ineffective. Ngai seems to be disconnected from the topic of immigration and The Shorthorn readers. She confines in her evidence, conceals her values, and the interest with the topic. In other words, she does not relate to anything in her writing, its transparent, and it executes her entire plea. To conclude this analysis “Reforming Immigration for Good” abandons the right of publication. Ngai’s academic approach is unappealing to the youth of Shorthorn readers, and she rarely grants the article a breath from overused factual evidence. Her weak central claim was backed up by minimal support, and she made no attempt to have common ground amongst other arguments. Nevertheless, she somewhat had an idea that could enlighten new prospective of immigration, her execution was deficient. To truly make her argument solid she would need to distinguish who are her audience, revamp, glamour her

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For my critical thinking assignment, I was asked about the functions and dysfunctions of immigration. I was also asked to tell my family’s root story and to consider how my ancestors arrived in the United States. As well as how other immigrant groups influenced and shaped my family’s past. I will answer the questions about my family to the best of my ability, because of the limited knowledge I have on them.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Enrique’s Journey illustrates a strong argument on the issue of immigration that is cleverly hidden in the binding of the narrative novel. In effect, Sonia Nazario is able to extend her arguments with a higher degree of success by appealing to emotion more so than logic. Her use of pathos significantly outweighs any arguments grounded on logic, therefore she inherently establishes a persuasive text that encourages the audience to avoid objectivity and read the book through a lens of emotion. More so, the humanization of the issue of immigration by establishing empathy with Enrique and the various sub-narratives in the book add to the emphasis placed on creating a persuasive text rather than a balanced and informative nonfiction book. Photography…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aishwarya Nandini Professor Martin ENGL 1301-060 22 October 2016 Rhetorical Analysis After reading and analyzing the article “no, our immigration system is not broken”, it is apparent that the article contains valuable information and is suitable for being published in the UTA student newspaper, The Shorthorn. In this article the author presents an overall argument about the United States Immigration System, talking against the proposed argument that states that the US Immigration System is broken. The author of the text is the Chief Political Correspondent of The Washington Examiner, Byron York. His purpose is to inform the audience of his article, the citizens of the country and the readers of the text, about his own viewpoint on the argument.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I write in contribution to Mae M. Ngai’s topic on “Reforming Immigration for Good” and other clusters on immigration to deepen my argument. The idea of immigration brings up skeptical responses on what happens and needs to happen during migration in the United States. It has not only been an ongoing topic for many decades, but also heavily dismissed recently by the President elect Donald Trump. He highlighted many controversial topics about the Mexican-American border, Mexican natives, and other ethnic backgrounds. For this reason, I whole heartily agree with Ngai’s central claim of adopting a new immigration system, because the system is ineffective, but I further argue to advance immigration our society ought to willingly set aside differences.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    "The Land of Open Graves" is a book written by Jason De León; a professor in Anthropology. The book focusses on reveling the troubling political issue that is facing immigrants when trying to enter United States through Sonoran Desert of Arizona. The author of the book highlights the sufferings that immigrants undergo as the result of implementing the US immigration policy for decades. While drawing insights from four core fields of anthropology, the author is able to articulate his ideas and critiques on the scathing and the gruesome experience that immigrants are always facing, especially in the Desert of Arizona.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Land of Open Graves: Living and Dying on the Migrant Trail by Jason De Leon and Michael Wells displays death and experiences of unpleasant factors of illegal immigrants that happens day-to-day in the Sonoran Desert of Arizona. There are thousands of illegal immigrants that try to venture across the border from Mexico to the United States of America. This book illustrates several fields of anthropology, such as archaeology, forensic science, ethnography, and linguistics. De Leon uses these four significant fields to critique the “Prevention through Deterrence” which is the enforcement policy for the federal border that motivates migrants to pass in areas with severe natural and environmental conditions and carries a high death rate. He also draws on beliefs of cruelty and brutality to assert that there are significant impacts such as wildlife and desert terrain that is involved in immigration law enforcement, and how they die can reflect on their social location.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Undocumented Students

    • 2108 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The sources that I chose put an emphasis on the conversation that I’m trying to portray. The text sources that I’m using are part of a bigger conversation that needs to be heard by everyone. The sources hit main points such as the experiences that undocumented students face when crossing borders and education systems. In addition to the little help that students are receiving. Undocumented students are going through a lot and not many are aware of what going on.…

    • 2108 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mr. Editor, you have requested I analyze the supplied article, “Reforming Immigration for Good” by Mae M. Ngai, and determine if it should be published in The Shorthorn. After reading this article and thoughtfully considering it I can say unequivocally this article would be great to include in the paper. It properly establishes a foundation of information for the reader, exposes immigration for the problem which it is, and proposes a possible solution to the reader. Furthermore Ms. Ngai’s writing style will be easy to digest for college students: she directly articulates an idea with effective and not overly flamboyant speech.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Should immigrants assimilate?”, Alejandro Portes and Min Zhou address the pressure to automatically assimilate that continues to hound second generation immigrants. They weigh the costs of this automatic assimilation and the effects of evident discrimination of a second generation immigrant that follows if assimilation is refused. Mary C. Waters’ article, “Debating Immigration”, acknowledges the inconsistencies of public debate and credible studies dealing with second generation immigrants and their assimilation. Waters’ argument widens the scope of Portes and Zhou’s take on the process of assimilation by providing a positive perspective and hindsight on the topic. Waters takes into account Portes and Zhou’s argument on how a second generation…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration Thesis

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ever since the birth of the United States, one of the largest controversial issues pertaining to the nation has been the debate over immigration control. Whether the influx of individuals derives from Central America or overseas, the issue continues to be discussed due to the significant impact on our society. As time continues to progress, immigrants from the spectrum of the globe continue to step on America’s soil legal or illegal. The propositions made in the United States is not only essential to the growth to the nation, but with the correct provision, can reform the negative connotation attached towards immigration into a beneficial solution. Our current system regarding the reformation towards immigration does not properly support the…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Millions of undocumented immigrants live in the shadows of American society as second-class citizens, hoping every day that they will not get deported. Loosing what has taken them many years to acquire. Many of these immigrants live anxious as they think of the possibility of being separated from their families at any given time. Millions of these immigrants have lived in the United States for many years, and many have children born in this country. There are those who have lived in the U.S. for so long, that they consider themselves part of this country.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration Beyond Ellis Island Kazi I. Hossain Kazi Hossain is a professor in the Education department at Millersville University, Millersville, PA. The major focus of the text is that teaching aimed at developing an appropriate awareness of the immigration process is essential in K-12. The reading was assigned to give us an updated discussion on immigration, one that centers on the legal process and experiences of a modern day American immigrant. The text was a good source of immigration policy, however, my highschool did spend a considerable amount of time teaching and making us discuss modern immigration policy and issues.…

    • 1571 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In reading the article Reforming Immigration for Good written by Mae M. Ngai, I am interpreting this article in response to the editor if it should be published in The Shorthorn. Her position regarding immigration will most likely impact The Shorthorn readers because many UT Arlington students are immigrants or may have experienced a similar situation. Others might say who cares about immigration when in fact immigration laws have become a “top domestic priority” (Obama). Immigration has pointed towards disputes with major ethnic groups in the U.S. Ngai argues about our current immigration system which she claims is not practical, meaning she supports changing the immigration law.…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is the author’s main argument or position? (5 marks) The author is of the view that although immigration has several advantages, however, the immigration system needs to be reformed. The premises he uses to support his conclusion are that, the immigrants, who came under the old immigration policy system are not as successful as local Canadians because they are not young enough, their credentials are not recognized in Canada, their language skills are lack luster and in some cases they are not adaptable.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, each year, the U.S. government only issues 65,000 new H-1B visa, which is a small portion of the total number of applicants who apply. In recent years, “USCIS instituted a “lottery” system for accepting applications because more than 65,000 regular H-1Bs were received on the first possible day of filing”. This process is entirely random, and any qualified international student can be turned down because of mere chance. The fact that the number of applicants far exceeds the number of visas filed means that each year, the majority of qualified applicants are rejected. Some will continue giving their effort in applying, and others will leave the U.S. to work elsewhere (“Beyond”).…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays