The Narrative Constitution Of American Citizenship In Collective Memory By Shoon Lio

Improved Essays
In “Redeeming America: The Narrative Constitution of American Citizenship in Collective Memory,” Shoon Lio explores the constant revision of history utilized by Americans to position movements and events as redemption narratives of society. While not exclusive to Americans, collective action groups aim to define the talking points of historical events, shifting public perception to favor ulterior motives by shining the talking points as parables. Ch.2, “Whose Collective Memories? The Social Construction of Moral Boundaries and Social Problem Claims,” examines how the memories of these revisions are exploited as evidence to justify acts of war, violence, and social engineering. These acts by groups are to help further cause for wars, combat violence, and position perceived past moral failings to teach future generations of previous “ills” of society like the counterculture and the Great Society movements and measures in the 1960’s that Conservative members criticized. Many of these stories are repurposed with the aid of the mass media in conjunction with politicians. Obviously, politicians and journalists have a pulpit from which to expound their spin on stories and help contextualize them to a greater story weave. Examples of this include Newt Gingrich’s use of decrying …show more content…
He usually reserves just a paragraph to describe and cite an example and proceed to add its context to the overall main point. Rather than focusing on a few examples in the chapter and examining them fully, Lio illustrates some examples and then turns to a study of sociological processes and phenomena that describe these actions. The paper tends to drift off towards the end of the chapter as it gets bogged down into the minutiae of sociological phenomena and characteristics and defines many of these complex terms in relation to the previous

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Gross Paper When history is read, it is read from the viewpoints from those at the top: the politicians, the kings, the influential. Robert A. Gross instead gives the reader a view “ from the bottom up” in his book, The Minutemen and Their World. Gross exhibits how the people of Concord saw the American Revolution and in doing so enhances our understanding of it by letting the reader see the common person’s view. Concord is known as the location of “the shot heard around the world” and non-historians would believe Concord to be in favor of the revolution since the beginning, but Concord was still loyal to the crown until nearly the eve of the war.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Professor Glenn Moots’ article pertaining to the American Revolution, the author both summarizes and analyzes the 2013 symposium where scholars gathered to debate the justifications of the war. The analyses, which he provides from multiple perspectives, address question of jus in bello and jus ad bellum, helping to determine whether the events of the Revolution were defendable. By referring to specific events and reflecting on fellow scholars’ contrasting opinions, Moots concludes that proper warfare conduct is vital and encourages scholars to reevaluate their outlook on the American Revolution. The body of the article contains sufficient evidence for the author’s call to action in his conclusion.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the book, “American Citizenship: the Quest for Inclusion,” by Judith N. Shklar, Shklar places emphasis on the fact that America was founded upon the principles of freedom and equality, yet excluded various groups of people based on economic status, gender, race and religion, and many people were enslaved. Shklar recounts the circumstances these people endured in order to gain citizenship, economic independence and ultimately the right to vote. Born to Jewish parents in Latvia, Shklar immigrated to the US when she was 13. She went on to attend McGill University and Harvard University and later became a professor and political theorist. Shklar provides a unique perspective on citizenship because she, like many other Americans, faced challenges…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s presentation Bree Newsome discussed the symbolic meaning behind the removal of the Confederate Flag from the grounds of the South Carolina State Capitol. The Confederate Flag, has long been a sign of differential citizenship. James Holston presents to us the necessity of insurgency as a tool of marginalized citizens as they strive for equity of citizenship. The removal of the flag from the grounds of the capitol was a demonstration of insurgency against the government’s clear support of symbolic discrimination against black Americans. T.H. Marshall discussed the ways in which people are disenfranchised through a systemic form of discrimination that strips them of their rights.…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Oftentimes as Americans we tend to exclude certain parts of our history because we either do not agree with them, or because we are embarrassed by them. Examples being, the exaggerations of the Alamo, the Jim Crowe Laws, and the discrimination Japanese immigrants faced during World War II. Our culture now often prefers to hide its past rather than learn from it, which is a tragedy. Instead of teaching of our mistakes and what we can do to prevent them from ever happening, many believe that it is more ‘American’ to hide our past and pretend as though we have never had our share of mistakes and defeat. Ignoring our defeats and mistakes can have large repercussions in the future.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    America is a story that questions the lies and omissions told, primarily by educational institutions, and political organizations, but also Saul Alinsky, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and other progressives, to ultimately break down America and everything it stands for. D’souza’s main point in this book Is that universities in recent decades have been run by left-wing intellectuals who have shaped most of the young minds of our day and age. The outcome is younger generations of Americans who don’t have the same fervor or patriotism that young people may have had in say, the 40’s or 50’s. D’souza analyzes the main accusations that the leftists have conjured up against our history and one underlying theme remains: thievery. D’souza refutes each…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To begin, let’s remember back, let’s search our reminiscings, our memories, for traces of a scenario in which the tree of liberty to which Americans shed their blood, sweat, and tears was still fledgling, when its branches were in the beginnings of flourishes than would grow to shade and shelter the world. A time when life was synonymous with oppression and the struggle to lift free of that dread shadow that stretched from across a wide, wide ocean was more than threats and news stories, more than sporadic strikes. When red was for red coats, more than a color on our star-spangled banner, before we had a star-spangled banner. Remember—no, imagine—that, because that’s all most can do. Because it’s not the most that give their futures to the few, it’s the few that give their futures to the most.…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What does it mean to be American? Through understanding America’s past and present domestic and foreign policies and actions, it would be too easy to analyze the ways in which Americans tend to be too aggressive, selfish, hypocritical, or uncaring. However, Americans also seem to tend to be hopeful and idealistic demonstrated in the rights listed in The Declaration of Independence, and I am an American. While I do not want to encourage any nationalistic or egocentric dispositions, I also want to hold the American people, myself included, to the high ideals set by our founding government. Americans have the responsibility to uphold the human rights to life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness through historical understanding and empathy as described in Michelle Alexander’s…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Manjoo describes our particular moment in history by saying that our society is biased and blind to truth depending on our political standing. The events that were described in chapter one were made possible because people were willing to believe Kerry’s misrepresentation of his service during Vietnam. The people that were wiling to over look the evidence that proved Kerry’s account of Vietnam was false were the majority of democrats. But the majority of the republicans were skeptical of his account from the beginning. Manjoo describes this bias as an addiction to ones preferred spin of the truth.…

    • 98 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Jackson And Greed

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This paper was written about a soldier in the 1830s who wanted to share his accord as to how Americans’ are only educated on the good of their country and not necessarily the bad. He believes that America has done an injustice to these Native Americans,’ the Cherokees to be exact. Telling us how by recalling his memories to express the significance of greed, the treatment of Native Americans,’ and how he and others were complacent. Let’s start off with the overall problem in the story, greed, because without it. None of these incidents would have ever taken place.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was like any other school day, coming back from lunch, sitting in class, and talking to friends; however, it all changed once I arrived in my American Studies class. Mrs. Forbs was standing in front of the class waiting for everyone to quiet down. The class was a bunch of sixth graders, so it took a while to make us be silent. The day felt weird for me, I had my same robotic schedule but for some reason something didn’t feel right. I thought it had something to do with the food I ate for lunch, I would be prepared to head down to the bathroom or even nurse if that was the case; however, what happened that day no sixth grader would be able to prepare for.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion, America has been through great triumphs and failures. There have been countless amounts of times when people have felt as though they were subjected to abuse and misconduct regarding their rights causing uproar. Carroll best states through her journey of writing and discussing radicals of New York that archives hold the key for change in history, “… importance of documenting history of community activist… [they] have important stories to tell about social change in the United States (pg…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So carefully, after waiting until I knew Ma wasn’t going to wake up, I crept outside into the winter air that was as cold yet placid, and began to walk to the harbor. Walking along the main street that lead straight to where the Sons of Liberty, and my Pa, were gathering before going to the harbor. The location was unknown to anyone outside of the Sons of Liberty, but Pa had spoken to a fellow Son of Liberty and I just happened to hear every word, including the location of the meeting. It wasn’t until I spotted a redcoat when I realized that the redcoats would for sure get me in trouble me if they spotted me past the 10:00 pm curfew.…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the video “Political Culture,” Thomas Patterson describes the origins and distinctiveness of American’s political ideals, illustrates the acceptance of these ideas by future generations (and challenges they pose), and provides examples of how these ideals affect today’s politics. When colonists questioned Britain’s authority over their public and private lives, the American Revolution was initiated and later ended with the colonies being freed from British rule. As a result, the colonies developed an important set of ideas such as the right of freedom, liberty, rights, and justice. These ideas, compiled in one writing known as the American Creed, was embraced by succeeding generations. Subsequently, rights were expanded to include minorities…

    • 143 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What world I would like to live in is a question before this course that I had not spent much time pondering. The pre-test that was taken at the beginning of the course really reflects what my narrative was before taking the course. From the beginning I knew I wanted to live in a world where countries worked together regardless of difference. Nearing the end of the course this idea has not changed, but it has evolved with me throughout the course. Many of the ideas of the continuing revolution contributed to what is now my new narrative.…

    • 1938 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays