Reflection Between Crime Control And Due Process

Great Essays
On Friday the 7th of August, I attended the Roma Street District and Supreme Court. I attended court for just over three hours and observed three various criminal cases. This essay will detail the proceedings of these cases and analyse them in terms of which model, due process or crime control, the cases presented as. Using the academic literature available I will detail the cases and how they were conducted as well as a brief over view of both models reflected. After reviewing these cases alongside the scholarly sources I have decided that both crime control and due process methods were present at the time of my observations.
Court Details
I observed at court three separate cases, kidnapping, police brutality and property damage/arson. All
…show more content…
L. Packer as early as 1968. He stated that the Crime Control Model relies on a presumption of guilt during the later stages of the court process. A heavy dependence is placed on finding factual evidence through police and witnesses at early stages of the model in which they can then ‘weed out’ any innocent persons. It operates under an oath of efficiency and accuracy.
Unlike the Crime Control Model, Due Process lacks faith in the reliability of evidence gathered in the early stages of investigations and places more stock in the information found during the adjudication process. The Due Process Model also distinguishes between the factually guilty and the legally guilty whereas the Crime Control Model does not (Marmo et al, 2012, 397). In summary, Crime Control is concerned with the apprehension and prevention of criminals and wrong-doers. Whilst Due Process also retains this belief to an extent its focus is on ensuring that crime is controlled in a way that the citizens are not subject to the abuse of power by the state. Many different things separate these two models, however, these are the main points that need to be made for the point of this
…show more content…
The Crime Control Model is also used but sparingly and only at times in which factual guilt is already presumed. On the date that I observed court the Due Process model was clearly present within two cases. I acknowledge that there is a need for both models within our criminal justice system but believe that Due Process is the fairer and more effective way of dealing with

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Introduction On the Wednesday the 5th of August 2015, I attended the Brisbane District Court for approximately 3 hours. This essay outlines on the observations that where made that day and critically reviews the components of crime control and the due process models, which these findings represent. I will then go on to draw upon my observations guided by academic literature, which will provide an overview of both models. This essay however will dispute that the governing model for what I observed on the 5th of August at the courts was both the due process and crime control models of the criminal justice system. The Observed Court Hearings On Wednesday the 5th of August 2015, I attended the Brisbane District Court, in which I…

    • 1593 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, there must be a legal basis for the appeal such as alleged material error in the trial, despite not because the losing party did not agree with the verdict. If the defendant was convicted through the plea bargain then the right of appealing is demolished. Any convicted offenders are able to appeal their case based on the matter of law. When there is an appeal, the court reviews the case looking at the previous proceedings in the lower courts and will not consider new evidence. The appellate courts look at the record and the written briefs filed by the defendant and the prosecutor of the appeal.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The crime control model tends to focus on the conviction and punishment of criminals; while the due process model takes a more liberal approach and focuses on the protection of the individual and their rights. The criminal justice system currently and should use aspects of each model so that things are kept effective and efficient so that the system treats both the victim and the defendant fairly. If the criminal justice system focused predominantly on the crime control model it may allow for police technologies to be implemented which by themselves might cause less crime but can also create concrete evidence to…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Profiling Ryberg

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The normative foundation is based on the idea that the costs associated with racial profiling will outweigh the benefits of apprehending more criminals. This is in conjunction with the legal restrictions that are placed on police departments such as a prohibition on racial discrimination and so forth. In addition, the use of police profiling is fought on the basis of majority/minority dynamics. The author asserts that when a focus of the police is directed at a certain minority group, the majority tends to view the minority group as criminals. The author’s overall argument is that “the apprehension of more criminals may not constitute a reason in favor of racial profiling at all (Ryberg, 79).…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: Offender profiling can be defined as making predictions about offender’s characteristics from the way they behaved during a crime (Davies & Beech, 2012). Offender profiling can play an important part in criminal investigations, especially when there is no DNA left at crime scenes. It requires using other types of evidence such as characteristics of the crime scene and eye-witness testimonies from victims and witnesses. Profiling techniques can be unified with police forces to help elicit and prioritise suspects and may predict what an offender may do next (Canter & Youngs, 2009). However, it’s important to assess the reliability of such psychological procedures as they are frequently applied to serious and violent forms of crime…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This keeps the overseer of the lineup from giving coincidental or deliberate verbal or nonverbal signs to impact the witness to pick the suspect and reduces the effect of bias. These procedural changes are to enhance the accuracy of eyewitness distinguishing proof and identification among suspects. These changes have been acknowledged by the police and criminal investigations show that because of the decline of witness errors. In the ted talk “Why eyewitnesses get it wrong” by Scott Fraser, he proposes that criminal investigations need to utilize scientific research to find proof as opposed to using the eyewitness report alone to help maintain wrongful convictions. Fraser also suggests combining science with the law system to shape a more logical law system and that every one of us should be mindful excessively trust in our memories.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Criminal profiling refers to a tool implemented in analytical psychology. Just like any other scientific tool, criminal profiling has its disadvantages. The disadvantages influence the validity, reliability, and utility of the technique, making it to be classified as a tool rather than science. For one to be conversant with the validity, reliability, and usefulness of this tool, understanding its definition is crucial. Criminal profiling refers to the procedure of categorizing personality mannerisms, behavior inclinations, and demographic variables of a criminal basing on the characteristics of the crime (Bartol & Bartol, 2012).…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Burden Of Proof Analysis

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This is because ADR procedure helps in reaching a resolution earlier and less in expenses than going to a court or traditional litigation. In fact, many courts suggested or required parties to carry out ADR process before going to trial. However, ADR also has their own disadvantages as this process depends on the willingness of the individuals to compromise. If one of the party is not willing to compromise, this process will resulted in not achieving any resolution. In my opinion, even there are a few disadvantages of the ADR process, I strongly believed that courts is not the only best way in resolving a dispute as there are many other option which is more effective and the results can bring more satisfaction to both parties such as ADR.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This happen because between these two fields there are not many differences, on the other hand there is more similarities then people think. The only differences between these two fields are: Criminal Justice is more related with crime control and how is punished. That is why Criminal Justice focuses more in policing, corrections and criminal courts. The main purpose of Criminal Justice is to prevent crime and apply the law to whoever broke the law (Criminal Justice 2013). On the other hand, criminology focuses more in the behavioral and social science that explores the origins of criminal behavior and the social response to crime.…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rights In Criminal Cases

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The court further stated that were they to strictly apply the fresh period in Neypes and make it applicable only to civil cases, they would foster an absurd situation where a litigant in a civil case has stronger rights than an accused in a criminal case, giving undue favor to civil litigant and against an accused. Criminal cases are differing from civil cases. At the beginning of a federal criminal case, the principal actor is the U.S. Attorney and the grand jury. There is this thing called U.S. Attorney represents the United States in the most court proceedings, including all criminal prosecutions. In criminal trial, the burden of the poof is on the government.…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays